RottenTomatoes.com has a cute mini-gallery following the history of Holmes on the big screen:
24 Frames: The History of Holmes. It's enjoyable.
After Basil Rathbone's films, the gallery lists
A Study in Terror (1965) and
says this:
"In his first story written for the big screen, Sherlock (this time portrayed by John Neville) sniffs out Jack the Ripper's bloody trail."
I'm glad they found an excuse to squeeze in
A Study in Terror... but I'm not sure what that excuse is. "His first story written for the big screen" isn't right, since there were plenty of stories, adapted and original, on the big screen already; most of Rathbone's Holmes stories were contemporary originals of him fighting Nazis. If they meant the first story written for the big screen since Rathbone, then that was
The Hound of the Baskervilles (1959) with Peter Cushing as Holmes. I bet they meant the first original story since Rathbone. But whatever, I'm being picky. It's Holmes vs. Jack the Ripper, it should be listed at all costs.
Then it says this: "Robert Downey Jr. is the first actor invited back to play the big-screen character again since Basil Rathbone."
My first reaction was, "no way, there's been a ton of Holmes," and then I went to find one. Surely Peter Cushing played him twice, but I checked: he was in Hound in 1959 on the big screen, but all his subsequent portrayals were TV including The Masks of Death in 1984. Vasili Livanov - nope, his were TV movies. Christopher Lee, TV movies. Jeremy Brett, while very popular, was solely on the Granada channel. There have been plenty of actors portraying Holmes multiple times, but all on television or straight-to-video movies. It's been 72 years since the same actor played Holmes on the big screen for a second time. Mind = blown.
Of the sixteen films/series' listed, I've seen all but two:
Sherlock Holmes (1922) with John Barrymore and
The Speckled Band (1931) with Raymond Massey. This needs to be rectified.
And of course I will be seeing
Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows later this week. Midnight showing, yeah!