Yes, but is it the web?
What is the web? I’ve been working in the web since the beginning of the web, and I co-chaired the W3C Technical Architecture Group for over a decade, so you think I might be able to answer this simple question. Some think anything you can do “in the browser” is the web and anything that happens outside the browser (such as in a native app) isn’t the web. However, you can have very non-webby experiences in the browser and likewise apps can sometimes be very webby. I think the web isn’t only the browser. It’s a system of globally addressable, linkable resources, built on open standards, that anyone can access, implement, and connect to. When I’m using Mastodon via an app on my phone, I’m still using the web. The Fediverse is the web. It’s linkable. It’s porous. It doesn’t lock you in. Today, I got to thinking about what a set of tests might be for a digital service, where if you can answer “yes” to all of them, then it’s most probably the web. Here’s what I came up with: Is it globally addressable? Is it linkable across boundaries? Is it built on open, interoperable standards? Is it client-agnostic? Can you move or replicate your presence without permission? Does this look right? Is this a meaningful or useful question to ask?