Archive for the ‘Discussion’ Category

Switzerland to hold five days of mourning after 40 killed in resort fire…

January 3, 2026

When one reads such news, you till think there is some humanity, some empathy left somewhere.

Swiss investigators are racing to identify the victims of a fire that tore through a crowded bar, killing about 40 people and injuring 115 who were celebrating at a New Year’s Eve party in the Alpine ski resort of Crans-Montana.

President Guy Parmelin has said the country will hold five days of mourning, describing the blaze as one of the most traumatic events in Switzerland’s history. “It was a drama of an unknown scale,” he said, paying tribute to the many “young lives that were lost and interrupted”.

When similar events happened in Rajkot or Goa (and many more places) in India, the point was to just shift blame. The leaders of ruling political party will point how worse events happened in the past under some other political party. The opposition  would retaliate.

At the end cricodile tears are shed, money given to kin and we move on before the next fire breaks out….

 

Scanning White House website: Welcome to the Golden Age!

December 30, 2025

I just stumbled onto the website of White House. The website welcomes you with the following words: WELCOME TO THE GOLDEN AGE! (yes in capitals letters).

As you scan thw website, you get this sense of dejavu all over again. The website is full of pictures of the “Greatest Leader/President” US has ever had and will have in future. It says things like “America is Back”,

Image

Where did America go?

Then “The Work Never Stops”:

Image

As if no one was working earlier.
And so on.
How all these leaders follow the playbook of tyrants is quite amazing. They use huge propoganda to dispel the message that how they are restoring the golden age and there is no one as hard working as them.
Even more amazing how humanity keeps falling into the same trap of greatness and golden age. They forget that all these leaders just care for their own glory and have zero interest in the country and its people.

The Great World War 2 Afterparty is over

November 5, 2025

Noah Smith on his blog says: Our ancestors bought us eighty years of peace, institutional effectiveness, and moral clarity. But nothing lasts forever.

Further:

(more…)

100 years of Syndicate Bank: An anniversary that could not be celebrated

November 4, 2025

Syndicate Bank established in October 1925 would have completed 100 years in 2025. However, the centenary of the iconic bank could not be celebrated as the bank was merged with Canara Bank in 2020.  I have documented the glorious history of Syndicate Bank and banking in South Canara District in this book.

Having said that, the retired Syndicate Bank officials called as “Retired Syndians” celebrated the centenary.   You have to go and talk to the local people to understand the impact these South Canara banks had on people’s lives.

 

How Kerala ended extreme poverty: Former Kerala CS Sarada Muraleedharan shares inside story

November 4, 2025

In a conversation with Onmanorama, former Chief Secretary Sarada Muraleedharan, who helped conceive and implement the project, explains how Kerala ended extreme poverty.

Cameroon’s Electoral Farce: How Paul Biya, Cameroon’s 92-Year-Old President, Won’t Let Go At Any Cost

November 4, 2025

92 year old Paul Biya has been Cameroon President since 1982. He won again for a record eighth successive term.

Madras Courier on the electoral farce in Cameroon:

For over four decades, Paul Biya has clung to power in Cameroon, a symbol of Africa’s enduring autocratic tendencies. At 92, his grip on the nation remains firm, built on a system of electoral fraud, state violence, and patronage.

While many parts of the world see political renewal through younger leaders, Biya’s rule is marked by stagnation, where opposition voices are silenced and reforms are a mere illusion. His regime’s manipulation of the electoral process has transformed democracy into a formality, with every election a farce.

Meanwhile, the country’s youth, increasingly disillusioned, face a future defined by repression and economic stagnation. Even as the international community grows more critical, Biya’s longstanding ties to powers like France and the US have allowed him to remain largely unchallenged. As Cameroon teeters on the edge of change, one question looms: how much longer can this aging autocrat hold on before the country demands its overdue transformation?

Autocrats can hold onto power longer than we can imagine and their decline is also quicker than we can imagine.

This elctoral autocracy is a farce in so many countries. You hold elections for namesake to show that you are a leader of masses but manipulate the system in such a way that no one else has a chance to get reelected.

