Stop me if you've heard this one... worlds will live, worlds will die... but imagine if your every fear, each bad decision, gave birth to a malformed world of nightmare. A world that shouldn't exist. And desperate as it fights to survive in the light of the true multiverse far above... these worlds are doomed to rot apart, and die, because they are wrong at their core. Welcome to the Dark Multiverse. Home to stories that should never be... It's all one big cosmic joke, except no one on this side is laughing. ...well, almost no one...
The Dark Multiverse, also known as the Nth World by its residents,[74][75] is a shadow under the primary Multiverse, one formed of every fear and bad decision that was ever made or dreamed of. Worlds in the Dark Multiverse are fragile and constantly deteriorating, inevitably doomed to destruction by their own malformed construction.[32]
History
Contrary to the worlds of the normal Multiverse, those from the Dark Multiverse have their names preceded by a minus sign, such as Earth -52 compared to Earth 0, for instance. Each of those inverse worlds shown so far bears some degree of thematic resemblance to its positive counterpart.
- Earth -52 begins as a twisted and darkened version of Prime Earth, although it has some elements of Earth-31.
- Earth -44 while also similar to Prime Earth at first, features Batman becoming a cybernetic being, while Earth 44 is centered around purely robotic versions of superheroes.
- Earth -32 and Earth 32 both deal with Bruce Wayne being granted a Green Lantern Power Ring.
- Earth -22 and Earth 22 are both worlds in which the Joker is killed and his death serves as a catalyst for a major catastrophe.
- Earth -12 and Earth 12 are both worlds in which Bruce Wayne and Diana of Themyscira are romantically involved.
- Earth -11 and Earth 11 are both worlds wherein characters are the opposite sex of their mainstream equivalents.
- Earth -1 and Earth 1 both deal with a darker, grittier take on the DC Universe, with Superman and Batman serving as the initial focus.
Because of its nature as the cradle of yet unborn worlds, the number of worlds in the Dark Multiverse is far greater than in the normal Multiverse, as seen when Barbatos chose to show to Batman the "galaxies" of worlds born from his fears.[1] Other superheroes also have had an impact on the Dark Multiverse, with many twisted versions of superheroes such as the Flash, Aquaman, and Wonder Woman preparing to invade the Multiverse,[2] even if they could have been created by Batman's fears all the same.
Early History
At the dawn of creation, what would later become the Dark Multiverse was known as the World Forge, a realm of infinite possibilities which was assigned to the cosmic being Alpheus by his Mother, Perpetua, the creator of the Multiverse.[3] The Higher Being, who would later be known as the World Forger because of his duties, was tasked to oversee his own realm as one of the three fundamental parts of creation, similarly to what his brothers, Mar Novu/The Monitor and Mobius/The Anti-Monitor had to do with their respective realms.[3][4]
The World Forge was completely composed of dark matter, a substance rich in potential, which was to be used to forge new universes out of the pure metals of creation and the hopes and fears of all sentient life. Worlds that proved themselves stable would rise up into the light to join the Orrery of Worlds, while worlds that were lacking, flawed and corrupt at their cores had to be destroyed so that their energies could be released to fuel the birth of new universes. As the World Forger needed to find a way to destroy these unstable realities, he created his own "pet", Barbatos[3], then known as the Great Dragon[4], who was tasked with annihilating the decaying realities.[3]
After the banishment of Perpetua and Alpheus' return to the Forge,[3] Barbatos, who had served his master for millennia, got tired of him and his lust for destruction, which was also fueled by Perpetua's "whispers", led him to rebel against the Forger and ultimately kill him. Without the World Forger, the cycle was broken; failed universes were now allowed to exist beyond their time, festering and rotting into nothing with all the sentient beings within these realms now suffering nightmarish ends.[4]
Barbatos' rise to power forced the Monitor to generate a race of controller, the Fuginauts, which could ensure that anything and anyone from the Dark Multiverse could invade the Orrery of Worlds, infecting the positive realities with their corruption. In the modern day, Tempus Fuginaut is one of the last defenders of the Multiverse's walls against the darkness of the Dark Multiverse, always checking up on the nightmare realities.
