What follows is an argument for that most-detested word, mediocrity. The argument: Mediocrity can’t be helped.
The idea floated into my head one day when like countless others before me, I went through the harrowing realisation of not having an expert area. In other words, there was nothing I could find myself good at. This was even more disconcerting since I had already left one field of work for another, claiming I’d finally found my footing. But enthusiasm can be a dangerous affair, especially in the early days, when it lures you into such lousy convictions as “I found my footing”. Hogwash. Well, it is of course subjective. The new area one floated into can be the green pasture one had always dreamt of and finally discovered. For me though, it was a fall from the heights I had not envisaged when with all that unfounded enthusiasm I made the upward climb.
Mediocrity may not be the comforting word one reaches for after a fall. But it certainly worked like a magic potion I didn’t know I needed. Imagine a constant mantra inside your head, a noisy whisper that goes: You are not good at what you studied, you are not good at your job, you are not good at this, or that, or that other thing, you are not, you are not, you are not. No amount of reasoning or patience seemed to work until I could utter two words to mute the voice: So what.
I began to question the compelling rule we’d all grown up with, that everyone must excel in something. Should it be such a bad thing if you don’t find that something that you could excel in?
The argument began to develop. If everyone was good at what they did, how would only some people be exceptional, why would we need a word like genius. No, everyone was not going to be great, or even good at something. Where would the balance be, the equal and opposite forces that Newton so earnestly established. If the geniuses or the experts had to exist, there should be among them, those who did not do as well as them. Gold can only stand out if it stands among lesser gems. Just as there would be no good without bad or no happiness without sorrow, there would be no great without mediocrity. The experts needed the rest of us to be experts.
I was getting so good at this argument, that I decided my expert area was mediocrity. At a time when every word was measured and judged for its attitude, I did not understand how mediocrity could be so easily attacked. One was not to use words casually anymore, for many carried a potential insult or offence. And yet, mediocrity never made the cut. It was still shamed and labelled on people as a mark of their incompetence. How was it happening, I wondered. That you cannot call anyone out for whatever skills or possessions they lacked – and rightly so – but you can belittle them for not being up to the mark?
My counter-mantra – “it is okay to be mediocre” – began to work. I am not trying to lull young minds into thinking they don’t have to make an effort, and find an easy way out by blaming it all on the ‘mediocrity they were born with’. I am just making a case for those who tried and could not find something to excel in. They should be told it is okay that you are mediocre at what you do and it is not your fault. In the meantime you can keep trying new things, just in case you belatedly find your calling, but no problem if you don’t. You still matter. If Sean Maguire of Good Will Hunting was here, he would have shushed down your protests and told you, it is not your fault.
The gist of it all in a basic flowchart is:
