Too Long To Wait, Long Enough To List
There was no Doctor Who Christmas special this year – in fact, there’s no new Doctor Who on television (not counting Doctor-less spin-offs) until Christmas 2026, which will be over 18 months since The Reality War aired. As a result, in accordance with the ancient prophecy Ian Levine has been loosed from his imprisonment in the Divergent Universe and is currently scaling Bad Wolf tower, batting at biplanes whilst clutching an AI reconstruction of The Space Pirates in one hand.
While we all hunker down in our Christmas-decorated bunkers until he’s repelled, I’ve been prompted to think about my season rankings in my Doctor Who reviews. These are very much weighted towards assessing seasons based on how much I enjoy individual stories; I love every story in Season 26, so it ended up at the top, I don’t think any of the 2022 specials were particularly good so they languish at the bottom.
That’s fine to an extent, but it does end up with results that nag at me. In particular, in my most recent review, I ended up declaring Series 15 to be the strongest that the revived show had ever turned in. I still stand by that assessment… with caveats. In terms of individual episodes I might want to revisit later on to enjoy in isolation, separated from the season arc, Series 15 was a short but sweet collection of real gems. Moreover, I don’t think The Reality War is as big a disaster as some sectors of the fandom make it out to be, though I will admit a lot of my enjoyment of it stems directly from the fact that the hastily-arranged reshoots make the whole epic struggle seem like a bunch of silly busywork which isn’t actually as important as the simple fate of an entirely ordinary child.
In addition, on rewatches it shows all the scars, gaps, patches, and scaffolding that’s inherent to a story that was blatantly conceived with Ruby Sunday in mind as the main companion (Ruby as Poppy’s mother would make much more sense given prior interactions between them in Space Babies), then had to be rewritten when Millie Gibson stepped back her involvement in the series, then had to be rewritten again when Ncuti Gatwa decided that he wasn’t going to keep his career progression on hold indefinitely just because the show itself was in limbo.
And this sort of points into why I’m not sure about Series 15 landing as high as it does; though most of the individual stories are brilliant and I can find value in all of them, there’s stuff going on in the broader structure of the season which aren’t so good for the long-term health of the series, much like eating a whole Viennetta for dinner might be a lovely treat but if you do that for each and every one of your meals you’re going to have a bad time of it. I’m not necessarily talking about backstage production circumstances, though if the Sixth Doctor’s televised era taught us anything it’s that backstage circumstances can bleed over very easily into onscreen problems, and certainly something similar has happened here, with an apparent lack of joined-up thinking and a morass of dangling threads that seemed to be setting up stuff which now will quite likely not be addressed occurring in part because RTD had fallen in love with ideas which cast changes were now making incongruous, in part because he was acting like he was going to get a third season with Gatwa even though he knew full well that there was absolutely no guarantee of such a thing.
Put it this way: different eras of Doctor Who have different vibes. Each period has an atmosphere which permeates it, a sort of texture that’s distinct to it. There’s an infamous fanzine screed by Jan Vincent-Rudzki which emerged in response to The Deadly Assassin whose author closed with the thunderous declaration WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO THE MAGIC OF DOCTOR WHO? There’s a lot of reason to take issue with the essay, not least because The Deadly Assassin is brilliant, but what makes Vincent-Rudzki’s objections seem so funny in retrospect is that he’s declaring that the show is ruined in the middle of what’s become one of its most revered eras.

Vincent-Rudzki’s reaction seems daft if you’re looking at it in terms of the specific story in question – it’d always be a bit silly to declare Doctor Who ruined or saved on the basis of a single story, even the best stretch of the McCoy era had Silver Nemesis and Colin Baker had Vengeance On Varos to his name after all. It’s also been refuted by the passage of time and consideration of the franchise as a whole. But there’s an intermediate scale between these where it does make absolute sense, and that’s on the level of individual eras’ vibes. The Hinchcliffe era might be the gold standard to many, but clearly they didn’t work for Vncent-Rudzki, and thus the magic was lost for him.
If the Magic of Doctor Who resides anywhere, it’s in the vibes, not in specific scripts or particular production decisions or individual cast members, and crucially the Magic of Doctor Who isn’t exactly the same magic from era to era – it changes, like the Doctor changes. The important thing is less that a particular Magic of Doctor Who is being delivered and more that a Magic of Doctor Who is being offered up. A consequence of this is that it’s tremendously difficult as an individual audience member to figure out whether, if you’re not feeling the Magic of Doctor Who, it’s because the Magic of Doctor Who has actually gone away for a while, or whether it’s simply shifted into a form which is flatly incompatible with your tastes, because from the individual’s perspective the experience is identical.
Continue reading ““What Has Happened To the Magic of Doctor Who?” – A Ranking of the Heart”