In the course of millennia, Perpetua continued to whisper in Barbatos' ears in order to cause a new Crisis and, as a consequence, damage the Multiverse just enough to ultimately free her from her prison. Barbatos was led to plan his invasion of the positive Multiverse; during the Final Crisis, the occasion finally came as Bruce Wayne, a.k.a. Batman, was sent back in time to the Prehistoric Era by Darkseid's Omega Beams. The event was noticed by Barbatos who chose him as his portal, and possible vessel, for his arrival into the Multiverse; the Bat God began inspiring humankind through the Bat Tribe and used the Bird Tribe, which in the modern day became the Court of Owls, to enact his master plan.
During the Final Crisis, Mandrakk the Dark Monitor was also banished from the Multiverse by Superman, sinking into the Overvoid until he finally arrived in the Dark Multiverse.[5]
For millennia, the existence of the Dark Multiverse was unknown to the Prime Multiverse's residents until, on Prime Earth, the investigations of the Blackhawk Squadron and the Challengers of the Unknown,[6] led the latter to journey into the unknown and reach the Dark Multiverse. Barbatos' agents, the Court of Owls, engineered the "mantling" of Batman by using the five native heavy metals of the Dark Multiverse, Nth Metal, Promethium, Dionesium, Electrum, and Batmanium, on him.
In 2016, just before the Rebirth, Batman glimpsed the Dark Multiverse and some of his counterparts dying over and over again while using the Final Invention.[7]
Barbatos' Invasion
Years later, after glimpsing the Dark once again through the Final Invention, the Dark Knight was tricked by the Strigydae into reaching the Tomb of Hath-Seth and opening a portal which banished him to the Dark Multiverse while bringing forth the Bat God Barbatos, who had previously assembled an army of the worst Dark Multiverse Batmen counterparts, the so-called Dark Knights, who were born from Bruce Wayne's fears, under the command of the Batman who Laughs, a Batman that was infected by the Joker's toxin.[8]
With the help of the Cosmic Tuning Fork and the Phantom Zone Projector, John Henry Irons, a.k.a. Steel and Barry Allen, a.k.a. the Flash helped Superman journey into the Dark Multiverse in search of Batman, only for his entrance to be part of a trap by its denizens, who hooked him up to the same machine that Batman was powering in order to use him as a battery to drive the Multiverse into the dark, letting loose Superman's own nightmarish versions in the process.[9]
As the Dark Knights conquered Earth 0, Barbatos recruited other nightmare counterparts of Earth 0's superheroes which were held back by Wonder Woman and Hawkgirl. During the final battle, the Dark Multiverse's forces were overpowering the resistance until the superheroes were helped by the Multiverse's superheroes, which were called upon the battlefield by the mysterious 53rd Earth, and managed to use Element X to conjure and wear divine armors whose powers let them defeat Barbatos and the Dark Knights once and for all.[10]

This section of the article does not provide a complete profile of the subject. You can help out by providing additional information, expanding on the subject matter in order to bring this article to a higher standard of quality.
