“vaffanculo” would be the predictable answer a Frenchman would get if he demanded from an Italian reparation payments for the slaughter that the Roman legions unleashed in Gaul and for the countless human beings that were enslaved by the Romans in Gaul.
The answer which translates to “kiss my a**” is rude but it is also perfectly justified and I hope it becomes clear why that is.
One doesn’t necessarily have to use that kind of language but the reparation payments for slavery that the city of Boston is considering should be rejected equally vehemently.
One could make a case that post-WWII Germany or modern Turkey should pay reparations for the holocaust and the Armenian genocide because these crimes happened in the name of these states and because as legal successors to the 3rd Reich and the Ottoman empire both countries should assume to some extent legal obligations of their predecessors.
Other than that reparations are unjust and evil when they have to be payed by people who have done nothing wrong.
If we were to be punished for the sins of our ancestors we ALL would be screwed.
I don’t care who you are. If you go back in time far enough you will find amongst your ancestors someone who did some horrible things to other humans.
You will find pirates, murderers, thieves, rapists, slave owners and persons who are guilty of too many crimes to mention here.
However, if you go back in time far enough you will also find ancestors of yours who were victims of some horrible, horrible crimes.
Forcing people to pay for crimes they never committed to people who were never victims of these crimes is deeply unjust to begin with but for the reasons mentioned above it is also totally impractical.
Everyone would be entitled to reparations and everyone would also have to pay reparations.
Everything written so far is made worse by the Left’s collectivism because it views people not as individuals but as parts of a collective, which is the reason why the Left calls for collective punishment.
Yes, the reparations the Left is calling for are nothing but yet another form of collective punishment.
You would be punished not even for the crimes of your ancestors but simply for being a part of a collective.
The problem with collectives is that every human being is not just part of ONE collective but of an unlimited number of collectives.
One could always pick the one collective that suits one’s own plans.
If a person who happens to be a woman and who lives in Armenia wanted to get money from a fellow Armenian who happens to be a man all she would have to do is to say that the person she wants money from is not only an Armenian but also a man and that because of that he should pay for all the wrongs that men had ever done to women.
The poor fellow would have to pay simply for being a member of the collective called men despite the fact that Armenians treat their women very differently than, say, North African men who were allowed to have up to four wifes and an unlimited number of concubines.
If there was a game called reparations roulette with the ball landing not on a number but on a country or a collective of any kind I would virtually always win.
You are from Zimbabwe and I’m an Italian? You owe me because the pharaohs enslaved the Hebrews, a Mediterranean people.
Doesn’t matter that the Egyptians never enslaved Italians. The Egyptans, like you, were Africans and you as an African owe me, one of the Mediterranean people, reparations.
You are an Indonesian and I live in Sweden? You owe me because the Ottomans colonized, enslaved and oppressed southeast Europe and robbed boys to turn them into fanatical warriors, Janissaries, who would fight their own parents.
Doesn’t matter that Indonesians never colonized Sweden. The Ottomans were Muslims and you as a Muslim owe me, a European, reparations.
You are an african-American and I’m an Austrian? You owe me because North African pirates plundered the coasts of southern Europe and enslaved their populations.
Doesn’t matter that North Africans never raided Austria. The pirates were Africans and you as an African owe me, a European, reparations.
Now, I can hear you, my black brothers and sisters in humanity say: “We had nothing to do with that. We were in America.”
That’s exactly the point.
Neither had Irish, Italians and Jews who immigrated to America at the beginn of the 20th century anything to do with slavery in North America.
Lastly, some words about the unDemocrats aka the “Democrat party” who are calling for reparations.
At the beginning of the American civil war only 10% of families had slaves.
This party which portraits itself as the the champion of “the little guy” had poor southern boys die on the bloody battlefields of the civil war, defending the interests of rich plantation owners.
Today the very same party wants the little guy to pay again for the sins of the rich and it imports a new generation of quasi slaves, illegal aliens.
While big corporations are reaping the profits of dirt cheap labour the little guy is screwed again by the unDemocrats because it is the little guy who has to pay for the illegal aliens’ housing, medical care, schooling etc.
The unDemocrats (with the support of globalist RINO Republicans) are still the party of slavery.