The past weeks there has been discussions within my family, clan and people I am part of, on the topics of Cultural Appropriation, Identity and Rights within a Community. I have different views than them, I discovered, by virtue of the fact that the path I was pushed into or choices I made, consciously or unconsciously, has allowed me to see the other side of things. For this, I am grateful to the Universe.
These are the things I gleaned from watching, listening and opining where I could – In the time of forced stay home, a lot of us are grappling with what our Identity is and what the rules for Identification are, within our community and the world at large. As the Identity that depended on our Vocation is disappearing, along with the other circles we were part of. People are wondering where they actually Belong. (Note : There are lots of new communities being formed, as we cope with the changes in social interactions.)
I also became aware – that depending on who you marry your Identity can change especially if you are a Woman(of course, I knew women went from Woman to Wife) – any Woman (doesnt apply for the Man) who has not met the implicit rule of marrying within their own community loses their previous Identity, the women are considered as someone who LEFT the Community, therefore treated as outsiders who have no right to opine about the community they were born into.
The power of Brawn(Emotional pressure via Mob Mentality/physical pressure via large crowds gathering) overrules any Brain aspect of things. Any Person, who use their understanding via education to speak of the Rights, or Logically points to where the wrong is, are treated with disdain, the points they make are selectively twisted and are completely disrespected through words and deeds, as someone who is bringing their Community down. The reasoning – If you weren’t born in this community you couldn’t have got that education, so be grateful and be loyal even if you dont agree with things or things are clearly Wrong.
Anger, Frustration, Entitlement Issues, Superiority and Inferiority Complexes, Ad Hominem arguments, A lack of awareness of their own Implicit Bias, Hypocrisy etc. do not make it conducive for Communication to Occur or Resolving any Issue or Help find any Solutions. I have to watch myself for what I feel while talking.
As I listened, it occurred to me that, I cant use just one word to explain All that I Am(Identity). I can never say “This is What I am” for all of the time I lived and all the time until I die. I only know what I am in the moment in the context of what the circumstance is. I have different hues, tiles, threads woven into who I am. I am not separate from any of those different Identities at any time, even when I use only One of them at any Time. The only Identity that holds for all of my life, is the fact that I am Human. Or at the least the fact that Human is the conventional name, I and others can agree upon for my Identity. All other identities will change according to what I say or do and how others can see me. Which means, that my Identity isn’t a solid tangible thing like, say, the ground we walk on. If I never stayed in One Place, or no one ever knew me(which is improbable), I can say whatever I want for My Identity and the Other will have to take my word for it.
Cultural Appropriation- a topic I dont have a clear understanding of. I believe in Respecting people and their traditions and customs- which means, I will never Knowingly use any of things that other cultures deem as part of their culture, as mine or treat their stuff with malicious intent. Most times it is unclear where the lines are. It causes me grief. In some cultures traditional clothing, tattoo designs, jewelry, ancestral artifacts, traditional foods, ingredients used in rituals, being in a certain place like an ancestral burial site, is important and it is considered disrespectful, if people of other communities to go to such places or use the said items when they don’t understand its nuance. While in some places and people, everything is about monetary gain, so sold for a good price. It is very confusing.
Rights – Its such a fleeting thing. It is given and taken away depending on who is in Power and what they think is Right or Wrong. No matter where we go in this world, our rights is such an ephemeral thing. We can talk all we want about rights, but how it manifests in the realty of life, depends on how much Influence and Wealth a person has and sometimes how many people like the person you are(Yep, think about jobs got through references). Which means most of us are choosing our battles with respect to Rights. Will Rights ever be something that cant be given or taken so we dont have to Fight for our Right, but IS because its the right thing to do, and not because we feel entitled?
All of the discussions only reinforced my belief in Karma – “All actions and inactions have consequences.”
Hoping to let go of my ineptitude as I learn the ways of our World
Signing off
You know who.
