We Fell Apart by E Lockhart

Image

18-year-old Matilda’s life has been anything but easy. A father who is a famous painter ( the reclusive Kingsley Cello), who has never been part of the picture, and a mother who can not see beyond her own ambitions. When Matilda’s mother once again abandons her to chase her new lover in Mexico, Matilda is left to stay with her mother’s ex-boyfriend, Saar.

When an unexpected invitation arrives from none other than Kingsley himself, inviting Matilda to his seaside estate, Hidden Beach, Matilda feels things may finally be turning her way. Yet when she arrives, she finds that Kingsley is not there, and instead meets her half-brother Meer, his hippie-like bohemian mother, and wife of Kingsley’s, June, a former child star, Brock, and an unfriendly wild-child Tatum who wants nothing more than to leave this place.

As days turn into weeks while Matilda waits eagerly for her father’s return, she finds she is stumbled into a web of lies and deceit, and a connection to the Sinclair property across the water, where secrets can run thicker than blood.

Hmm…. while an interesting read, set five days from the big happening of the Sinclair property across the lake, this story almost stands on its own. Yes, it’s peppered here and there with a little Sinclair note, and reveals more as it goes along – but not as connected as I had hoped.

That said, it was still a good read – it reminded me a bit of the Cedar Cove Series by Debbie Macomber that I read, I think, long before I wrote about books…. It was a 12-book series about a fictional town, and each book was an address. While the books all tie together, the main storyline was about the people at the address the book was titled and their connections to one another and the town. I thought then, and still think now, what a brilliant way to write a series.

Back to the book at hand, while I wanted more of a connection to the two previous books – We Were Liars and Family of Liars, once I realized this was something different, it made for an interesting read. I didn’t feel this was as strong a book as the other two, but good.

Rated: 2.75 out of 5
Read Author Before: Yes
Read Author Again: possibly

Themes: absent parents, secrets and lies

Book Club Worthy – Probably, most books can be. Topics such as absent parents and growing up on your own, what we thought of the tie-in to the Sinclairs, the whole chicken scene (don’t get me going)….

Family Of Liars by E Lockhart

Image

“Money – isn’t everything. ~ Sheila

**While this is a prequel to We Were Liars, it is important to read that book first, as this one contains information that would ruin the absolutely devastating beauty of the first book.

Carrie Sinclair, the oldest of the four Sinclair sisters, is haunted by her past. The wealthy and privileged family she is a part of’s lies and secrets did not start with the sisters’ teenage children… but long before Cadence, Johnny, Miren, and Gat were born.

As Carrie looks back at her own teenage years on Beechwood Island, playing the same games that their children played, and living by those same raised bar Singlair standards… secrets come to light of addiction, a boy, betrayal, and mistakes.

They…. have always been liars.

Recently, finding the We Were Liars mini series on Amazon Prime Video, I had a renewed interest in this book that I read over 11 years ago. I had seriously forgotten how good this book was! Of course, coming fresh off the video series, I didn’t need to read the book again, but I was thrilled to find out that a prequel had also been written.

I jumped on that bandwagon quickly, and here we are.

Family of Liars continues from where We Were Liars ends, but is not future writing – but writing of the past. Told from the point of view of Carrie, the oldest of the Sinclair sisters, she is recounting the tragic secrets of her own past with the family on Beechwood Island. We go back to the 80’s when Carrie, Penny, and Bess were around the same age as their children were in We Were Liars.

What I appreciate about this book is that you are getting more to the story, and it really explains a lot about these – dare I say uptight sisters that are trying to live up to the high standards of being a Sinclair… but also… wanting to be teens doing all the crazy things that teens do. Privilege comes with a price.

Secrets are revealed in this book, and while not as good as the first book (honestly, few sequels/prequels are), it does what most prequels do – give you a little more to the story and allow you to hang out a little longer in a fictional world with characters you have enjoyed.

Rated: 3 out of 5
Read Author Before: Yes
Read Author Again: Yes

Themes: secrets, betrayal, loss, murder

Book Club Worthy – If your book club has read the first book, absolutely! What a fun way to revisit. I don’t think my own book club has ever read a book that had a sequel/prequel that we also read together, but that seems like it would be a cool thing to do. So much to discuss in a continuing story, at the same time being able to revisit themes from the first book and how they tie together.

