Peng Shepherd (2022)
(Not a review, just some notes to help me remember the things I've read. But written this way because it's the Internet, and some people will stumble across this page.)
This book was a Pandemic Book Club selection.
The meeting was last night, according to when this was posted, but I wrote this yesterday, so the meeting hasn't happened yet. I might include an update.
The book starts with the murder of a prestigious reseracher at the Central Branch of the New York Public Library. His estranged daughter, Nell, who used to work with him, is called to the library by the cops and her former coworker. A mystery three decades old starts to unravel at this point and it centers on a old, seemingly worthless, road map that Nell found in what is referred to as "the Junk Box incident."
She was fired for arguing with her father when he was in fact her boss. He coworker Felix, a fellow intern, was fired at the same time. Swann, a kindly uncle-type figure, had always looked out for her and had hoped that she'd be able to come back.
Nell and Felix are both cartographers. Felix ends up working with maps for a big company, while Nell winds up creating fake relicas of old maps (with dragons and sea sprites added) in a cramped office in Crown Heights, Brooklyn.
Nell follows what clues (and what maps) she has to figure out this mystery, and as she does, she learns about this mysterious group, the Cartographers, that's something of a legend in map-collecting circles. Mild spoiler: they were her parents and five friends from school. They were all together on the day her mother died and Nell suffered burns in a fire in a cabin in upstate New York when Nell was three years old.
Each time she meets one of them, we get a little more of the background of what happened back in those days related to her. And every time, when learn that there were more secrets among the group other than the biggest secret: Agloe, a phantom settlement that only appears if you have the correct map. And it was only on one map. And every copy of that map is missing, stolen by collectors.
It turns out that someone out there would kill for that map. And then have a secret way into and out of the library and other places as well.
Edit: I'll put this here because it seems like a good place. Overall, everyone in the book club seemed to enjoy the book overall, but everyone also had a problem with the ending and with the motives of the villain -- and everyone else's, really, when you get down to it.
End of edit
I enjoyed this book, and I wasn't overly happy with the ending, but I rolled with it. Likewise, when police and murder are involved but there's a fantastical element at work, there's a bit of disbelief suspension at work.
But there was one thing that I did have to call out: for how well researched this book is -- Agloe in particular was a real place at one particular time because of a phantom settlement on a map -- there was a glaring error that someone should have caught. They flee from police and he up to the town through the Lincoln Tunnel and then spend hours on I-95.
I-95 does NOT go to upstate New York! They were on that highway for maybe 20 minutes, unless they secret went through New England.
Now, this should be a quibble. If the author had invented, say, State Road 145, I wouldn't have thought twice about it. But not only is I-95 a major thoroughfare -- BUT THIS IS A BOOK ABOUT MAPS!! How do you get something like this wrong? Especially when they're using a road map!
That aside, I enjoyed the book unfolding. I didn't think the stakes were high enough for some of the reactions the characters had or the actions that they took, but by the end, things were explained to not be as they seemed. Still that ending.
Second edit: One of the group members complained about one character morphing into a Bond villain.
I enjoyed this book, and now that the audiobook became available, I might listen to it for the next couple weeks.
If you stumbled across my page via the Internet, please check out my short book series, Burke Lore Briefs. A fantastical foursome of flash fiction and short stories.
