[One to four stars. Four sentences each. No spoilers. Sources: Criterion Channel, Hulu, Netflix, TCM, YouTube.]
Oy to the World (dir. Paula Elle, 2025). When a water pipe in a synagogue bursts, old school rivals — a rabbi’s son, now in a rock band, and an Episcopal priest’s daughter, now her church’s choral director — join to lead an ecumenical children’s choir, and love blooms. One problem with this movie: there’s no chemistry between the leads. Another: the movie presents Episcopalians as the unmarked case (no talk of, say, their post-service coffee hour, known as “the eighth sacrament”) while playing to ridiculous lengths on tropes of Jewish food and culture. Think of the Frasier episode “Merry Christmas, Mrs. Moskowitz,” in which the Cranes pretend to be Jewish, and Frasier laments, “By the time my brisket’s done my kugel will be dry as the Sinai.” ★ (H)
*
Just Another Girl on the IRT (dir. Leslie Harris, 1992). Chantel Mitchell (Ariyan A. Johnson) is young, gifted, and Black: she wants to finish high school in three years, head off to college, become a doctor, and not end up living, like her parents, in a Brooklyn housing project. Chantel addresses the camera with the same smarts and impatience with which she addresses her obstinate history teacher and school principal: you root for her at every turn. And then unforeseen circumstances upend her life. An indie movie that’s something like an Afterschool Special for young adults and grown-ups, and one of the best movies about adolescence I’ve seen. ★★★★ (CC)
*
Return to Glennascaul (dir. Hilton Edwards, 1951). Orson Welles made movies everyone knows, or should know, and he participated in all manner of projects that remain obscure, or obscure, at least, to me. The premise of this short: while filming Othello (which was not made in Ireland), Welles goes for a nighttime drive in the Irish countryside and gives a ride to a man whose car has broken down. One of the world’s many variations on the trope of the vanishing hitchhiker. A comic touch: Welles is recognized by other characters in the story: “Aren’t you …?” ★★★★ (CC)
*
The Princess Bride (dir. Rob Reiner, 1987). I realize now that Rob Reiner resembled Billy Wilder in directing such varied movies: This Is Spinal Tap, When Harry Met Sally…, Misery, and so on: somehow I never got that. This movie is a sweet story of swashbucklers, a princess, and true love, set in a frame story with a grandfather (Peter Falk, looking like Kurt Vonnegut) reading to a skeptical grandson (Fred Savage). The cast includes André the Giant, Billy Crystal, Christopher Guest, Carol Kane, and Wallace Shawn. My favorite bit: the cups of poison. ★★★★ (H)
*
Christmas in Connecticut (dir. Peter Godfrey, 1945). Barbara Stanwyck is Elizabeth Lane, unmarried and living in a New York City apartment, where she writes a magazine column about her purported life as a wife and mother on a Connecticut farm. When her publisher (Sydney Greenstreet) devises a publicity scheme to have a seaman who survived a U-boat attack (Dennis Morgan) visit the farm for Christmas, Elizabeth must come up with a farm, a husband, a baby, and flapjacks. Wonderfully funny and transgressive stuff: Elizabeth, who’s supposed to be married (to a friend, played by Reginald Gardiner, who lends his farm and seems at least a tad gay), falls instantly for her guest, and they soon end up in bed — a bed of snow — together. With S.Z. “Cuddles” Sakall and Una O’Connor as great supporting players in the kitchen. ★★★★ (TCM)
[Fun to think once again about the mythic Connecticut where almost everyone gets around by sleigh. And strange to remember that this movie begins with two seamen adrift on a raft for eighteen days. And sad to think that this movie is likely the distant inspiration for the dreadful 2022 movie Christmas in Pine Valley .]