People We Meet On Vacation by Emily Henry

Image

Just great snarky fun unfolding in a unique, engaging style ~ Sheila

When Poppy and Alex meet during a shared car ride home from college, they have nothing in common. Poppy is a free spirit, adventurous and daring – loving to push the narrative a little farther than perhaps she should… and Alex is most content to stay at home with a book, keeping his circle of influence small and comfortable.

Somehow, this odd match works, and they become the best of friends, taking an annual one-week vacation together where Poppy’s wild child persona pushes Alex to be a little more out of his shell, which they fondly refer to as “Vacation Alex“. This fun tradition continues with the friends for 10 years until a disastrous trip to Croatia creates a rift between the two of them, and they both agree that this will be their last trip together.

Two years later, Poppy is in a rut and can’t stop thinking of her once-best friend. She reaches out to Alex, convincing him to take one last trip together to see if they can bring back the magic they once had together, mixing the intoxicating combination of Poppy’s spirit with Alex’s need for stability.

What could possibly go wrong?

Image

Full disclosure.. I have kind of been stocking people’s first book of the year selections and cherry – picking the ones I would like to give a try. This one looked fun, so in I went.

I love the layout of this read… it’s common in books today to have a present-time narrative as well as a narrative of the past… what’s unique ( and fun!) about People We Meet On Vacation, Is that this back and forth narrative takes us through Poppy and Alex’s past vacations – starting with the ride from college when they met, to their annual tradition sharing with us their bond together, leading up to the fateful trip that reveals to us the readers, what went down… all the while alternating with present time in their current trip.

It works.

I loved Vacation, Alex. The way Poppy draws out this playful alternative person, where they play act with strangers, pretend to be married with a hilarious back story of how they met to get perks at hotels and restaurants, and let go of all the inhibitions that you can when you are in a place that no one knows you, and most likely you will never see them again.

Highly enjoyable read. I didn’t know until I had started this book that it was also going to be a Netflix movie. Double Score!!!! My timing was kind of perfect, as the movie released on January 9th, and I finished the book on this day as well, and treated myself to a follow-up with the movie last night.
The actors playing the roles of Poppy and Alex were perfect. They capture Poppy’s snarky, fun personality and her sense of adventure, as well as Alex’s more laid-back personality.

Highly recommend the book – and the movie.
It’s the perfect time of year to enjoy both.

Rated: 4.5 out of 5
Read Author Before: Yes
Read Author Again: Yes

Themes: friendship, romance, nothing triggering

Book Club Worthy – Yes. Discussion can be centered around friendships, if men and women can just be close friends or best friends, and if anyone has (or had) this kind of relationship with the opposite sex… also, vacation is a fun topic, and if you do act differently when not around people you know – do we let go of inhibitions?
Of course – vacation food pairings… the options are endless!

We Were Liars on Amazon Prime

Image

In May of 2014, I read the book We Were Liars by E Lockhart, and it blew me away. CRAZY good book! I raved about it in my review at that time, and well…

A lot has happened in my life personally since 2014, as well as a WHOLE LOTTA BOOKS… so, as I suspect most readers do as well…
I forgot about it.

Over the recent holiday weeks, I had a little extra time and noticed that We Were Liars was a mini-series on Prime Video. I thought I had read the book, didn’t check here to verify, and actually, I am so glad I didn’t. 🙂 I remembered very little other than that our teenage protagonist, Cadence, had returned to the Island near Martha Stewart’s Vineyard for the summer as she had done every summer since she was young, but this time was different, as something had happened the previous year. There was an accident, and Cadence could not remember the details other than that she was found in the water and sent to the hospital.
Now, back to where it all happened, spending time with her cousins and friends who were there every summer as well, and holding some secrets to what went down… Cadence is slowly piecing it together.

Crazy what you can forget. I was blown away as this came together, and two MEGA recommendations for you.