 

Economics and its role in undermining democracy

October 27, 2025

Peter Radford writes about role of economics in undermining democracy on RWER Blog:

It was the intention from the very beginning of economics to eliminate the power of the demos in order to enforce the discipline and conformity of its logic.  It wasn’t the expression of self-interest that produced the collective good.  It was the subjugation of self-expression and idiosyncrasy in order to be part of a machine that did the trick.  Authority was not dissolved, it was simply hidden when explicit coercion was made implicit.

Much more in the post…

A Teacher Writes to Students Series (54): Monetary Economic Bunk

October 6, 2025

A Teacher Writes to Students Series (54): Monetary Economic Bunk
Annavajhula J C Bose, PhD
Department of Economics (Retd.), SRCC, DU

(more…)

Witch Hunts, Autocracy, and the Age of Algorithmic Empires

October 3, 2025

Asokakumar V writes in TheIndiaForum:

As cyber empires tighten control, digital platforms spread unseen violence that colonises the mind. Yet counter-movements are emerging—decentralised tools restoring openness, autonomy, and resistance to censorship. Can people reclaim peace and freedom from the very digital cages that confine them.

The product of the railways is the timetable

October 1, 2025

Benedict Springbett in this substack post:

We could therefore say that the product of the railways (and roads, and airports) is travel. But we can be more specific than that. A railway is not like a road. A road is built, and then it is open for anybody to use it at any time. There is no need to plan out precisely when cars move along the road. The movements of trains, by contrast, have to be planned out months in advance. It would neither be possible nor sensible to run trains ad hoc. They are not taxis, free to roam the roads whenever they like. Railway tracks are a network; everything depends on everything else. The service from Cambridge to Norwich affects the service from Norwich to London Liverpool Street, which in turn affects the service from Liverpool Street to Southend. To optimise the use of the tracks, train movements have to be planned out well in advance with precision.

This planning is what we call the timetable, the mapping between space and time that determines which train occupies which track at which time. The railways offer travel to the public via the timetable: a traveller buys the (supposed) fact that the 12.32 from Reigate gets into London Victoria at 13.19. The product of the railways is the timetable.

The world is following the China model

September 25, 2025

Sanjaya Baru writes about how the world is following the China model. He defines China model as countries curbung freedoms in name of development.

He cites how the earlier models – Washington Consensus and Fukuyama Man- that advoated liberal democracy have been sidelined.

Against Publication: The Case for Academics to Write Less

August 1, 2025
Prof Arun Sagar of BML Munjal University makes a case for academics to write less:
  • The commodification of academic research has led to the prioritisation of publication metrics over the substance of scholarly work.
  • Institutional pressures for publication targets distort the focus of scholarly pursuits.
  • Academics are forced to rush inchoate work to journals and neglect their teaching responsibilities.
  • The weight of publication numbers towards university rankings reduces scholarly merit and intellectual pursuits to mere numbers.

There is nothing worse than the so called “publish or perish culture” fostering in academics. Most academic places consider it as a matter of pride. Academics who lecture corporates on work culture and practices need to introspect and look within….

50 years and counting: The magnificent reign of Naseeruddin Shah

July 22, 2025

Naseeruddin Shah turned 75 two days ago. It also marked 50 years of his work in theatre and cinema.

Sohini Chattopadhyay on the 50 years of Naseer:

It is half a century since Shyam Benegal’s Nishant in 1975 where Shah made his debut proper. (He had a walk-on part in the 1967 film Aman, that featured philosopher Bertrand Russell in a cameo.) In the years since, Shah has acted in an astounding 274 films listed on IMDb, with at least one film releasing every calendar year across this half century. In celebration, a fan lists her favourite Naseer films, with the aid of Bharata’s rasa theory

All Indian cities fit to host olympics but not fit to keep its people

June 25, 2025

India’s political class has a new fascination: Hosting Olympics. Some of them are telling us how some of the cities where there jurisdiction lies are fit to host olympics! Really?

I mean when none of the cities are fit to keep its people, they are fit to host olymipcs? Where do these leaders get this arrogance and hubris from?

