Introduction

This ad was found at adesignconcern.com. The designer (not named on the site) discussed working with directors at Lake Powell Marinas in 2016 to create ads that show how Lake Powell is immense because of its coastline and also because of the many activities that are done there. Every experience at Lake Powell is a little different because it has so much to offer. The goal for the developer was to draw people in to the experience that is Lake Powell and have them want to come try it out for themselves.
Original Ad Analysis
Design

I really like the image of the sky with the map of Lake Powell coming through. The designer used the sky as a backdrop for the map, but it’s subtle and not overdone. The message he portrays in this image matches the text below about Lake Powell having more shoreline than the west coast and has so much to offer visitors. This effect repeats the message of the text well.
Proximity within this image is done well. I like how the designer put the text “1,960 shore miles” on top of the sky which has the map showing through. This effect associates the map of Lake Powell with the idea of the length of the shore. This creates the idea that it would be hard to see all that Lake Powell has to offer in one visit. The ad also has the main message “Rock the Water” in close proximity to the boat and wake boarder. This solidifies the message by showing an example of rocking the water right above the text.
The alignment of the main message is center aligned. It appears that the designer is attempting to align the other text to the edges of the white picture frame, but this where I believe the alignment is a little off. The text on the left is a little too far right and the Lake Powell logo and name could be a little further right so that the edges of both texts match the edges of the white picture frame. Also the paragraph of text crosses over the center line of the ad on the right side. I believe he should have moved the whole body of text to left slightly to align on the left side with the white picture frame and on the right side with the center alignment.
Color

The three main colors in this ad are blue, white and brown. The blue in this ad is portrayed in many different shades. There is the blue text which is brighter blue to stand out against the blue of the sky. The sky has varying shades with the strokes of the map in the background. The water is also blue and shifts to a darker blue where the white text starts. This helps the white text to stand out against the background. Besides the blue text about the miles of shore line, all the rest of the text is white, which helps it stand out against the colors in the image. The boat, which is also white, pops out of the image. The browns of the rock are a classic Lake Powell look. The brown contrasts well with the blue and white and creates a striking backdrop.
Typography

The typography in the ad is various san-serif fonts. While there is contrast between the different texts, it doesn’t come from using two different typefaces. The contrast comes in thickness and size of fonts. As an example, the main message “Rock the Water” is all caps, large and in a thick font. The paragraph below is of lesser importance and is smaller text. The contact info is slightly larger and bold. The text in the top left corner, 1960 Shore miles is in a different color and the number is bold while shore miles is all caps but not bold. The name Lake Powell has letters that are long and narrow. All of these differences create contrast even though the typeface isn’t contrasting. Each message stands out because of changes in character and stroke size.
New Ad Analysis
Design

The original ad campaign had a couple of ads with different messages about things to do at Lake Powell. The one in my original ad here is “Rock the Water”. Another one was “Made for Adventure”. One of the things my kids like to do most at Lake Powell is surf so I used the message “Ride the Wave”. For the design of this new ad, I used a picture from our Lake Powell last summer. I framed it the same as the original ad with a white box framing the activity. I used the map behind the sky and turned the opacity down so that it is subtle like the original.
I created the same proximity as the original ad by putting the main message “Ride the Wave” in close proximity to the picture. This helps associate the image visually to the message of the text. Because of the size of the image, the sky was not near as big and so I put the message “1,960 Shore Miles” as close to the sky as I could while still keeping it within the white picture frame like the original ad.
I tried to improve the alignment in my recreating on the original ad. It is still center aligned like the original ad, but I moved the two columns of text away from the center line so they didn’t cross over. I wasn’t able to align the edges of the text with the picture frame without making the text much smaller so I deliberately moved the alignment past the picture frame so it was an obvious choice.
Color

The color scheme in the new ad is green, white and brown. I kept the white text like the original ad, including the logo. Even the surf board is mostly white. However, the color of the water in this picture is more green than blue like in the original ad. There are varying shades of green in the water and the water got lighter towards the bottom of the image. So I used a green rectangle box (with opacity set down low) behind the white text on the lower section of the image so that the white text would still stand out like in the original ad. The brown rock is a nice contrast to the green and white.
Typography

Like the original ad, I used all san-serif fonts. I created contrast in the text, by using different size strokes and varying character sizes. On the phrase “1,960 Shore Miles” I used bold on the numbers and regular, but all caps on the the words. The main message “Ride the Wave” is all caps, bold, and very large characters. This helps this message to stand out as the most important message to the reader. The text on the left side (the long paragraph message, contact info, and company info) is of varying sizes and separated from each other to show they are different messages. To match the original ad, “Lake Powell” is long and narrow with Resorts & Marinas smaller but still all caps. By using different stroke sizes, character sizes and all caps. verses regular, there is contrast into the text without changing the type face.
Conclusion



This new ad fits well with the original ad campaign because it shows another activity that is done at Lake Powell. It has a three-word, catchy main message like the original ad campaign. The white picture phrase, with a cutout for the main phrase ties it to the original ads. The map behind the sky is similar to the original ad. It uses the white text in a san-serif type face through out. The logo placement is the same as the original ad campaign.
The message in the ad campaign that Lake Powell has something for everyone and is a new experience every time you visit is well portrayed in the original ad as well as the new ad. A submessage that is portrayed in the original and new ad is that because Lake Powell has so much coastline, you will feel like you have the lake to yourself. Notice that in all three ads, one person is enjoying an activity without the traffic of other boaters in the image. This emphasizes that there is enough space at Lake Powell for everyone to enjoy it.
