1) If you have not read this book – We Were Liars, get it. Read it. Do it now. I’ll wait.
2) If you have read this book, ABSOLUTELY watch the Prime Video series under the same title.

SO SO GOOD. And I can’t stop thinking about it.

I didn’t know until recently that there was a second book, written as a prequel – Family Of Liars, which I just started listening to on audio yesterday.

Stay tuned… 😉

Best Offer Wins by Marisa Kashino

Image

Delightfully insane… ~ Sheila

House hunting wars go to a new level in the suburbs of Washington DC for Margo and Ian Miyake. After 18 months of house searching and 11 failed bidding wars, Margo is feeling her dreams of the white picket fence and the tire swing in the back yard to raise their future children slipping from her grasp. Will they ever catch a break?

Then, just as she is about to give up, Margo gets a hot tip about a house that will be listed in the upcoming weeks… sworn to secrecy, Margo can not believe her luck – this house checks off all the boxes (including the tire swing!). But how will they beat out the other interested buyers… what can be done differently than what they have done before?

While Ian, an EPA Lawyer, is more level-headed and realistic, Margo has become obsessed with the house – HER HOUSE, and will stop at quite literally nothing to be sure that when the dust clears, it is her… err… their name on the title.
After all, what’s too much when it comes to your dreams?


Honestly, you are getting a mixed bag of nuts on this one. When the book started – I loved it. It was just fun to watch Margo slowly lose it over the pressures of securing a home and then finding the holy grail. Months of trying and failing will do that to a person, and in the start, Margo’s wild antics are humorous, and for most of the book, I am all in.

Deeper in – the book takes a pretty dark turn – totally changing the feel of the book for me. Maybe it was because it was unexpected (I mean – I’ve read some pretty creepy psychological thrillers), maybe I was looking for something lighter – but it left things a little wonky in the end. Some things in the book felt unnecessary and did not add to the book; in fact, IMO, took away. I’m a little sad about this, as 3/4 of the way through the book, I thought I had hit on another 5-star read.

And the moral of this story – be careful what you wish for.

Rated: 3.5 out of 5
Read Author Before: No – this is a debut author
Read Author Again: unsure

Themes: unhinged, infidelity, Going TOO FAR

Book Club Worthy – As much as I have mixed feelings about this, I think a good book club discussion could happen. Who hasn’t gone to great measures to get something they really wanted – even to the point of being a big unhinged ;P

Theo of Golden by Allen Levi (First Book of 2026!)

Image

What an absolutely beautiful book that will stay with me forever~ Sheila

When a mysterious older gentleman moves to Golden, Georgia, little is known about him other than that he goes by the name Theo.
When in a coffee shop one morning, where 92 framed sketches of various residents are on display, Theo comes up with the idea to purchase each of these portraits and gift them to their “rightful owners” – the person in the frame. And what a wide variety of people! An accountant, a custodian, a landlord, a bookstore owner, a street musician, a one armed mixolist, a young girl, and a homeless woman, just to name a few.
As Theo sets out on his mission, each sketched person is invited to meet. All Theo asks in return is that they sit with him and tell him about themselves… stories are told, long-lasting hurts are shared, treasured memories revealed, and in the process, lives are changed.

Image

This is my planned first book of 2026. Only recently did this book draw my attention – and in an even shorter time, when a friend posted about this book on social media, the deal was sealed. Not only did I need to read this, but the timing, the beginning of a New Year, seemed to be perfect.

Having just finished this book yesterday afternoon, I am fresh from the words and all the feels. As I think about this today, I honestly don’t know if I can name another recent book that I have read that left me feeling this emotional, inspired, and with chills.

What a perfect book to start the year with. Beautifully and thoughtfully written. May we all take each day as a gift and a chance to quietly make a difference in a positive way. May we all long for Heaven the way that Theo does – and may we be the type of people that bring a little bit of Heaven to earth.

Absolutely read this book.

Rated: 5 out of 5
Read Author Before: No
Read Author Again: Maybe – this feels so good I kind of don’t want to touch it 🙂

Themes: Faith, Hope, Spiritualness, Selflessness, Kindness

Book Club Worthy – YES, and if I have anything to say about it – it absolutely will be. There is so, so much that would make for great discussion here.