 

Uttarakhand crash shows how cheap a pilgrim’s life is

June 18, 2025

Cdr KP Sanjeev Kumar, a former Navy test pilot digs deep into tender documents issued by Uttarakhand Civil Aviation Development Authority (UCADA) to show how tourist lives ar cheap in India:

In the post, Cdr Kumar compares how heli services in Mumbai High with Uttarakhand which is worth reading. One is professional and another anything but professional.

A glimpse into UCADA tender:

 

In a country where people die in stampedes and fall off the footboard of moving trains without doors in the 21st Century, who should be the final arbiter for safety? The pilgrim who has been given the opportunity to buy a helicopter ticket cheaper than a pony ride? Or a ‘2+1 helicopter company’ who wants to ‘extract maximus’ from the milk cow of the industry? Or UCADA, whose website, replete with spelling mistakes and “no data found”, gives a glimpse into how cheap a pilgrim or tourist’s life is in India?

Look at the odds. And the irony. Listed below are some of the clauses extracted from a recent tender floated by UCADA for the selection of a helicopter shuttle operator from Joshiyara to Gangotri:

    • Operator will have to provide 10 flying hours (on non-chargeable basis) each Yatra season to meet exigencies as determined by UCADA. Each operator will provide the flying hours when directed by UCADA, failure is doing so will attract a penalty of Rs 02 lakh each time. In such a case the balance number of hours will remain unchanged. For utilization of these hours a roaster will be followed. These services will be provided as per the direction of CEO, UCADA.
    • When the helicopter is requisitioned by UCADA and if any operator refuses or shows inability, a penalty of Rs 02.00 lakh will be levied.
    • Withdrawal of any helicopter on the grounds of reduced pilgrim traffic etc. shall be allowed only after the Operator has obtained the specific written approval of the Chief Executive Officer/ Addl. Chief Executive Officer, UCADA failing which a penalty @ Rs 20,000/- per scheduled flying hour (subject to a maximum of Rs. 100,000/- per day) shall be liable to be imposed. The above penalty shall also apply in case the Operator suspends flying beyond 24 hours, on account of some technical snag/ non availability of pilots or any other reason whatsoever. The penalty amount shall be double in the subsequent days of suspended operations i.e. Rs. 40,000/- per scheduled flying hour (subject to a maximum of Rs. 200,000/- for 2nd day), Rs. 80,000/- per scheduled flying hour (subject to a maximum of Rs. 400,000/- for 3rd day) and so on till 07 days after which the contract of the successful operator can be cancelled.
    • The Company shall carry out the flight operations daily, with least inconvenience to the Yatris, subject to fair weather conditions and clearance by the ATC/Competent authority. (to be clear, there is NO ATC or “competent authority” in Chota Char Dham sector except for pilots).
    • Each pilot operating Shuttles will be permitted a maximum of 50 landings in a day and the bidder will comply with DGCA CAR Section-7 Series-J Part-II without any aberrations.
    • The booking of heli tickets for shuttle services will be 100% online through website authorized by UCADA. 03% (Inclusive of GST) of the tariff of each booked ticket as Yatra Facilitation Charges shall be charged by UCADA from shuttle operator. (This is like booking airline tickets through DGCA!)
    • Booking charges/convenience fees over and above the ticket charges shall be collected from the passenger by the ticket booking agency authorised by UCADA. Dynamic pricing system over and above the L1 rate may be introduced. The SOP for the dynamic pricing system will be as directed by UCADA which will be binding on all the selected bidder.
    • The Operator shall pay royalty inclusive of GST equal to Rs 5,000 per landing at all government owned helipads. The royalty amount has to be deposited on weekly basis. Shuttle royalty shall also increase by 05% with every extension in contract.
    • All other equipment/infrastructure for communication, meteorological facilities, medical facilities, fire-fighting and safe flying operation etc shall be the sole responsibility of the Operator, who shall provide it as per norms prescribed by DGCA/ other agencies.
    • When the helicopter is requisitioned by UCADA and if any operator refuses or shows inability, a penalty of Rs 02.00 lakh will be levied.
    • Withdrawal of any helicopter on the grounds of reduced pilgrim traffic etc. shall be allowed only after the Operator has obtained the specific written approval of the Chief Executive Officer/ Addl. Chief Executive Officer, UCADA failing which a penalty @ Rs 20,000/- per scheduled flying hour (subject to a maximum of Rs. 100,000/- per day) shall be liable to be imposed. The above penalty shall also apply in case the Operator suspends flying beyond 24 hours, on account of some technical snag/ non availability of pilots or any other reason whatsoever. The penalty amount shall be double in the subsequent days of suspended operations i.e. Rs. 40,000/- per scheduled flying hour (subject to a maximum of Rs. 200,000/- for 2nd day), Rs. 80,000/- per scheduled flying hour (subject to a maximum of Rs. 400,000/- for 3rd day) and so on till 07 days after which the contract of the successful operator can be cancelled