The Aftermath of the Invasion
With the defeat of Barbatos, who was chained somewhere in the Dark Multiverse by the Monitor, the dark realities were now without any supreme ruler until the rise of Mandrakk the Dark Monitor, who tried to return to the Multiverse but was stopped by the Unexpected whose leader, Neon, altered Mandrakk's physiology so that he could feed on dark matter, allowing him to stay forever in the Dark Multiverse as its new ruler.[5]
During a journey into a reality where the Black Lantern Corps conquered the universe during the Blackest Knight, Tempus Fuginaut was forced to seal the walls of this reality to stop one of its residents, Thaal Sinestro, a.k.a. Limbo Lantern, from escaping the damnation of his world.[11]
It was eventually revealed that the Batman who Laughs had survived the first invasion of the Multiverse and planned to conquer Earth himself. First, he tried to finally kill Batman and corrupt the planet with the help of another dark Batman, the Grim Knight, [12] then he took advantage of the Justice League's war against the Legion of Doom over the dominion of the Totality, building his own army of infected superheroes[13] and using it to counter both Earth's superheroes and Lex Luthor, who had become the right hand of a released Perpetua. As the Batman who Laughs proposed to further empower her with the Crisis Energies from the Dark Multiverse's unstable realities, Perpetua replaced Luthor with the Batman who Laughs, rewarding him by giving him the chance to build a new Dark Multiverse army and invade again Earth 0.[14]
The Batman who Laughs returned to the Dark Multiverse where he saved a maniacal teenage Bruce Wayne known as the Robin King from his world's annihilation and, as the Batman who Laughs believed him to his trump card, masqueraded him as a Groblin[15]. Then, he discovered the existence of the Final Bruce Wayne, a Batman from the Dark Multiverse who had replicated the same incident that created the Super-God Doctor Manhattan, becoming the almighty entity known as Batmanhattan; the Batman who Laughs ambushed him as he rebuilt his body and lobotomized him, keeping his body for the final act of his takeover plan.[16]
At some point before the beginning of the Ultrawar, the Golden Destroyer somehow reached the Dark Multiverse and made a deal with dark versions of the Green Lanterns and their supervillains, building his Armies of the Pit. Later, after Zundernell confronted the Green Lanterns of the Multiverse, he showed them his allies, who were trying to pass through the veil between the Multiverses; however, the Lanterns prevented their dark versions from moving into the positive Multiverse by defeating Zundernell before they could obtain physical bodies.[17]
Meanwhile, Tempus Fuginaut summoned to the Dark Multiverse Wally West, a.k.a. the Flash, the Fastest Man Alive in the Multiverse, in order to save the infinite realities from a dark, unstable world which was refusing to be destroyed.[18] Wally traveled through the realities in order to discover the origin of this realm, and he finally reached the Dark Multiverse realm where he learned that it was born from his fear to not see again his lost children, Irey and Jai; as he met them again for the first time since he disappeared, Wally made a deal with Tempus to undo the creation of this nightmare world in exchange for his children's safety. Tempus agreed, so Wally sat down on the Mobius Chair, which supercharged him with the Connective Energy of Doctor Manhattan, saving the Multiverse by erasing the unstable reality and planning to heal the wounds in it, as his "predecessor" had tried to do in the past.[19]
Some time later, during his journey through the dark realities, Tempus Fuginaut was confronted by a survivor of one of these worlds, Duke Thomas, a.k.a. the Last Monitor, who attacked him for not interfering to save the doomed and damned universes from their destinies and proclaimed himself the savior of the Dark Multiverse as the Final Knight.[20]