Morning Meanderings… What Day Is It?

Image

Good morning, fellow readers. I hope your Holidays were wonderful, and you are not as confused as I am that we are back in full swing and…. It’s Friday.
I am posting an update to yesterday’s First Book. We had a few more trickle in throughout the day, so I am reposting the pictures below to provide a full look at what people are reading. The links to the books will remain on the previous post.

I am excited about books this year, and that in itself is exciting, as I have not been a strong reader/reviewer for many years – in 2025 I set a goal of 50 books and ended with 78.

Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image

First Book Of The Year 2026!!!!

Image

Happy New Year! It’s snowing here in Central Minnesota. I’m at my kitchen table with my COFFEE looking out the glass sliding door to the deck.
This morning, I have spent time putting together this annual post. Thank you, friends, fellow book lovers, and Authors who sent me what book you are starting the New Year with. It’s so fun to see the variety – both new and old titles… hopefully some will get added to your TBR pile (mountain).
Be sure to watch for the authors – Thank you to PJ Tracy, Cary Griffith, William Kent Krueger, Jill Hannah Anderson, Allen Eskens, Randy Sue Meyers, Lorna Landvik, Kao Kalia Yang, Barbara Claypole White, Heather Gudenkauf, Joshilyn Jackson, Adriana Trigiana, Julie Schumacher, Laurie Frankel, Nadia Hashimi, Erin Soderberg Downing, and Jenna Blum. So fun to see you in the mix and what you are reading 😀
If I missed anyone, please let me know.. pictures come to me by text, email, Facebook, PMs…. I can easily miss someone, so please resend, and I will get you added.

And with no further babbling from me – here are this year’s wide variety of First Books (titles linked below for easy access.

Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image


The Jackal’s Mistress by Chris Bohjalian

Horse by Geraldine Brooks

Secrets You Can’t Keep by Debra Webb

A Mercy by Toni Morrison

Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir 2 picked this!

The Secret Library by Hanna Reeves

The Bravest Battle by Dan Kurzman

The Water Keeper by Charles Martin

State of Retribution by Marie Force

Us Against You by Fredrik Backman

We Did OK, Kid by Anthony Hopkins

The First Witch Of Boston by Andrea Catalano

Best Offer Wins by Marisa Kashino

Cougar Claw by Cary Griffith

Mercy by Sara Cate

Framed In Death by JD Robb

Hamnet by Maggie O’ Farrell

The Woman in Cabin 10 by Ruth Ware

Tom’s Crossing by Mark Z Danielewski

The Miracle Among Us by Marci Siegel

The Deepest Cut by PJ Tracy

Nightshade by Michael Connelly

Daughters Of The Bamboo Grove by Barbara Demick

The Princess Bride by William Goldman

Theo of Golden by Allen Levi 2 picked this!

