
The No. 5 is one of those items where collectors know it exists, but nobody seems to know much about them. This may be because this wasn’t advertised as an office stapler in newspapers, available for sale by office suppliers, or written about in the office-related publications of the day. It was, in fact, made originally for book binding companies or companies with similar needs. You’ll see this mentioned in publications such as The American Bookmaker, The Inland Printer, and various Type Foundry Price Lists.
This fastener was designed and patented by William J. Brown Jr. who formed the Wire Staple Co and ultimately the Acme Staple Co in 1894.
The No. 5 was first advertised in 1886, the year it was released. It was made by the Wire Staple Co of Philadelphia. It was ultimately made in two versions, with the main visual difference between them a series of holes along the ridge for version 1 and with a solid ridge in version 2.

Brown’s No. 5 Breech Loader Binder version 1, missing paper stay and staple push

paper stay and staple push highlighted in yellow in the above picture
Version 1 measures 6.25 inches long by 1.625 inches wide by 8.25 inches tall and weighs 1 pound 13 ounces. It is made of cast iron and steel. This version was available until approximately 1890. It was manufactured by the Wire Staple Company at least until 1890 and possibly up until 1898.

1886 magazine ad

1888 magazine ad
Sometime between 1888 and 1899 Samuel J. Yarger started manufacturing and distributing the No. 5. Yarger began advertising this model in 1899 and it was available at least until 1912 (note 1). On many of the stapling machines of this period you’ll find a small one-inch oval brass plate attached with “S.J. YARGER PHILADELPHA” embossed on it.

It’s unknown what the relationship was between Brown and Yarger. However, once Yarger began manufacturing this, and other, staplers in this line the Wire Staple Co was no longer mentioned. It is worth noting however, that this was shown as the “Brown Breech-Loader” throughout its availability.
After several short years, the design of the No. 5 was changed by the Wire Staple Co to a version with a solid ridge. Once Yarger started manufacturing these they stayed with this design.
Version 2 of this stapler measures 6.25 inches long by 1.625 inches wide by 8.5 inches tall and weighs 2 pounds. Like the previous version, this is made of cast iron and steel. There were a few other minor changes, but these didn’t change its functionality nor did it have any obvious improvements. But many parts from versions 1 and 2 are not interchangeable.

1894 catalog ad

1906 catalog ad

1912 catalog ad

example of staples

Samuel J. Yarger, 1909
Samuel J. Yarger was described in 1909 as a “man of massive build”, “a conspicuous figure in any assemblage”, and a “man among men”. Born in 1837, he joined the Union Army during the American Civil War and was active in politics. Yarger was originally trained to be a paper hanger and worked decades in the field of paper hanging and wall-paper before eventually going into the manufacture of wire staple machines.
Patent and Other Information:
- Patent 369916 Machine for Inserting and Clinching Metallic Staples (filed 10/13/1885, granted 09/13/1887
Notes:
- The Early Office Museum site mentions that the No. 5 was advertised until 1923. It also states that Acme Staple Co introduced this model into its lineup as the Model No. 4. However, after extensive searching I cannot find any evidence of either of these statements. That doesn’t mean that they aren’t true, just unverifiable at this time.
- Wire Staple Co, (1886, March), advertisement, The Inland Printer, page 357
- Wire Staple Co, (1888, February), advertisement, Printer’s Circular
- Chicago Type Foundry Price List, (1890), Chicago, IL, page 145
- John Ryan Foundry, (1894, September), Latest and Standard Faces in Type, page 434
- American Type Founders, (1906), American Line Type Book, page 1099
- Sam Hudson, (1909), Pennsylvania and It’s Public Men, Hudson & Joseph
- Frank A. Weeks Mfg Co Catalog, (1912), New York, NY, page 77
Help support the American Stationer. The site really needs your help in order to stay alive. Please become a supporting patron by subscribing to our Patreon at www.patreon.com/americanstationer.
Visit me at https://www.facebook.com/groups/americanstationer and let’s get all nerdy about office stuff 🙂
If you enjoy the American Stationer consider purchasing one of my books at Amazon.
- STAPLERS, STAPLING MACHINES, & PAPER FASTENERS VOL 1 – E.H. HOTCHKISS COMPANY OFFICE AND INDUSTRIAL STAPLING MACHINES
- STAPLERS, STAPLING MACHINES, & PAPER FASTENERS VOL 2 – NEVA-CLOG
- NEVA-CLOG STAPLING MACHINES PRICE GUIDE: 2019 EDITION
- STAPLERS, STAPLING MACHINES, & PAPER FASTENERS VOL 3 – ACE FASTENER
You’ll get one-of-a-kind references and information you won’t find anywhere else and you’ll help me keep American Stationer going.





















































