Put Out that Star - Harry Carmichael

THE STORY: Movie actress Madeleine Grey leaves the set of her film in progress up in Scotland to travel to London where she plans to meet with her insurance agent John Piper. Shortly before the meeting she appears to have vanished from the hotel. No one saw her leave: not Quinn, Piper's reporter friend waiting in the lobby; not the receptionist; not even the elevator operator. Where did she go? And how did she get out unseen? This apparent impossible mystery is soon complicated by two deaths, one a questionable accident and the other a definite murder.

THE CHARACTERS: Put Out That Star (1957) first attracted my attention because it was listed in Adey's Locked Room Murders as being an impossible mystery.  But the ostensible mystery surrounding Madeleine's disappearance is easily figured out.  Not just because there were multiple ways to leave the hotel (an emergency exit door leading to a fire escape, and a stairwell that leads to the ground floor right near the brasserie and cocktail bar) but because of the rather obvious way anyone can leave unnoticed. And I figured that part out instantly. But the story is a gripping one for the way Piper approaches the problem, for the intriguing friendship between Quinn, the nosy and often intrusive reporter who is friends with Piper, and the way Carmichael handles the supporting players who all seem to be acting a little too suspiciously or too indifferently regarding the disappearance of a celebrity guest in the hotel.

The oddest of the suspects is Sydney Noble, the hotel assistant manager who first treats Madeleine's disappearance aloofly.  She'll turn up, he says repeatedly to Piper. But when days pass with no sign of the actress he gets nervous and worries about the hotel's reputation being damaged. That's on the surface. In reality he's more worried about himself and his job. He manages to convince Piper to turn private agent to try and locate the movie star before the press gets hold of the news and before he may be forced to call the police. Piper reluctantly agrees more because he wants his own curiosity satisfied.

Piper also interviews Mrs. Airey. the hotel housekeeper for the third floor where Madeleine was staying, and learns about the flawed fire escape door that cannot be properly closed from the inside of the hotel. He also deals with Benny Seagar, talent agent, who has a couple of secrets he'd rather be left buried. But Piper digs them up all the same. Then there's Roy Mitchell, Madeleine's husband and the scriptwriter on her film. When his wife does not call him at 9 pm as they agreed he calls the hotel and learns that his wife is not there. He insists on driving down to the hotel and plans to do so in a single night.

INNOVATIONS: It's a shame the impossibility of sorts is so unimaginative. With the introduction of a single character at the story's midpoint it's fairly simple to solve the problem of how Madeleine left the hotel. Much of the mystery involves the recurring discussion of Madeleine and her fur coat which made her distinctively noticeable for anyone who a wasn't a film buff and could recognize her by her face. The fur coat is missing from her hotel room, though all of her luggage and clothing was left behind. Some bloodstains on one of her suitcases and the used washcloth in the bathroom are two major clues that bother Piper for the entirety of the story. They are also clues to figuring out what happened to Madeleine.

Carmichael has a neat way in rendering cinematic action sequences. The story opens on February 27 and play outs over the following three days. The winter season plays a major part in the story and a severe winter gale acts as a menacing minor character endangering Piper's life as he pursues a lead involving a missing movie magazine. The outdoor sequences are handled sinisterly with the threatening weather conditions becoming almost a persona of villainy itself. These lent a noirish feel to the novel.

THE AUTHOR: "Harry Carmichael" was a pseudonym used by Leopold Ognall (1908-1979) who was born in Montreal then emigrated with his family to Scotland. In his early adulthood Ognall moved to Leeds where he married in 1932 and remained there for the rest of his life. He worked as a goods manager, a warehouse employee and was an ARP warden during the war years. He began his writing career as a journalist for a Scottish newspaper and apparently later gave up it to become a full time novelist. He wrote at least 84 novels using two different pseudonyms. As "Harry Carmichael" his mystery novels feature either John Piper or Quinn or both and follow the dictates of traditional whodunit style mysteries while as "Hartley Howard" he created Glenn Bowman, a private eye, and Philip Scott, a British Intelligence agent.

EASY TO FIND? There are a handful of the paperback reprint (Fontana Books #286, 1959) editions offered for sale from online booksellers. The UK 1st edition is rather scarce and I turned up only one copy with the equally scarce DJ from a well known vintage crime fiction seller on eBay. Five copies of the US edition retitled Into thin Air (Doubleday/Crime Club, 1958) are available for purchase, all with the DJ.

Exit to Music - Neal Shepherd (aka Nigel Morland)

THE STORY: Chief Inspector Michael "Napper" Tandy attends a party at the home of musician John Farnham for what he thinks will be a private performance of a new composition for piano, violin, cello and clarinet. After being dared to attempt a complicated clarinet passage in the new piece Farnham drops dead. He's been poisoned with strychnine. Everyone is sure that the whisky he drank was poisoned but Tandy proves that Farnham never drank from the glass. How was the poison administered?  Was it that specially ordered bowl of sweet almonds that Farnham was so fond of? Or some other way?

THE CHARACTERS: There certainly are a lot of suspects to choose from and a many of them seem to have strong motives.

Myra Farnham - The victim's young and (of course) beautiful wife who seems to be the object of many of the musicians' attention. She's the only woman in the story which should come as no surprise to those familiar with the "Neal Shepherd" books which tend to deal with realms of übermacho businessmen and maverick scientists and engineers. In this case the world we are visiting is the milieu of contemporary composers of new chamber music. Not one female musician among them. Ugh. But Myra is presented as sensitive, intelligent and a bit complicated.  She is discussed at length rhapsodically by the men but when Tandy
finally interviews her he finds a woman of intelligence, indomitable spirit and a repressed independence.