And here’s the clincher!

    • UCADA shall not be liable for what-so-ever consequences arising out of any accident, incident, mishap, or any event relating to the operation of the helicopter services of the Operator, who shall be solely and exclusively liable for any injury, damage or liability of any kind arising directly or indirectly out of its operations.

In the end, it is all about propaganda and marketing:

Thanks to all the hardsell coupled with the pull of cheap tickets, the hill shrines of Yamunotri, Gangotri, Kedarnath and Badrinath have been seeing footfalls like never before. Shrine boards and the UCADA have been incentivising this feeding frenzy with no real investments in infrastructure or safety management systems. To make matters worse, operators hire ex-military pilots with hill flying experience and incentivise them with cash bounties that draw them away from well-regulated sectors like offshore. It can only go south from here.

The situation is so bad, helicopter operators can learn a thing or two from pony operators who seem to have a higher benchmark for what works in the hills and what doesn’t. The flawed financial model at the root of this unholy heli-tourism sector merits greater scrutiny and could well hold the keys to solving the puzzle. Meanwhile, as fare-paying passengers, please do your due diligence and take the safer option till further advice. As it seems, nobody has your back.

If the triumvirate of MoCA, UCADA and DGCA has succeeded in one mission, it is to unite the pilgrim with his/her Maker, as two fatal accidents in as many months have shown. It is about time pilgrims take responsibility for their own lives.

Signing off with thoughts and prayers for seven onboard the last flight of VT-BKA.

“Baba Kedar ki Jai”

Who cares? Lives are cheap.

Fifth helicopter crash in Uttarakhand

June 16, 2025

It has been a month since I suffered a personal tragedy in the helicopter crash during the chardham strategy at Uttarakhand.   Since then, there have been four more crashes. The recent one led to the death of all the seven passengers.

I mean tell me one country where there have been so many helicopter crashes and yet things go on as if nothing happened. The government set up an inquiry commission after the first crash in May but nothing has come of it. How much time will it take? In the meanwhile, the helicopter operators continue functioning and crashing. It is just simply crazy.

The government has suspended the helicopter operations now but then what is the point? Families and friends have again been destroyed.   The flights should have been stopped a month ago which would have mean the later crashes would not have happened and lives would not have been lost.

In this regard, I don’t see the super tragic aircraft crash in Ahmedabad as a one-off event. Same with the recent stampedes at Kumbh and Bangalore. As I was writing this post, a bridge collapsed in Pune.  We blame it on crowd. But there was no crowd in the case of helicopter crash.

The key reason is lives are super cheap in India and the authorities just don’t care.  There is no democratic pressure from citizens holding authorities accountable. All the authorities do is to first deny the tragedy and then hide the actual number of those who suffered. The families and friends are too grieved to ask government take any action. Overtime, we forget and move on. It is back to normal in no time before a new tragedy strikes. It is a vicious cycle.

Whatever, 5 crashes in a matter of 40 days should be a record when it comes to negligience, misgovernance and shamelessness.

Number of autocracies more than democracies: first time in 20 years

June 9, 2025

V-Dem’s recent report on Democracy shows the continued decline of democracies and rise of autocracies across the world. For the first time in 20 years, number of democracies are lower than autocracies.