This section of the article does not provide a complete profile of the subject. You can help out by providing additional information, expanding on the subject matter in order to bring this article to a higher standard of quality.
The Second Metal War
In the Prime Multiverse, Earth 0 was overrun by the Batman who Laughs' army and remade as the Metalverse by Perpetua,[21][22] while the Dark Knight made a deal with the Anti-Monitor, Superboy-Prime and Darkseid to win their respective Crises in the Dark Multiverse worlds whose Crisis Energy would fuel the Mother of the Multiverse forever.[23][24]
After Earth's superheroes rebelled against the Batman who Laughs,[22] who had become a Dark God known as the Darkest Knight after his mind was transplanted into Batmanhattan's body,[25] Wonder Woman assembled a team to travel to the Dark Multiverse, as they wanted to steal the Crisis Energy and fuel the Mobius Chair in order to supercharge Wally West enough to make him able to defeat both Perpetua and the Darkest Knight;[26] during their journey the superheroes also met a caged Barbatos, who mocked them for believing themselves to be able to win the battle against the Darkest Knight.[23]
The team split up into three groups as Batman reached the first Crisis' dark reality, Wonder Woman landed on the Infinite Crisis' reality and Superman arrived at the Final Crisis' reality,[23] where they discovered the Darkest Knight's alterations and their former supervillains' dominion;[23] Diana eventually managed to convince Superboy-Prime to stand with them against the supervillains and redirect the Dark Multiverse energy to Wally West. However, it was revealed that the Mobius Chair was previously altered so that the Dark Multiverse's energies were sent to the Darkest Knight, who became an omnipotent version of himself that managed to even murder Perpetua and create his own multiverse, which was inspired by the Dark Multiverse.[27]
In order to defeat the Darkest Knight and his army, Wonder Woman traveled again into the Dark Multiverse, reaching the Forge of Worlds where Darkseid had taken refuge after the undoing of his dark realm. Despite Darkseid's warnings, Diana of Themyscira bound herself with her lasso to the Forge itself; because of the Forge's possibilities, Diana managed to unknot reality itself as all the memories from past events resurfaced into the mind of Earth 0's residents.[28]. Later, a Forge of Worlds-empowered Wonder Woman managed to destroy the Darkest Knight once and for all at the End of Time and, as a reward for saving their lives, the supreme Hands chose to spare both the Multiverse and the Dark Multiverse from their inevitable destructions.[29]
Infinite Frontier
In the aftermath of the rebirth of the Multiverse, Lex Luthor revealed to the other Totality members that the Dark Multiverse still existed under the shadow of the positive Multiverse; it was also now one of the Multiverses that formed the so-called Infinite Frontier, a small Omniverse within the larger Omniverse.[29]
According to the Batman of Justice Incarnate, the Dark Multiverse was sealed off.[30] However, this statement was later revealed to be false.[31]
Dawn of DC
The Empire of Shadows

There's something missing here. This section of the article is incomplete, and contains information, but requires more before it can be considered complete. You can help DC Database by editing this page, providing additional information to bring this article to a higher standard of quality.
War on the Nth World

There's something missing here. This section of the article is incomplete, and contains information, but requires more before it can be considered complete. You can help DC Database by editing this page, providing additional information to bring this article to a higher standard of quality.
List of known Dark Realities
The Dark Multiverse is largely composed of dark worlds where superheroes and supervillains' lives were damaged beyond repair, damning the universes. Only a few of these alternate realities were given an actual designation:
