I'll level with y'all. I commissioned this piece to be written when Lorwyn Eclipsed was still being spoiled, anticipating a few new kithkin commander options.
Turns out, we got 1 new commander, bringing us to a paltry total of three for the game's hobbit knock-offs. Oh well, more than we had before, right?
Have you ever dabbled with kithkin in commander? Did they deserve another new legend? Let us know, and check out our ranking of all kithkin commanders in MTG:
Look, I know what I'm signing up for by going on the internet and calling some of the most popular commanders in EDH overrated. I lay in the bed I make.
But as a reminder, "overrated" does not mean "bad". Just because I think people are jamming Atraxa a bit too often in 2026 doesn't mean Atraxa won't kill you in a few attacks.
Are there any commanders you think are overrated? How about underrated? Let us know, and check out my ranking of the most overrated/overplayed commanders in casual EDH:
Lutri was banned the day it was spoiled in 2020. 6 years later, you can finally run it in your Commander deck (but not as a companion).
