Several years ago I received an unexpected Christmas gift.
It was Christmas of 2011. Christmas was on a Sunday that year. I had spent much of the month of December anticipating and preparing, looking forward to how wonderful Christmas was going to be for my kids and my family. As Christmas Eve approached, I had a beautiful vision in my mind of how perfect everything was going to be. The vision in my head looked something like this:
Christmas Eve would be a fun day of decorating cookies, wrapping the last of the presents, listening to Christmas music all day long, and preparing our special Christmas Eve dinner. We would enjoy a lovely dinner together as a family, have a spiritual lesson about the birth of Christ, and then my girls would get their new Christmas pajamas and we’d take our traditional Christmas Eve family photos. We’d put out cookies for Santa and the girls would be off to bed. In the morning we’d be awakened bright and early by very excited children. The girls would put on their beautiful new Christmas dresses and we’d go to church together where we’d be filled with the Spirit. Then we’d come home and have a wonderful time opening presents and spend the rest of the day relaxing together, playing with new toys, and eating lots of good food.
Sounds perfect, right?
Well, this is how it actually went:
The week before Christmas, my youngest was very sick. So I spent all day on Christmas Eve caring for a sick and miserable 18-month old who wanted to be held constantly. My day full of Christmas music turned into a day full of Barney, because that’s the only thing she wanted. So we listened to Barney. All. Day. Long. All of the Christmas preparations were done in a frenzied fashion, whenever I could squeeze a moment in between trying to console her, force medicine down her, and get her to let me put her down. By the end of the day, I was frazzled and frustrated. The kids wouldn’t touch the beautiful Christmas Eve dinner I had prepared, and our traditional Christmas Eve photos were not exactly full of smiles. By this point, our spiritual lesson had gone out the window. We decided to just put the cookies out for Santa and get the kids to bed. Just as my oldest was picking out the cookies, she said that her tummy really hurt. And then she threw up. A lot.
I was up all night, obsessively checking on my sick kids, watching for more throw-up from my 4-year-old and trying to console a feverish and miserable 18-month-old.
Sometime around 3 am, as I was worrying and fretting about my sick kids and thinking about all of my wonderful Christmas plans that had gone down the drain and all of my expectations that hadn’t been met, I found myself thinking about Mary. I had been asked to narrate the part of Mary in our church Christmas program the next morning, so she was on my mind.
I would guess that when Mary found out she would be giving birth to the Son of God, she didn’t envision that she would be giving birth far away from her home, out in a dirty stable, because there was no room for her anywhere else. Those aren’t exactly the ideal conditions for having a baby. That’s probably not what she expected.
But that is why we have Christmas.
We have Christmas because a perfect baby was born in imperfect circumstances, in an imperfect world.
We have Christmas because that perfect baby grew up to be a perfect man who would allow all of us to overcome our own imperfections and “be perfected in Him.” (Moroni 10:32)
We have Christmas because that perfect One loves each of us perfectly – in spite of our imperfections.
During those moments of reflection in the early Christmas morning hours, I came a lot closer to understanding what Christmas is really all about. While there are so many beautiful, wonderful things to enjoy during this season, you could take all of them away, and the real reason for Christmas – the real beauty of Christmas – would still be there.
Without the trees, the lights, the presents, the stockings, the treats and the feasts, Christ is still there.
Without the picture-perfect family moments - even without family at all – Christ is still there.
In fact, it is actually because of the less-than-perfect moments that Jesus Christ is there. So Christmas should not only be about the beauty and wonder and joy that we see in the movies and envision in our minds. Perhaps Christmas is even more about the ugliness and heartache and despair that we encounter in this fallen world.
With all of this in mind, I didn’t feel so disappointed or upset on Christmas morning when my sick girls didn’t even remember what day it was, or when their beautiful new Christmas dresses remained hanging in the closet while I had to leave my sick family to go to church alone. It didn’t matter that the rest of Christmas day wasn’t at all what I had envisioned or expected. I threw my expectations out the window and focused on what Christmas is really all about.
That is the wonderful gift that I received years ago. The gift of an imperfect Christmas.
The lessons of my imperfect
Christmas experience that year have extended far beyond fevers, vomit, uneaten
dinners, unworn dresses, and unmet expectations. Since that time, I have gone
through some holidays with deep heartache. Life, as it so often does for all of
us, has brought a multitude of agonizing challenges and heavy burdens. When I
am struggling with disappointment or discouragement, I often reflect on the
lesson I learned that Christmas.
Sometimes in our lives we do experience the joy, the beauty, and the wonder. Sometimes we do have those picture-perfect moments that we envision in our minds.
But sometimes – often – things don’t go according to our plans, no matter how good or well thought out our plans may be. Sometimes, despite all of our righteous desires and intentions and expectations, our circumstances in life are less than ideal.
Sometimes we are disappointed. Sometimes we face discouragement, depression, and even despair.
Sometimes we must deal with sickness, pain, and disease.
Sometimes we face death and loss and consuming grief.
Sometimes we are violated or betrayed or hurt by others.
Sometimes we mess up.
Sometimes the people we love mess up.
Sometimes things are simply beyond our control.
Sometimes life is just not fair, and there is no reason or explanation.
Our mortal experience here on earth is far from perfect. But that is why we have Christmas: because our Heavenly Father gave us the greatest gift of all, the gift of a Savior. He gave us a Savior so that when life is imperfect and difficult and downright ugly, we can find healing and hope and we can overcome. He gave us a Savior so that despite how imperfect we are, despite how imperfect everyone around us is, despite how imperfect this world is, we can all ultimately “be perfected in Him.” (Moroni 10:32)
The gift of an imperfect Christmas that year taught me to stop chasing after holiday perfection and instead let all the imperfections and disappointments and messiness be a beautiful reminder to me of what Christmas is truly all about: why that baby was born in a stable, why we are celebrating His birth. It’s a lesson I need to remind myself of every year. It’s a lesson I need to remember throughout the entire year.



