*Artists In Crime* by Ngaio Marsh
Jan. 11th, 2026 05:05 pmDiscussion prompts:
- How does Inspector Alleyn's professional eye for detail assist in his first meeting with Troy Alleyn?
- Inspector Alleyn's interrogation/interview techniques vary from suspect to suspect. What did this achieve for him? Do you think he was good at his job?
- This book has a large set of artistic suspects from varying backgrounds. Did the author convey the individuals well enough, or were they mostly a jumble for readers? Was there an artist you would have liked to hear more about?
- Has anyone tried sketching or posing for figure drawings? Did the author convey well enough what was going on with the artist model's poses and behavior and how that may have contributed to potential motives?
- Does the book make the solution to the complicated mystery clear? Did you think you knew the murderer before the end?
- Did the romance get in the way of the mystery or enhance it?
- One of the people from the boat trip at the beginning of the book is very vocally attracted to Alleyn's British-ness and hounds him, which contributes to Alleyn and Troy's initial issues. Have you ever known anyone who aggressively pursued anyone because of being so into British people? Do you think Marsh was parodying/criticizing someone in particular, or just an American "type" she'd noticed?
- What did you think of the use of epistolary writings (letters/diary entries from the first part that re-surface later in the book)?
- How do Inspector Alleyn's encounters with Troy in this book compare to Lord Peter Wimsey's encounters with Harriet Vane in Dorothy Sayers' *Strong Poison*?
- What are other similarities between those protagonists' romances and families? Do you think Marsh was consciously imitating or trying to improve on / contrast with Dorothy Sayers' characters, or were her characters' characteristics/arcs an inevitable part of Golden Age mysteries?
- Would this 1938 book still hold up as a mystery if the problematic aspects were modernized out? Did they spoil the book for you, or were they not so bad as that?
- Would you recommend this book to other mystery fans?
Resources:
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artists_in_Crime
- https://newbookrecommendation.com/summary-of-artists-in-crime-by-ngaio-marsh-a-detailed-synopsis/ (includes more detailed major characters explanation)
- https://www.shedunnitshow.
com/ ngaiomarshgoeshometranscript/ (or listen to the podcast episode from that page) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_Poison