I don't know why I keep bothering with these WB Animated adaptations of classic DC Graphic Novels, as they seem to be willingly missing the point of the original work and instead focusing on the fights and violence. Superman Red Son (the comic) is one of the smartest and best written Elseworlds titles in the entire history of DC Comics, taking the simple concept of baby Superman's ship crashing in the Soviet Ukraine and using it to explore almost every facet of The Man of Steel. By contrast, the 2020 animated version strips out any nuance, making Superman a villain because he's a Communist and glorifying Lex Luthor's free market capitalism in what, honestly, almost comes across as a pro-Trump take on American politics. Thanks to more than 50 years of American propaganda, people still seem to have trouble reconciling the idea that a Communist can be a "good guy"; because Stalin was bad, so they all must be, right? It's the same kind of lack of education and critical thinking that has had generations label universal healthcare "Socialism" and all Socialism "dangerous". Idiots.
As much as I want to talk about the merits of the animated Red Son, such as they are, discussing the film is functionally impossible without comparison to the original text. Entire characters like Hyppolita and Grigory are just gone, Superior Man is changed to be heroic, rather than monstrous, because we can't have America represented as morally dubious. In the comic, Batman is an anarchist funded by foreign interests but not guided by them, in the film, he works for Luthor. Hal Jordan has a killer introduction in the comics, being an iron-willed Vietnam Veteran with a personal axe to grind against the communists, here he's introduced and we next see him fighting Superman. That fight is a perfect example of how the adaptation fails with the material, taking a strategic engagement that Superman has to think his way out of and turning it into a straight fight that doesn't serve the narrative in any way. In fact, any of the intellect and insight that the comic version of Superman gets to display has been stripped away, as are any arguments that attempt to justify his perspective. Can't have the kids realising that Capitalism is bad now, can we?
And that's the real issue with the animated Red Son, it doesn't challenge or make space for ideas like the comic did, not that it ever does anything silly like defend Gulags or the Purges, but the version of Communism that emerges under Superman's rule is strongly humanist. All of the nations that join the Warsaw Pact in the comic come willingly, whereas the film sees Superman himself lead an invasion of South Korea. Even Lex Luthor's rebuilding of the United States is framed here as the inevitable victory of the free market, instead of becoming a centralised and welfare-based system as it does in the comics; essentially becoming a form of socialism, which, you know, was the joke. I really don't know any reason why you would want to bother with this version when there's the comic so widely available and its being so much better. Stripping out all the nuance and challenge from the story means that this version is just an hour and a bit of fluff and filler you can do much better than, even if it's just to kill time.

































