Ever since I first heard that the TV adaptation of these novellas was going to go ahead, I've been crossing everything that they'd do a good job. The novellas are a great bit of (mostly) contained storytelling in a franchise that is otherwise notable for its narrative sprawl. Plus, I've loved both Dunk and Egg since I first read The Hedge Knight in the Legends anthology back when it came out just before the turn of the millennium.
And you know, as it turns out, the show really, really does not disappoint. First of all, the casting is spot on, starting with Egg. If Dexter Sol Ansell had not existed, they would have had to create him. Like Gwendoline Christie being cast as Brienne of Tarth in GoT, I can't imagine another actor being so perfect for a role. Dexter was still only nine when they shot this, but he'd already been acting for five years. Amazing. Meanwhile, I saw Peter Claffey in an interview saying that many actors could have done justice to Dunk, but only Dexter was right to play Egg. I agree with half of that. Peter inhabits Dunk. At this point, I can't imagine another actor being him. I'm also super happy with the supporting cast, but especially Bertie Carvel as Prince Baelor Breakspear Targaryen and Daniel Ings as Ser Lyonel Baratheon aka the Laughing Storm. I really liked Bertie Carvel in the title role of Dalgliesh and he brings that same sort thoughtful but authoritative calm to Baelor. Perfect. Meanwhile, Daniel Ings has the charisma that the Laughing Storm requires.
I'm also really happy with the script and the direction. ( Spoilery stuff for the end of episode 4 + episode 5 under here )
And you know, as it turns out, the show really, really does not disappoint. First of all, the casting is spot on, starting with Egg. If Dexter Sol Ansell had not existed, they would have had to create him. Like Gwendoline Christie being cast as Brienne of Tarth in GoT, I can't imagine another actor being so perfect for a role. Dexter was still only nine when they shot this, but he'd already been acting for five years. Amazing. Meanwhile, I saw Peter Claffey in an interview saying that many actors could have done justice to Dunk, but only Dexter was right to play Egg. I agree with half of that. Peter inhabits Dunk. At this point, I can't imagine another actor being him. I'm also super happy with the supporting cast, but especially Bertie Carvel as Prince Baelor Breakspear Targaryen and Daniel Ings as Ser Lyonel Baratheon aka the Laughing Storm. I really liked Bertie Carvel in the title role of Dalgliesh and he brings that same sort thoughtful but authoritative calm to Baelor. Perfect. Meanwhile, Daniel Ings has the charisma that the Laughing Storm requires.
I'm also really happy with the script and the direction. ( Spoilery stuff for the end of episode 4 + episode 5 under here )