- Earth -52: a universe where Batman lost his family and decide to get Barry Allen's super-speed. The Dark Knight kidnapped him and forced the speedster to merge with him so that they became a speed monster known as the Red Death.[32]
- Earth -44: a univere where some of Batman's supervillains learned his secret identity and attacked him in the Batcave, where Bane murdered Alfred Pennyworth. An enraged Batman was helped by Cyborg in creating an Alfred-based AI, whose desire to protect its "son" led it to go evil and murder every one of Gotham's supervillains and, ultimately, the Justice League. Then, Batman himself was forced to become the Murder Machine.[33]
- Earth -32: a universe where a young Bruce Wayne was chosen as a Green Lantern in Crime Alley after his parents' murder. He used his new powers to unleash his fury on Joe Chill and, later, on Gotham's criminals. Eventually, his willpower ultimately overpowered the ring and unleashed dark forces into the universe which destroyed the Green Lanterns and the Guardians of the Universe; he came to be known as the Dawnbreaker.[34]
- Earth -22: a universe where the Joker drove Batman to kill him. His death unleashed a powerful toxin which infected Batman's brain and turned him into the new Joker: as he had no more restraint but his abilities were intact, Bruce became the Batman Who Laughs, slaughtering all of his supervillains and allies and causing the world to become a wasteland.[35]
- Earth -12: a universe where Ares waged war on Earth's superheroes for two years, which culminated in Batman stealing his helmet and power so that he killed the God, but this new power made him sink into madness. Bruce murdered his beloved Wonder Woman and the rest of the Justice League before destroying both Olympus and its Gods as the Merciless.[36]
- Earth -11: a universe where, in the aftermath of Sylvester Kyle's death, his lover, Bryce Wayne, killed many rogue metahumans and waged war on Aquawoman's Atlantean army, forcing the Batwoman to become a human-Atlantean hybrid known as the Drowned, who let the world become a giant ocean.[37]
- Earth -1: a universe where Superman somehow went evil and murdered his friends, supervillains, and even his own wife. Batman chose to sacrifice himself in order to save the world, injecting himself with the Doomsday Virus and finally killing Superman; however, he only made the situation worse instead, as he became a feral monster known as the Devastator.[38]
- Earth-Metal: an obscure version of Prime Earth where an alternate Barbatos succeeded in conquering the world during his invasion after corrupting the Element X armors of the Justice League, possessing Batman and turning the others into the monstrous Dragons of the Bat; then he completed his destruction, ravaging the dark version of the remaining New 52's worlds and leaving only the Last Monitor to watch for the destroyed realities.[20]
- Earth al Ghul: a dark world where Bruce Wayne became Ra's al Ghul as well as the head of the Empire of Shadows, an evil organization of invincible warriors which came to rule Earth and its governments. After one of Bruce and Talia's children captured a deceased Fuginaut and the Empire began planning to conquer Earth 0, this realm was invaded by the Earth 0 Batman and the Authority that prevented the al Ghuls from crossing over into their home universe.[31]
There are also shown to exist a large number of unnamed realities, which are not only born from the hopes and fears of the positive Multiverse's residents but even from certain events from all of its history, such as Crisis on Infinite Earths or Flashpoint which, at some point in time, caused the birth in the Dark Multiverse of nightmare version of themselves where evil conquered the universe. Among these realities, there are multiple versions of Earths from all of the Multiverse's past iterations: for example, there exists alternate versions of Pre-Crisis Earths such as Earth-Two, Pre-Flashpoint realities such as New Earth or Earth-30, Post-Flashpoint realities such ass Prime Earth or Earth 12, and even the Hypertime realities.
