Omission d’informations sur le risque suicidaire induit par les médicaments






Objet: Omission d’informations sur le risque suicidaire induit par les médicaments.
Chers Professeurs, chers Docteurs, chère Madame,
J’ai appris que le 10 septembre était la journée mondiale de prévention du suicide. Le 10 septembre 2021, mon fils Romain s’est suicidé à l’âge de 16 ans. Il était alors sous médication de Paroxétine et Tercian.
Emission «Enquête de Santé», diffusée sur France 5, le 28 février 2023, intitulée “Antidépresseurs, utiles ou dangereux?”
Enquête de santé : Antidépresseurs : utiles ou dangereux ? (France 5, 28/02/2023)
Le 2 Novembre 2024
À l’attention de
France Télévisions, Direction, Mme Delphine Ernotte Arcom, Direction, Mr Roch-Olivier Maistre
Copie:
Formindep, Direction, Dr Christian Guy-Coichard
Objet: Emission «Enquête de Santé», diffusée sur France 5, le 28 février 2023, intitulée “Antidépresseurs, utiles ou dangereux?”
Madame, Monsieur,
Je suis le père de Romain Schmitt, décédé par suicide à 16 ans, le 10 Septembre 2021, alors qu’il était sous médication paroxétine et tercian.
Suite aux démarches du Formindep et leur récent communiqué de presse voir [1], je souhaiterais revenir sur l’émission Enquête de Santé dont il est question et faire part, à titre personnel, à la direction de France TV et à l’Arcom, de mes remarques et de ma désapprobation.
Question : suicides induits par des traitements médicamenteux

16 août 2024
Cher Monsieur,
J’ai appris que le 10 septembre était la Journée mondiale de prévention du suicide. Le 10 septembre 2021, mon fils Romain s’est suicidé à l’âge de 16 ans.
D’après mes recherches depuis, je me demande si vous, la Cnam, n’êtes pas passés à côté d’un point qui aurait sauvé des vies, y compris celle de Romain. J’ai appris qu’il existe plus de 100 médicaments différents dont les effets secondaires peuvent entraîner la mort. Ceux-ci comprennent les antidépresseurs, les antipsychotiques, les benzodiazépines, les comprimés antipaludiques, les médicaments contre l’acné et certains antibiotiques.
Responses
- Cnam (assurance maladie) [response]
- 3114, numéro national de prévention du suicide
- Ministre de la santé [response]
- l’hôpital Robert-Debré, Service de psychiatrie de l’enfant et de l’adolescent [response][DH.org Blog]
- PSSM France [response]
Questions (Italy) [letter]
- Ministère de la Santé
- ISS (institut supérieur de la Santé)
- Secrétaire Général de la défense
- IASP ITALIA
Patient safety: a letter to the President of the Royal College of Psychiatrists

16th June 2024
To: Dr Lade Smith, CBE, President of the Royal College of Psychiatrists
Copied to: Dr Trudi Seneviratne, Registrar, Royal College of Psychiatrists, Professor Subodh Dave, Dean, Royal College of Psychiatrists, Sonia Walter, Chief Executive Officer, Royal College of Psychiatrists, Corinne Bishop, Director of Strategic Communications, Royal College of Psychiatrists, Elen Cook, Interim Director of Professional Standards
Dear Dr Lade Smith,
I am writing on behalf of a group of people who have suffered life changing harm from antidepressants.
[pdf]
Response to articles and corrections of factual inaccuracies in Daily Mail

August the 28th, 2023
To the attention of the Daily Mail editor and Eve Simmons.
Daily Mail, Northcliffe House, 2 Derry Street, London W8 5TT, United Kingdom
Subject: response to articles and corrections of factual inaccuracies.
Dear Eve,
I read your two newspaper articles entitled
Top psychiatrists warn patients could be put at risk by TV scaremongers ‘highlighting the risks of antidepressants’ in BBC documentary
Dylan’s suicide featured in the documentary… but it failed to mention that such cases are mercifully rare
published online respectively on the 19th and 20th of August.
Response from Daily Mail

Dear Mr Schmitt,
Thank you for your emails, which have been passed to this office.
Please accept my sincere condolences for your loss. I cannot begin to image how painful this subject must be for you and your fellow writers.
I have passed on your letter to Eve Simmons, and I have certainly made a note of your points. Although I cannot see that the article contains any significant inaccuracies which require correction, I am grateful for you taking the time and trouble to write to us.
Response to the President of the Royal College of Psychiatrists

27th August 2023
Drs Lade Smith and Adrian James
President
Royal College of Psychiatrists
London Office
21 Prescot Street London E1 8BB UK
0208 618 4000
Dear Drs Lade Smith and Adrian James
We are writing to Dr Smith, the current president of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, and Dr James, the past president, to pursue an issue raised by Dr James following a paper by Dr John Read on deaths by suicide at inquests in Great Britain.
Response from Dr Smith

It is worth me clarifying that the College’s press release that quoted Dr James did not state that it was a mistake to publish the
paper. I note in previous correspondence with some of you, Dr James noted that we issued this statement because of our
concern that the media reporting about the newly published research on coroner inquests and antidepressants did not provide a
balanced assessment of the overall association between antidepressants and suicide. The evidence shows that when
antidepressants are prescribed in line with guidance there is not a clinically significant increase in the risk of completed
suicides or suicidal behaviour. We believe it is important to ensure that there is clear public messaging on this aspect to ensure
those who are taking this medication, or who are considering doing so, understand why they are recommended and the overall
potential benefits to their health, as well as side effects that might occur with their use.
Response to the President of the Royal College of Psychiatrists again

3rd March 2024
Dear Dr Lade Smith
Thank you very much for your email. We still have some questions.
“Dr James noted that we issued this statement because of our concern that the media reporting about the newly published research on coroner inquests and antidepressants did not provide a balanced assessment of the overall association between antidepressants and suicide.
The evidence shows that when antidepressants are prescribed in line with guidance there is not a clinically significant increase in the risk of completed suicides or suicidal behaviour.”
1. We are not aware of such evidence. Please show us your evidence.
