
I love Shannon Hale. I've read her YA fiction, and I've gone through the Bayern books more than once. I hold her on a high I'll-read-this-aloud-to-my-babies pedestal. That being said, her adult fiction stinketh.
The Actor and the Housewife was such a disappointment.
If you're planning on reading this book don't read this post. I hope my not liking it doesn't ruin your experience. There are several 5-star ratings on goodreads for this book.
I gave it a 2-star rating. It made me laugh and cry, and that's why it got an extra star. I like books that can do that. But there were so many things that bothered me I would never recommend it. Unless you're simply curious ... and you're a fast reader. :)
Can a married woman be best soulmate friends with a man other than her spouse? Possibly. Should she? No. Absolutely not. Why marry a man you're not compatible enough with to have a real friendship? Eldon and I aren't exactly peas in a pod, but we laugh and laugh and laugh together. We're such good friends I wonder how any friendship before him fulfilled me. The fact that Becky "loves" her husband Mike and is "committed" to her marriage while flying off for weekends with another man makes me gag. Are you reading this, Honey? I'd never do that. Or want to do that. Or admit it if I were even remotely tempted to do that. :) And if you ever wanted to do it, or asked me if you could, or anything remotely similar to those two things I think I'd laugh. I wouldn't realize you were serious. If you didn't laugh with me you'd be in big trouble. :) Mike tells Becky, "I'm having a hard time with this." and "I don't understand." and "I trust you. Do what you feel you need to do." And she DOES it. Sheesh. What are her kids thinking, watching all this?
AND, and, Hale plays it all up like it's some kind of gift from God that she had this special friendship with a man because Becky's husband dies later in the book and Felix helps her through it. Moral of the story: Make friends with a backup man in case you need "platonic" comfort later in the form of cuddles on the couch and long, hand-holding conversations? I just threw up in my mouth. Honey, are you reading this? I would never, under any circumstances, do that. If you're going to move on and date, then move on and date. By all means. But don't sell it to yourself and to your kids that that's what a platonic relationship is like. For the love.
AND AND AND, no amount of token kissing etc. will ever make it up to a spouse if you tell them another person of the opposite gender completes you. Seriously. Eldon, I love you and I'm so glad I married you and you're the man of my dreams and I can't imagine a happier life than the one we share together ... but in order to be 100% honest with myself and my personal needs I need to have an intimate, talk-all-night-on-the-phone, take-weekend-holidays-alone-together relationship with a man who's not you. But don't worry, if it bothers you I'll stop, but I'll become a shell of the woman I once was until you tell me I can again. Can you imagine treating your spouse that way? Honey, are you still reading this? I hope you already know I'd never do that. Or want to do that. Ever. Worlds without end. :)
I recently got back in touch with an old ex, and while I liked it the first couple times we chatted online, I'd rather just talk to Eldon. Nothing against the guy, it doesn't make him a bad person or mean that his friendship isn't worthwhile ... for someone else. But I can't imagine needing him - or anyone - the way Becky needs Felix. I do support the idea that women and girls need other women and girls as friends. I will probably always need a handful of ladies I can welcome into my heart and trust them to tread kindly. But I don't need guy friends.
Anyway, back to the book. Shannon Hale is entertaining, but her adult fiction is very unrealistic. I think this book was marketed to a general audience too, and it's so full of Mormon-ness I wonder what a non-LDS person would think. "So
that's how they get through polygamy." Wrong. Wrongwrongwrong. And I don't like that Becky's supposed to be the epitome of a mainstream, typical Mormon woman. No, some of us actually do really
love our husbands, thank you.