That was phase ONE. I wasn't loving the khaki green shutters or the gray door for that matter. I was happy with the white trim. So I kept going and painted the garage doors.
EASY! and no drama. But drama was heading my way. I wanted to paint the shutters when the weather warmed up. I actually bought a gallon of black paint for them when I bought the white trim paint. But by the time it warmed up, I had changed my mind. I wanted gray shutters. Of course the gray door that didn't look so great to start with had to change. Yay more paint!! I wanted a medium gray for the shutters. I had just bought and used my first Annie Sloan paint and loved the color. I had used it HERE
And HERE
An all around good gray. It's called French Linen. Well . . . I didn't want to spend a fortune to buy enough Annie Sloan paint to do my shutters, plus although the website said they use it for exteriors, I wasn't so confident. I'll just match it, I thought. I thought wrong. I had Home Depot try to match it. At least at Home Depot I could buy $3 samples, but when they were unsuccessful, I tried Sherwin Williams. All they do is paint right? They tried twice and I had to buy two quarts at almost $20 a piece. That trickster Annie Sloan had somehow made it so people had to buy her paint. I still didn't think chalk paint would hold up, so I went to my Benjamin Moore paint deck and found a color that looked like the French Linen. It was called Galveston Gray. It was almost identical. GRRRR! Here's a pic of me trying to get it right.
I painted all of the lower shutters myself and my sweet, reluctant, daredevil husband did all of the uppers. Everything was looking awesome UNTIL . . . I painted the shutters on the siding. Sad face. Ignore the yellow side door, that's next.
The gray almost looked like the same color as the tan siding. But this was the last shutter that we painted, and I was not about to tell my sweet, reluctant, daredevil husband that we needed to choose a new color. Especially after all the Annie Sloan drama. I am not THAT dumb. So I moved onto the door. SPOILER ALERT in the last photo!!
I had a few colors in mind. Yellow, robin egg blue or teal. Funny thing. Looking at this photo makes me realize that I'd tried to paint the door a lighter gray than the charcoal at some point I guess! My poor neighbor across from me. I'd call her and say "which one?" She'd look out her window and give me her opinion.
Yes, I know how ridiculous I am, but it's just sorta my thing. It makes me happy to paint things. (AND by the way, I did get on Sherwin Williams and tried out different shutter and door colors on a picture of my own house that I downloaded before I started buying samples.) I was outside one day and just was sick of the shutters over the garage fading into the siding. I wanted something that popped. So I tried darker grays, black (the paint I had bought 3 years before) and navy.
I decided in the process that I was fighting the tan siding and orange brick. I really wanted a gray house, but I am not going to paint the siding and I don't think the HOA would be thrilled if I painted the brick as much as I'd like to. Well, have someone else paint it for me. So I chose Hale Navy by Benjamin Moore. I liked it with the yellow. The brick looked okay and I loved it on the siding.
I liked it all, so I moved around the front of the house and painted all of the bottom shutters navy. Corey agreed to take down the upper ones, so that I could paint them. It required more coats than the last time and I didn't want him up on the ladder for that long. Now here comes some more drama. When the light hits the front ones in the afternoon, they sorta look (dare I say?) purple. I panicked. Of course I did right. Come on this was the second time painting the shutters in 3 years and I wanted to get it right, so I went and bought a darker navy. I tried it on one set of shutters and it looked just plain old black. I don't really want to talk about how long I stared at the stupid shutters at all different times of the day. My poor across the street neighbor sat with me on the lawn at her house discussing the subtle nuances of the two navy choices. I already said that I know I'm ridiculous. Stop laughing!
See that it looks black? I wasn't ready to give up my navy. In hindsight, I probably should have gone with the darker navy. Or just removed all the shutters altogether. I think if I ever build a house, I will forego shutters.
| Darker navy on the left. Hale Navy on the right. |
Wow, the lawn looks really green.
I got so fed up thinking about it, not to mention having to repaint all the lower shutters, that I went with Hale Navy. Got those suckers painted and back up, and washed my hands of it. Let me sum up. I like the navy shutters better than the gray ones, and I will never paint them again. At least I will never involve my husband in painting the shutters ever again. POOR GUY!
Remember before?
It wasn't hideous before, but I like it better now. I might hire someone with a really tall ladder and no fear to paint the trim on the roof line white. I'm not sending Corey back up on that ladder; not that he would do it anyway.