Felix Hinton - the founder of a modern music quartet (piano, cello, violin, clarinet). He teaches violin to college students and gives private lessons to budding musicians. Not well thought of by the other members of his quartet. He is obsessed with Myra having once been engaged to her but losing her to Farnham, the clarinet player. Felix also has some depression issues and when his violin case reveals a hidden bottle of strychnine he descends into his morass never to return.

Dr. David Wylie - one of Myra's closest friends who has managed to move in with the Farnhams. Tandy soon learns that Wylie was receiving large payments from Farnham related to stock manipulations. Wylie is a gambler both in casinos and in the stock market. His medical case was broken into and the poison used to kill Farnham was certainly taken from a bottle stolen from him. Arrogant, suspicious and his greed knows no bounds. Tandy discovers nearly everyone in the house
was approached by Wylie who asked for loans of large sums of money.

Leslie Farnham - the victim's son.  Currently a 4th year medical student.  He asked for strychnine from Dr. Wylie to experiment with because his toxicology classes were fascinating to him.  That's what he claims. But was he planning to kill? Has a very eccentric religious belief system he calls "New Morality".  Has written a manifesto that Tandy finds among the young man's possessions. Comes across as a religious maniac to Sgt. Holland.  Tandy, however, sees Leslie's extreme beliefs as thoroughly sincere if utterly dispassionate and lacking in humanity. Views his father's death as a just end the result of Divine Intervention for his adultery and betrayal of his first wife, Leslie's mother Lily, who is long dead at the start of the novel.

Brian Tweed - composer who has finagled his way into the Farnham household as a lodger. Pretentious wanna-be, known to mimic the behavior, speech and dress of well known artists, writers and musicians. Still Myra finds him charming and he exploits his rare moments of charm in manipulating others.

Medlicone - Farnham family lawyer who talks with Tandy about the strange will that gave Farnham his wealth and cheated Dr. Wylie out of a fortune he thought he was going to inherit. The lawyer also provides some very interesting details about the odd financial relationship between Farnham and Wylie that seems to have bound Farnham to his lodger.  Also, early in the book and during the music party the lawyer inadvertently reveals the contents of Farnham's will and who will inherit what.

Anton Cheveral - cellist in the quartet. A despicable gossip who enjoys maligning everyone involved in the case. Builds on rumors of Myra's infidelity with two different men and disparges all the musicians, especially Farnham's lack of skill with the clarinet.

Jarvis - butler in the Farnham household.  Devoted to his former mistress Lily Farhman. Myra is treated with disdain by the butler. Slightly sinister in his omniscience of what goes on in the house. His refusal to accept the new Mrs. Farnham gives off a strong Mrs. Danvers vibe. I thought he was a baddie for most of the book.

Douglas Rome - clarinetist in the quartet. He dares Farnham to play the clarinet solo in the piece by composer Holt Linray (who does not appear in story).  When Farnham dies Rome flees the house without anyone noticing him.  Tandy sends police off to locate him.  Rome never appears again in the book.  Odd little plot element that I thought would pan out to a surprise, but nothing really comes of this.

INNOVATIONS: The murder method is diabolical and worthy of John Rhode's complicated death traps. Obviously I'm not going to discuss it. But I will mention that the portion of the book in which Tandy and Holland together review evidence about the whisky glass determining it could not have been used to administer the poison (even though the glass contains enough strychnine to kill five men) is extremely well done.  Overall, there is an emphasis on excellent detective work related to physical evidence.

Morland's fascination with abnormal psychology is on strong display here. By the mid 1940s and beyond this aspect of crime led Morland to write some non-fiction works on criminal pathology. In Leslie Farnham, the victim's son, Morland has created quite a religious zealot. He may remind modern readers of the new crop of neo-conservatives trying to revert Christian beliefs back dozens of centuries to the days of antiquity when God was truly the only Force to reckon with and the laws of men were negligible. Morland also delves into the consequences of men who become obsessed with women and the danger of falling in love and never getting over rejection. Felix Hinton suffers from an obsessive attraction to the victim's widow coupled with severe depression and it leads to his own demise.

Nigel Morland (1905-1986)
(aka Neal Shepherd, John Donavan,
Roger Garnett, et al.)

In the final pages Morland also attempted to introduce a moral dilemma for Tandy in his dual professions. he is not only a policeman but a scientist. Throughout the book some of the characters refer to him as Dr. Tandy. MD or PhD? I was never really sure. Tandy in previous books uses his knowledge of chemistry to help him in solving impossibilities in the murders he investigates.  But in this book he also acts as a physician.  In any case, during one crucial scene a character while recovering from a poisoning attempt and in a delirium re-enacts a conversation with another suspect. This rambling "conversation" reveals the murderer's motivation. Tandy doesn't know how to act on this. Has he eavesdropped? Has he heard this in a capacity as a physician? If so, then it's private and should not be revealed. But can he use this information he has overheard as a policeman to help capture the criminal?

Interesting idea, but I found the whole scene utterly contrived in that an entire conversation is re-enacted in a form of delirium and yet is done lucidly and clearly to deliver all the salient points. Other than that flaw in the story I thought this was the best of the Chief Inspector Tandy detective novels. It's rich with complicated characters, psychology and is teeming with wonderful detection set pieces throughout the story.  Even Sgt. Holland gets his due in three scenes when Tandy asks for his insights. 

And now the bad news... Ridiculously scarce! I think it's a genuinely rare book. My copy was the only one I've come across in over 20 years of looking for the book. And it's gone already. Sold to a lucky reader in Australia. Good luck finding another. Perhaps in a library in the UK, Canada or Australia? There must be a copy...somewhere!