
It was not even om my radar. But as many times before birding is full of surprises. Yesterday I got a call from Ragnar Smith, who has moved to the Faroes in 2025. He had found a potential Short-billed Gull at Miðvágur. I was rather sceptical, but when I got some Back-Of-Camera shots I got excited. I forwarded the pictures to Killian Mullarney. He replied in his typical cautious way, but ended with saying: “If I were you, I’d go for it! 🙂
So I drove to Miðvágur one hour before sunset, but the bird was gone. Today I tried again, and this time the bird was easily relocated on the beach at Miðvágur. What a relief and what a bird! First for the Faroes and second for the western Palearctic. And not a bird I have had on my rader!
Ragnar was kind enough to write about the discovery:
After several days of brutal northerlies and storm, me and another Faroese birdwatcher, Bartal, decided to spend 3rd January and 4th January checking harbours and coastal areas. Target species were Spectacled Eider, Ross’s Gull and maybe a wintering Baltimore Oriole, inspired by our “brothers” to the north in Iceland, though we would be satisfied with finding a Brünnich’s Guillemot or even an confiding Little Auk.
3rd of January was spent on Eysturoy, where we checked different harbours and lakes, which yielded three Iceland Gulls and a Lesser Scaup female, the same one Silas Olofson found some time before at Viðareiði. Not bad birds accounting for the periodic snow storms and the constant 14-16 m/s from north. While we drove around in the storm, we talked about what rarities we would love to find, and I had a brief monologue about the Common Gull species-complex, how he should read “Identification of the Larus canus complex” by Peter Adrians and Chris Gibbins, and how all gulls with long pale tongues in the outer primaries, should be documented and checked, as those features are good indications that it might be something rare.

Should be said, since I moved back to Faroe Islands in September 2025, I have spent a lot of time and energy checking gulls, especially Common Gulls. It has resulted in hundreds of common gulls photographed and thousands of photos taken, combined with several hours reading the aforementioned article and studying photos, both my own and others. Thankfully Common Gulls are a lot scarcer than in Denmark for example, which makes it more manageable to go through the ones that are up here, but I honestly didn’t expect to succeed.
On 4th January we went to Vágar, starting at Sørvágar, where we agreed to split up. He checked the gardens, while I started scanning the gulls. It yielded an Iceland Gull 3cy, while Bartal found a Bullfinch, a scarcity up here. Next stop was Miðvági, where we parked down by the beach, and immediately we saw good numbers of gulls roosting. We repeated the same strategy as before, so I walked to the breakwater and started scanning. While herring gulls dominated, I picked up three Common Gulls standing together and one of them stood out.
Even 100 meters away and in the binos it stood out from the two other common gulls. It was slightly darker on the upperparts, seemed small-headed and a much darker head and chest. I took some quick snapshots, adjusted the camera and started slowly getting closer. I called Bartal and asked where he was and if wanted to maybe see a possible “American common gull”, he said maybe, if I got it id’d (Should be said that he misunderstood me, concerning which species I meant, and I had “cried wolf” a few times concerning gulls, so it is fair enough that he didn’t immediately start running). I slowly got closer, and closer, while I took more photos, hoping that it would fly around a bit, so I could get some photos of the primaries. While standing much closer to the gull, I could see a unbanded bill, that the hood was concentrated in the neck ala Caspian Gull 1cy, that the pattern was a densely vermiculated and mottled brown pattern, that extended down the side of the chest and met at the front, while slightly extending on the flanks, and the palest part of the head of the gull was around the bill, on the forehead and on the throat, creating a somewhat unique impression of an isolated white throat.

When I was 10 meters away, it took off and I blindly fired a small series of photos, while following it towards east and over the harbour area. I took a quick look at the flight photos, and to say was shocked is the understatement of the century! Primaries where the black extended down to P5, long, grey tongues on the inner web of the primaries and large, white tongue-tips from P8-P5! The adrenaline started surging and I started jogging in the snow towards the car, sweating my boiler suit and mumbling expletives in Faroese, danish and English. While in the car, I wrote in the Faroese birding messenger, that I had a potential Short-billed Gull, 2nd record for WP, and that Bartal should return to the car. When he sat in the car, we skimmed the article, while looking at the photos on the camera and at a quick glans, it looked like a slam-dunk! Silas called and I told him I had a 95% sure Short-billed Gull, my reluctance based in the fact that it is quite the rarity and for obvious reasons I had zero experience with the Common Gull-complex outside of ssp. canus. He asked if he could refer my BOC shots to Killian Mullarney and from there it was just a waiting game. Meanwhile me and Bartal started walking down the coastline towards the neighbouring village to look for the gull, either to see if it might have taken refuge on the cliffs or on a different beach.
Silas called some time after and said that Killian had given a tentatively positive response, that it looked very promising, and that he would attempt to twitch before sunset. We continued walking around the cove, but we didn’t find it again. Even with what I had seen in the field and the positive response from Killian, I was quite anxious to look at the photos at home. Returning, I immediately started checking the photos in conjunction with the article.
I will try to list the features that point towards Short-billed Gull:
- Slightly darker grey upperparts akin to the difference between Herring Gull ssp. argenteus and ssp. argentatus
- A smaller looking head, almost pigeon-like
- Absent band on the bill
- The hood is concentrated in the akin to Caspian Gull 1cy, extending down the necksides, out on the breast, creating a continuous breastband. The pattern is a brown, mottled pattern, that also extends slightly onto the flanks.
- P10: Grey tongue that extends 1/3 down from the the PC (primary coverts).
- P9: tongues reaches aprox ½ down the inner web, white apical spot is equal in size toe the black tip, the black on the outer web doesn’t reach all the way to the PC.
- P8: Black on the outer web ½-1/3 from PC, grey tongue reaches more than ½ down and has a bright, white tongue-tip
- P7: Bright, white tongue-tip and the black reaches ½ op towards the PC.
- P6: Black on the outer web reaches 1/3 up towards the PC.
- P5: Large, symmetrical (W-shaped) black spot.
- P4: On some photos a small spot is visible on the inner web.
And following the identification key in the article for adult common gulls, it goes B4b B4b2 B4b2b2 brachyrhynchus.


After sitting at the computer rereading the same article ten times to be sure that I am fully comprehending it and triple-checking my photos 50 times to be sure that I am interpreting them correctly, it was slowly dawning on me that it was an actual, proper Short-billed Gull I had found and euphoria took over! To find a mega of this caliber is absurd, but to find one that I had actively been searching for is quite the trophy and validation of all the time and effort in field that has been spent, and thankfully everyone who twitched on the Faroe Islands, got to see it today (5/1). Now we will see what the rest of 2026 brings.
Writer: Ragnar Smith
Photos: Silas Olofson



































































































































































































