Women of Promiscuous Nature by Donna Everhart

Heartbreak Hollow by Frank Weber

The God Of The Woods by Liz Moore

The Nine Moons of Han Yu and Luli by Karina Yan Glaser

This is Happiness by Niall Williams

A Gambling Man by David Baldacci

Gone Before Goodbye by Reese Witherspoon and Harlan Coben

The Onion Came First by Elinor Wilder

This American Woman by Zarna Garg

The Austen Affair by Madeline Bell

The Home For Unwanted Girls by Joanna Goodman

Like Mother, Like Mother by Susan Rieger

Heart The Lover by Lily King

What The River Knows by Isabel Ibanez

Romantic Comedy by Curtis Sittenfeld

Good Intentions by Marisa Walz

We Were Never Friends by Kaira Rouda

Mirage City by Lev AC Rosen

Funny Story by Emily Henry

Wisdom Corner by David Heska and Wanbli Weiden

The Book of Kin by Jennifer Eli Bowen

The Secret Book Society by Madeline Martin

Murder at Holly House by Denzil Meyrick

Culpability by Bruce Holsinger

Death of The Author by Nnedi Okorafor

Ghosts of Fourth Street by Laurie Hertzel

Little Women by Louisa May Alcott

Let Them by Mel Robbins

The Ministry of Time by Kaliane Bradley

Next of Kin by Gabrielle Hamilton

You Are Here by Karin Lin-Greenberg

My Friends by Fredrik Backman

The Raven Scholar by Antonia Hodgson

The Lion Women of Tehran by Marjan Kamali

That’s A Great Question, I’d Love To Tell You by Elyse Myers

The Book Of Daniel by EL Doctorow

The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny by Kiran Desai

The Housemaid by Frieda McFadden

Something To Look Forward To by Fannie Flagg

Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin

Flashlight by Susan Choi

The Flight Attendant by Chris Bohjalian

Brigands and Breadknives by Travis Baldree

Life: A Love Story by Elizabeth Berg

The Moonshiner’s Daughter by Donna Everhart

The Book of Alchemy by Suleika Jaouad

Note about my pick: Theo of Golden by Allen Levi. As usual, I was back and forth on my choice… for a while there I felt certain I was going to go with a re-read (#comfort read) and then I recently was reunited with a book that I thought was a standalone and found out there are more and that this would be a great time to dig back in ( more about this later), there was also one I am intrigued by that a friend is also reading and I could not decide if it was for me now- or better to read once we travel to Florida when I can be all in when I have nothing but time over that three days of travel… – and then finally, Theo Of Golden caught my attention. This book was already in my peripheral vision as a “I need to read this,” and a recent post by a friend sharing her experience with this book sealed the deal.

If you missed this year’s participation deadline, feel free to send it today. I almost always have a few trickling in on New Years and I am happy to update to include your First Read.

Happy Happy New Year to you all! May 2026 bring JOY and Peace.

Love,
Sheila



The Perfect Hosts by Heather Gudenkauf

Image

The age old adage with a knife twist …trying to have your cake… and eating it too. `Sheila

Wes Drake does not like to do anything small. As a wealthy Wyoming rancher and horse breeder at his and his wife Madeline’s sprawling ranch called Lone Tree, he is all about being seen, and of course, others want to be seen with them.
When the couple hosts the party of the year, Pistols and Pearls, a gender reveal party so sensational that every A-lister wants to be invited, it makes headlines, not only before the party, but (in unfortunate ways) after the party as well.

When the vintage truck filled with colorful explosive powder blows up when shot, it leaves behind far more than the sex of the baby – it leaves several guests injured, and a good friend of Madeline’s dead.

As the police get involved to get to the bottom of what happened, things are revealed that make it clear that this was no random accident, but a premeditated plan… intended to keep some people quiet…
But who was the intended target?
And what are they hiding?

Image

It’s no secret that I love me some Heather Gudenkauf. Known for engaging discussion-worthy thrillers, when this one popped up on my radar, it was a no-brainer to dig in.
Heather did not disappoint. What a fun subject to plan a crime around – a Gender reveal? Excellent.

In her usual style, Heather brings us delightful, well-developed characters that make you feel like you were also a guest at this party-gone-wrong.

And trust me you are in for a treat as all is not as it appears, and when you think you know you know….

you don’t know…
But you will 🙂

Rated: 3.5 out of 5
Read Author Before: Yes
Read Author Again: Yes

Triggers: Marital abuse

Book Club Worthy – Yes! What a fun discussion to have around the whole gender reveal party trends – yay or nay – have you been to one? What was cool about it ( or not cool)? Would you do one/host one? In the book, they had some ideas for the catering team for after the reveal.
If money were no objecy how would you plan a reveal?
The history some of the characters have with one another – good/bad/indifferent

Harder topic – the abuse.

Favorites of 2025

Hey all – another Christmas here and gone, and in a few short days, we will be closing the chapter on 2025.
For me its been a great reading year – my best in 10 years. I am closing out the year at 77 books (possibly 78). Not only has it been a good year for quantity of reading, but also quality. I have read some great reads thanks to Book Club picks, recommendations from friends, and some lucky random picks as well.
Here are some of my favorites – a few of these (3) I have not read yet, but will be soon.

What would you add to this?