Points of Interest
- The Forge of Worlds
- The Other Place/New Myrra
- The Kingdom of Benevolence (On the borders) (Formerly, destroyed)
- The Dark Gods' Realm[77]
- The Sheed Realm
- Event Horizon (Destroyed)
- Behemothfall Fields
Residents
Main List: Dark Multiverse Characters
- Barbatos
- The Dark Knights
- The Devastator
- The Drowned
- The Merciless
- The Batman Who Laughs
- The Dawnbreaker
- The Murder Machine
- The Red Death
- Bathomet
- Doctor Arkham
- The Batmage
- Batmanasaurus Rex
- The Beyonder
- The Darkfather
- The Pararobins
- Castle Bat
- The Batom
- The Batmobeast
- Baby Batman
- The Batmanhunter
- The Collector
- Batrocitus
- The Night Glider
- The Mindhunter
- The Grim Knight
- Batmazo
- The Warbat
- The Ark
- The Black Monday
- The Chiroptor
- Kull
- The Pearl
- Quietus
- The Batman Who Frags
- Superman Blue
- The Dragon of Barbatos
- The Hawk Patrol
- Mayor Joker
- Janet Wayne
- The Joker Dragons
- The Salesman
- Dark Prof
- The Skeleton
- Mandrakk the Dark Monitor (Dax Novu) (Displaced)
- The Dark Gods
- King Best
- The Mob God
- Savage Fire
- Karnell
- The God With No Name
- The Inverse
- The Dark Elder
- Gloriana Tenebrae (Displaced)
- The Sheeda
- The Sheeda Spydroids
- Perrus the Benevolent
- The Insect Queen
- The Unseen
- The Otherkind
- The Upside-Down Man
- The Conjoined
- The Offspring
- The Rip
- The Soup
- Infernal
- Mayor Wayne
- Warden Wayne
- B.A.T.Man
- May Wayne
- Deathstroke the Terminator
- Saint Batman
- Batman the Broken
- Son of Bane
- The Dark Metal Men
- Nth Metal Man
- Aluminum
- Barium
- Calcium
- Plutonium
- Sodium
- Zirconium
- The Dark Fates
- The Eradicator (Lois Lane)
- Limbo Lantern
- The Avatar of Nekron
- OBAC (One-Beetle-Army-Corps)
- Gaia
- The Joker Dragons
- Batmanson
- Batmanhattan/"The Final Bruce Wayne"
- The Robin King
- Alfrood
- The Creepers
- The Nightwings
- The Lightning Knights
- The Rainbow Batman Corps
- The Starros
- The Swamp King
- Armies of the Pit
- Batman the Silenced
- Senator Elliot
- The Gray Son
- Hecate/Wonder Woman
- The Flash (Eobard Thawne)
- The Dread Lantern
- The Last Monitor/The Final Knight (Duke Thomas)
- The Dragon-Slayer (Dick Grayson)
- The Dragons of the Bat
- The Empire of Shadows
- Ra's al Ghul/Batman (Bruce Wayne)
- Janan al Ghul/"Norah Stone"
- Saif al Ghul
- Taj al Ghul
- Talia al Ghul
- Ra's al Ghul
- Ra's al Ghul/Batman (Bruce Wayne)
- Brother Fate
- The Circle of Crows
- Vulpecula
- Lord Aesop
- The Old Molder
- The Great God Skylight
- The Court of Skylight
- Errode
- The Court of Skylight
- The Valkyrie General (Otho-Ra)
- The Red Rook
- The Ouroborons
- The Shih of the Skies
- The Clown Princess of Crime
- Lord Harley
- Mad Harley
- Prophet Harley
Notes
- The Dark Multiverse was originally glimpsed by Batman in Batman (Volume 2) #49. It was first named in Dark Nights: Metal #2, before its first full appearance in Dark Nights: Metal #3.
- The Dark Multiverse is virtually infinite and keeps on expanding forever because new realities– and even small-scaled multiverses– are constantly born from the fears of the positive Multiverse's residents.
- Infinite versions of the Godsphere and alternate dimensions from all the iterations of the Multiverse – and even Hypertime – exist within the Dark Multiverse.
- The Dark Multiverse was not part of Perpetua's design, as it was never meant to propagate with unstable worlds.[13]
- According to the Robin King, evil counterparts of supervillains take the form of good versions of themselves, as they fear being good.[24] However, at least one version of Deathstroke the Terminator existed who is far more evil than his positive Multiverse's counterpart.
Trivia
- The Last 52 Multiverse is conceptually inspired by the Dark Multiverse.
See Also
- Appearances of Dark Multiverse
- Location Gallery: Dark Multiverse
