Post your icons and receive feedback to grow

Hi you guys. I made a couple icons today and I like the effect on them, but I'm unsure as to which one looks better.

or



Originals here and here.

Just recently, I began making black and white icons. I'm quite proud of some of my results, but I'm pretty sure there is a lot of room for improvement. What do you think?

 


The first one is my second icon ever made almost two years ago, it's been awhile.
On the second all I did was color it. But i'm wondering does it look awkward? It was pretty wide before i resized it.
The third. Ehh? I'm not that fond of it.
And the fourth I was just kinda expermienting.
Thoughts?

I'm fairly new to icon-making and would like some feedback/constructive criticism.

( Read more...Collapse )

What do you think? Feedback? Helpful pointers? Anything? :)

( always welcome a helping handCollapse )

Hello,
I am fairly new to making icons. I would love some advice. I really want to know how my cropping looks and how textures are flowing with the photos and and text. I also just want to make sure that the 100x100 is right to. Thanks!

Would you be so kind as to give me some pointers on these, everyone?

( I have no idea what to put as my cut text.Collapse )

I am still very new to icon making, so all comments are very much appreciated! I'm always ready to learn, so whatever constructive feedback you can give me would be great.

Thank you in advance.




Thanks. ^^

So... recently I started experimenting with textures and I would like some opinions on the results. All of them had been entered in icontests so to some extend I already had feedback on how they were received, but I'd like a bit more detail about how I could improve.

( 7 icons behind cutCollapse )