Key findings:

(more…)

A Teacher Writes to Students Series (46): Celebrating Madhav Gadgil

June 3, 2025

A Teacher Writes to Students Series (46): Celebrating Madhav Gadgil
Annavajhula J C Bose, PhD
Department of Economics (Retd.), SRCC, DU

(more…)

The two faces of Meloni’s Italy: disciplined and quietly dangerous

May 30, 2025

Sofia Melis in this OMFIF article on the two faces of Italia Premier Giorgia Meloni.

The first face is the projected image of a reformer and second of a democracy crusher. Have we heard/read this narrative earlier too? Of course. It is a playbook of authoritarian leadership. End result is weakening years of societal progress

Italy’s post-war system was built to stop power concentrating behind a single figure, wrapped in the language of stability. The safeguards today are being weaponised, not broken: the premierato, the security decrees and the institutional reshuffling are legal, incremental and strategic steps. Democracy isn’t being overthrown, it’s being refitted.

Nadia Urbinati, a political theorist, warned that democracy dies not in a moment of rupture, but when people stop noticing its erosion. Her theory of the ‘permanent majority’ captures what’s happening now: electoral wins converted into structural dominance, dissent sidelined, pluralism recast as dysfunction.

Europe, meanwhile, mistakes discipline for health. It sees a leader who ticks the right boxes and avoids chaos. But what it’s endorsing is something far more corrosive: a regime that governs by subtraction with fewer checks, fewer rights, fewer spaces to push back. And that’s just one Italy, the other is sliding backwards, not in chaos, but in silence; not in anger, but in indifference. And as Meloni finds ideological kinship with Trump’s America, she also finds cover.

The performance is convincing, the choreography careful. Behind it, a different kind of politics is taking hold: illiberal, enduring and dangerously easy to miss.

Humanity never learns. It keeps making the same mistakes and expects different results.

Universities: what can we learn from the US?

May 28, 2025

Peter Ainsworth writes in IEA blog:

Trump’s executive action-fuelled battles with woke universities fill the headlines. Columbia has capitulated; “heroic” Harvard holds its £53bn-endowment-funded ground. But these are skirmishes – tactical spats in a broader culture war. The real strategic shift is unfolding quietly in Congress, where profound legislative proposals to restructure university finance are advancing. If enacted, they won’t just reshape American higher education – they could undermine the UK’s global standing as the world’s No. 2 provider.

Enter the College Cost Reduction Act (CCRA), introduced by Representative Virginia Foxx, Chair of the House Committee on Education and the Workforce. A key component is institutional risk-sharing – where universities accept some liability for student loan defaults. This idea had been circulating in Republican policy circles for some time, and the bill was formally introduced in January 2024. At the time, it went nowhere—just one of several structural reform ideas parked under a Democratic president and a divided Congress.

But Trump’s return to the White House, coupled with Republican control of both Houses, has propelled the idea back onto the legislative agenda. What’s new is that key provisions have now been introduced to the House as the ‘Student Success and Taxpayer Savings Plan’. A revolutionary structural reform that once looked purely theoretical is now a live prospect. Amid headlines fixated on campus protests and DEI rollbacks, the CCRA carries a deeper ambition: a legislative mechanism for holding universities financially accountable when their graduates fail to repay their loans.

There is an opportunity to fix long term issues in UK univs:

Under the current model, where universities are paid on recruitment, the graduate earnings premium has been in long-term decline. The only way to reverse it is to link institutional remuneration to graduate success, as the Americans are proposing to do. Done well, that would motivate universities to reduce costs and/or reorient courses toward real labour market value, reestablishing the economic relevance of higher education.

What’s needed now is political courage. Risk-sharing isn’t just a technical reform—it’s a reset of the relationship between students, universities, and the state. The U.S. is moving first. If the UK hesitates, America – and any country that follows its lead – will improve the economic returns of their degrees, while the UK becomes less appealing to the international students who pay most of the bills.

The UK still has the infrastructure, the reputation, and the global footprint to lead. But unless universities are rewarded for delivering real value – measured in outcomes, not enrolments – it risks slipping into the second tier: still talking about the problem, while others get on with solving it.


Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started