*
The Phenix City Story (dir. Phil Karlson, 1955). Drawn from the real-life story of Phenix City, Alabama, known for marked cards, crooked dice, slot machines, prostitution, and the murder of Albert Patterson, a local attorney who dared to run for attorney general. The story is told in semi-documentary style, with a lengthy preface in which a reporter interviews (white) townspeople. When the story kicks in, it’s with immense brutality and something of the flavor of On the Waterfront. John McIntire, Richard Kiley, and Kathryn Grant (later Kathryn Crosby) star, and look for Jean Carson (known for “Hello, doll” on The Andy Griffith Show ) in the Poppy Club. ★★★★ (TCM)
*
Merry Christmas, Ted Cooper! (dir. Jason Borque, 2025). Okay, one more Christmas movie, as recommended by my daughter. It’s a genuinely funny story of Ted Cooper (Robert Buckley), a resolutely cheerful and optimistic TV weatherman (think Ted Lasso) who’s beset by mishaps every Christmas season (his co-workers even have a betting pool on what’ll happen to him). When he travels back to his hometown to cover a fundraiser for the local hospital, he runs into his high-school crush (Kimberly Sustad), now a doctor at — can you believe it? — that same hospital. Could Ted just maybe, maybe break his streak of Christmas mishaps? ★★★ (H)
*
Close to You (dir. Dominic Savage, 2023). Elliot Page is Sam, a trans man who travels from Toronto to his small home town for his father’s birthday after several years away. It’s not easy, and there are moments of great tension, mostly brought about by a sister’s boyfriend. There’s further emotional complexity in Sam’s highly charged encounters with high-school friend Katherine (Hillary Baack). The weakness in this movie: an overreliance on improv (I sensed it while watching and confirmed it afterwards), with scenes that end up sputtering out, but the story is nevertheless compelling in its depiction of what it might be like to show your true self to people who thought they knew you all along. ★★★★ (N)
*
The Door with Seven Locks (dir. Norman Lee, 1940). It’s identified as horror, but in truth it’s a dull thriller. A dying nobleman, a treasure hidden behind a door with seven locks, an heiress (Lilli Palmer), an evil doctor (Leslie Banks), and seventy-nine long minutes. Some fireworks at the end with the the evil doctor, but they seem almost farcical after the dreariness that precedes them. I must add: in her 1950s secretarial days, my mom once saw Lilli Palmer and her then-husband Rex Harrison on a Manhattan street, by which point Lilli Palmer had likely long forgotten this movie. ★ (YT)
*
Stranger on the Prowl (dir. Joseph Losey, 1952). Wikipedia tells me that this movie is the first by a blacklisted American director working abroad. Deeply reminiscent of Vittorio De Sica’s Bicycle Thieves (1948), with a not-father and not-son fleeing the police in Livorno, Italy. Paul Muni is the homeless, penniless stranger; Vittorio Manunta, the boy, whose only crime is stealing a bottle of milk. This movie, which I’d never heard of, is, I’d say, one of the treasures of YouTube: watch it before it disappears. ★★★★
*
Meet John Doe (dir. Frank Capra, 1941). It’s a Wonderful Life wasn’t the first Capra movie to put suicide and Christmas together. It’s especially eerie to watch Meet John Doe in the time of AI and so-called influencers: “John Doe” is a media creation, a persona created not by AI but by AM — Ann Mitchell (Barbara Stanwyck), a crafty newspaper columnist who dreams up a circulation stunt about a “common man” planning to take his own life as a protest against the state of civilization. Ann hires a man to play the role, a hobo named Long John Willoughby (Gary Cooper); a populist movement (funded by the newspaper’s publisher) is born; and soon things turn very troubling. It’s always remarkable to see Capra swerve from Norman Rockwell territory into absolute darkness. ★★★★ (TCM)
*
A Christmas Carol (Edward L. Marin, 1938). I’m partial to Mister Magoo’s Christmas Carol (dir. Abe Levitow, 1962), but this one works well. Atmospherics are perfect: the dim, narrow, snowy streets, Scrooge’s barren rooms; the Cratchits’ warm, joyful house. Reginald Owen makes a fine Scrooge – a curmudgeon whose bitterness is so profound as to be farcical. Gene and Kathleen Lockhart are the genial Bob and Mrs. Cratchit; daughter June appears as one of their children; and the actor who plays Tiny Tim, Terry Kilburn, is still with us, having turned ninety-nine last month: God bless us every one! ★★★★ (TCM)
[Here’s Terry Kilburn in a 2016 interview.]
Related reading
All OCA “twelve movies” posts (Pinboard)