- Catalogued images related to Dark Multiverse
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 Batman: Lost #1
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 The Batman Who Laughs #1
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 Justice League (Volume 4) #22
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 Dark Nights: Metal #4
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 The Unexpected (Volume 3) #6
- ↑ Dark Nights: Metal #1
- ↑ Batman (Volume 2) #49
- ↑ Dark Nights: Metal #2
- ↑ Dark Nights: Metal #3
- ↑ Dark Nights: Metal #6
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 Tales from the Dark Multiverse: Blackest Night #1
- ↑ 12.0 12.1 The Batman Who Laughs: The Grim Knight #1
- ↑ 13.0 13.1 Year of the Villain: Hell Arisen #1
- ↑ Year of the Villain: Hell Arisen #4
- ↑ 15.0 15.1 Dark Nights: Death Metal Robin King #1
- ↑ 16.00 16.01 16.02 16.03 16.04 16.05 16.06 16.07 16.08 16.09 16.10 16.11 16.12 16.13 16.14 16.15 16.16 16.17 Dark Nights: Death Metal Legends of the Dark Knights #1
- ↑ The Green Lantern: Season Two #10
- ↑ Flash Forward #1
- ↑ 19.0 19.1 Flash Forward #6
- ↑ 20.00 20.01 20.02 20.03 20.04 20.05 20.06 20.07 20.08 20.09 Tales from the Dark Multiverse: Dark Nights Metal #1
- ↑ 21.0 21.1 21.2 21.3 21.4 21.5 21.6 Dark Nights: Death Metal Guidebook #1
- ↑ 22.0 22.1 22.2 22.3 22.4 22.5 22.6 22.7 22.8 Dark Nights: Death Metal #1
- ↑ 23.00 23.01 23.02 23.03 23.04 23.05 23.06 23.07 23.08 23.09 23.10 Dark Nights: Death Metal Trinity Crisis #1
- ↑ 24.0 24.1 24.2 24.3 24.4 24.5 Dark Nights: Death Metal #4
- ↑ 25.0 25.1 25.2 25.3 25.4 25.5 Dark Nights: Death Metal #2
- ↑ 26.0 26.1 26.2 26.3 26.4 26.5 26.6 26.7 Dark Nights: Death Metal #3
- ↑ Dark Nights: Death Metal #5
- ↑ Dark Nights: Death Metal #6
- ↑ 29.0 29.1 Dark Nights: Death Metal #7
- ↑ Justice League Incarnate #2
- ↑ 31.0 31.1 Batman/Superman Authority Special #1
- ↑ 32.0 32.1 Batman: The Red Death #1
- ↑ Batman: The Murder Machine #1
- ↑ Batman: The Dawnbreaker #1
- ↑ The Batman Who Laughs #1
- ↑ Batman: The Merciless #1
- ↑ Batman: The Drowned #1
- ↑ Batman: The Devastator #1
- ↑ Tales from the Dark Multiverse: Batman: Knightfall #1
- ↑ Tales from the Dark Multiverse: The Death of Superman #1
- ↑ 41.0 41.1 41.2 41.3 Tales from the Dark Multiverse: Infinite Crisis #1
- ↑ Tales from the Dark Multiverse: Teen Titans: The Judas Contract #1
- ↑ Deathstroke (Volume 4) #46
- ↑ Deathstroke (Volume 4) #50
- ↑ Tales from the Dark Multiverse: Batman: Hush #1
- ↑ Tales from the Dark Multiverse: Wonder Woman: War of the Gods #1
- ↑ 47.0 47.1 47.2 Tales from the Dark Multiverse: Flashpoint #1
- ↑ 48.0 48.1 48.2 48.3 Tales from the Dark Multiverse: Crisis on Infinite Earths #1
- ↑ 49.0 49.1 49.2 49.3 49.4 The Flash (Volume 5) #33
- ↑ Justice League (Volume 3) #33
- ↑ The Batman Who Laughs (Volume 2) #6
- ↑ Dark Nights: Metal #5
- ↑ Dark Nights: Death Metal Infinite Hour Exxxtreme! #1
- ↑ Jim Johnson (June 19, 2020). 'Dark Nights: Death Metal - Scott Snyder Confirms Red Bat's Identity'. CBR.com. Retrieved on July 2, 2020.
- ↑ 55.0 55.1 Sideways Annual #1
- ↑ The Batman Who Laughs (Volume 2) #5
- ↑ The Batman Who Laughs (Volume 2) #3
- ↑ 58.0 58.1 58.2 58.3 58.4 58.5 DC Nation (Volume 2) #4
- ↑ 59.0 59.1 59.2 59.3 59.4 59.5 59.6 Sideways #8
- ↑ The Batman Who Laughs (Volume 2) #7
- ↑ Sideways #9
- ↑ The Batman Who Laughs (Volume 2) #2
- ↑ Justice League (Volume 4) #54
- ↑ The Flash (Volume 5) #70
- ↑ Heroes in Crisis #1
- ↑ The Batman Who Laughs (Volume 2) #1
- ↑ 67.0 67.1 67.2 67.3 67.4 67.5 The Darkfather stated that all the Dark Multiverse counterparts of Superman are tyrants who rule over humanity.
- ↑ Dark Nights: Death Metal The Last 52: War of the Multiverses #1
- ↑ The Batman Who Laughs (Volume 2) #4
- ↑ Dark Nights: Metal #4
- ↑ Justice League (Volume 4) #22
- ↑ Dark Days: The Casting #1
- ↑ Green Lantern: Blackstars #2
- ↑ 74.0 74.1 Black Adam #5
- ↑ 75.0 75.1 Hawkgirl (Volume 2) #6
- ↑ Harley Quinn (Volume 4) #37
- ↑ Wonder Woman Annual (Volume 5) #2