………….with Vanilla Frosting and Truffle Glaze. Excited :)? Well lets get to the recipe then :)!
BUT, If you’ve not read the post on how this cake came about, I suggest you read, Trans-Continental Baking Experiment: A Chocolate Mud Cake, and then come right back here for the recipe.

Two Way Chocolate Mud Cake with Vanilla Frosting and Truffle Chocolate Glaze
This is my version of the original, and it came about not out of choice but out of the availability of ingredients in my pantry at that point, and I’m so glad I made this version. It was absolutely divine, if I may praise my own cake ;). The bottom layer of dark bitter chocolate coupled with the top layer of mildly sweet milk chocolate is a perfect combination. I made two cakes and layered them rather than make 1 single cake and cut it horizontally. If you want to make 1 cake and then cut it in half for layering, double the recipe of either the bottom layer or the top layer and note the sugar difference in the two layers too. I used lesser sugar in my bottom layer because I love bitter dark chocolate 🙂
INGREDIENTS:
Bottom Layer
175 grams good quality unsweetened bitter dark chocolate pieces
113 grams butter (1 stick)
300 ml water ….. this is approx 1 cup + 1/4 cup
2 eggs
100 grams castor sugar (sugar is lesser than top layer)
200 grams self raising flour (approx about 1 and 1/4 cup
2 teaspoon good quality cocoa powder
Top Layer:
175 grams good quality unsweetened milk chocolate pieces
113 grams butter (1 stick)
300 ml water ….. this is approx 1 cup + 1/4 cup
2 eggs
150 grams castor sugar
200 grams self raising flour (approx about 1 and 1/4 cup
2 teaspoon good quality cocoa powder.
PREP:
Grease and line a 8″ round cake tin. [Note, the original recipe calls for a 9” pan. Use a 9” pan if you double the ingredients and prefer to make 1 large cake and cut it rather than 2 cakes. If using a 9” cake pan make sure it is about 3”-4” high.]
Also keep ready enough baking paper to cover the top of the tin securely. Covering the top of the pan while baking reduces cracks and prevents the top of the cake from over browning.
Preheat oven to 170C/325F.
Mix the dry ingredients of flour, sugar and cocoa powder together till well incorporated and all lumps removed. Run through a sieve to break the lumps.
In a saucepan over low heat, heat chocolate and butter.
When this mixture is starting to melt, heat the 300ml water for about 40 seconds in the microwave till lightly warm.
When the chocolate/butter has completely melted….pour in the warm water and stir frequently until the entire mixture in the saucepan is melted and smooth. While adding the water you will notice that the mixture will be grainy for a while…this is ok but don’t stop stiring…continuing stiring the mixture till smooth.
Remove from the heat and cool slightly for about 5 to 7 minutes.
In the meantime, in a large bowl, lightly beat eggs one at a time i.e. break one egg into the bowl whisk it for 40 seconds with your electric mixer and then add the other egg and whisk for another 40 seconds.
Now gradually add the cooled chocolate mixture into eggs. Here it is recommended that you use your hand to whisk the mixture. Continue whisking the batter with your right hand while constantly pouring the chocolate mixture with the other hand. It is recommended not to use an electric mixer in this case because this batter is very runny and the mixer will create lots of bubbles which in turn might create cracks and tunnels in the cake while baking. If you have HAVE to use the electric mixer then beat at your lowest speed. But I strongly recommend you use your clean hands. Whisk the batter for about a minute.
Now add in the sugar, flour and cocoa mixture a little at a time into the chocolate/egg mixture, while continuing to stir the batter with your hand. When all the flour mixture has been added to the wet mixture, whisk well until smooth and well blended. Break any lumps with your hands. Continue mixing the batter for about 20 minutes in one direction with your hand. Remember not to change the direction of your hand. If you’ve been whisking in the clockwise direction continue clockwise. Yes your hand will ache :), but think of the lovely texture you’ll get.
Pour mixture into the prepared cake tin. Cover the top of the cake tin with baking paper and press to seal the edges with your fingertips. Put the cake mixture in the center of the rack in the oven. Close the oven and DO NOT OPEN till the baking time is up. If you MUST MUST check the cake in between do so only about 30 minutes of baking time is up, else the draught from outside will enter the oven and cause the cake to drop.
Bake for 45 minutes. Check with a skewer or knife by inserting into the centre of the cake. If the knife/skewer comes out clean, your cake is done…if not bake for another 3-4 minutes checking every 2 minutes. Remove from oven when done…let it sit in the pan for 5-10 minutes and then turn cake onto wire rack or plate to cool.

Bitter Dark Chocolate Bottom Layer
Bake the 2nd layer exactly the same way.

White Chocolate Top Layer
Now before you add the cut the dome/rise in the middle to level the cake, put the cakes in the freezer for about 30 minutes. Freezing the cake reduces the crumbs when you cut it in half.
While the cake is in the freezer prepare your vanilla frosting.
VANILLA FROSTING
INGREDIENTS:
1 cup (1/2 lb.) unsalted butter, at room temperature
1 1/2 cups (1 lb.) powdered sugar, sifted…add 1/2 cup more sugar if you want it sweeter.
1/8 teaspoon salt
2 tablespoons cream
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
PREP:
In a bowl, whisk on low speed butter, powdered sugar, and the salt until blended and smooth. Add cream and vanilla; beat until blended. Turn mixer to high speed and beat frosting until fluffy and smooth.
Your frosting is Ready!
Now take your cake out of the freezer, level the top of the two cakes by cutting off the slice dome/rise in the middle (if any).

The Two Layers Ready for Frosting
Layer the vanilla frosting on both the cakes on the side you leveled off. Layer it nice and thick. Refrigerate for about 20 minutes.
In the meantime make the Truffle Glaze. This is the exact recipe as found here . Note, in the original recipe, the truffle mixture was used as the middle layer frosting. I used it as my glaze on top of the cake with one small modification. I added chocolate sprinkles for that grain-stony mud feel.
TRUFFLE CHOCOLATE GLAZE
INGREDIENTS:120 grams dark chocolate pieces
100 grams butter
300 grams sifted icing sugar
4 tbsp double or whipping cream
30 grams chocolate sprinklers (optional)
PREP:
In a bowl over a pan of simmering water, melt the chocolate, stirring frequently. Make sure no water enters the chocolate mixture. Add the chocolate sprinkler. Stir. The chocolate mixture will be grainy because the chocolate sprinklers do not melt completely. Cool slightly, then stir icing sugar, butter and cream until well blended.
Your Truffle Chocolate Glaze is ready
Remove the cake from the refrigerator and pour the truffle chocolate glaze over it and spread it around.

Cake Layered with Truffle Chocolate Glaze
Decorate. Let it stand for about 30 minutes, then cut and enjoy a piece of heaven 🙂

A Slice of the Two Way Chocolate Mud Cake