before i forget, my grandmother also said this "i got paid for house work, with a home, furnture, spending money.."
that made her sound like she was taken care of, so i asked if she felt subjacated, and she said no, he was never home."
she also blames feminism on rising divorces, and thinks the nuclear family is the most stable...so grain of salt time, but it lead me to think was her marriage, the one that lasted 46 yrs, a mercancy arrangement, where both knew the cost ?
all shall be well all shall be well and all manner of things shall be well julian of norwich
Tuesday, December 30, 2003
cowtown
I saw a statue of the buddha, with sunken skeletal features, veins crawling over canoe keel ribs, gaunt arms and gaunter legs, and I thot , he took himself to the edge, denied the physical, and then came back the self same way, to somewhere in the middle…is this what i need to do w. celibacy, is this what the church needs to do w. celibacy—i got so caught up in assuming the match b/w buddha & christ was the anihalltion of self, maybe it is temperance, balance and restraint. what next ?
the same place i found the buddha, i saw a disappointing show of the bog people---mysterious souls left persved in the peat bogs of Ireland, Denmark, Norway and Holland, there were some of the corpses there, and some tools, but also a collection of ritual jewelry/pots/adzes/etc that was deeply moving, but the light was so dim, and the display cases for some of the best work prevented a full view…that & they quoted heany’s bog poems but did not sell the volume.
To go along with the was wolfgang bleekers photos of moors, which had a decent colour sense, and some startling compostion, but by the most part, were overly romantic, and almost too cinematic.
The art gallery of calgary had a show of paintings done with acrylics, and clothes line, the gallery attendant described some of it as strong, and some of it as laboured. I was more excited by the eames plywood chairs then the work (which I found too concerned with material & theory, and nont nearly concerned w. form, so we had another show of b&w grids/rondos.
A bookstore cross stephen avenue had a book of censored comic art, including some v. well drawn boy pinups by p craig russell, almostl cadmusian in its details.
(saw some v. good public art, Yoruba murals on the side of a south African resturant, a horse made of farm implements, ekens glossy/blurry/glam/fuck you funny trophy cibrachromes as trophy art in the husky oil lobby/22 blackbirds carved, numbered and placed on a pole, etc.)
terse, wasp fight w. gramma about money, gave me my bday cheque early,
dependent on bryan’s car too much, found that out today, need to change it.
I saw a statue of the buddha, with sunken skeletal features, veins crawling over canoe keel ribs, gaunt arms and gaunter legs, and I thot , he took himself to the edge, denied the physical, and then came back the self same way, to somewhere in the middle…is this what i need to do w. celibacy, is this what the church needs to do w. celibacy—i got so caught up in assuming the match b/w buddha & christ was the anihalltion of self, maybe it is temperance, balance and restraint. what next ?
the same place i found the buddha, i saw a disappointing show of the bog people---mysterious souls left persved in the peat bogs of Ireland, Denmark, Norway and Holland, there were some of the corpses there, and some tools, but also a collection of ritual jewelry/pots/adzes/etc that was deeply moving, but the light was so dim, and the display cases for some of the best work prevented a full view…that & they quoted heany’s bog poems but did not sell the volume.
To go along with the was wolfgang bleekers photos of moors, which had a decent colour sense, and some startling compostion, but by the most part, were overly romantic, and almost too cinematic.
The art gallery of calgary had a show of paintings done with acrylics, and clothes line, the gallery attendant described some of it as strong, and some of it as laboured. I was more excited by the eames plywood chairs then the work (which I found too concerned with material & theory, and nont nearly concerned w. form, so we had another show of b&w grids/rondos.
A bookstore cross stephen avenue had a book of censored comic art, including some v. well drawn boy pinups by p craig russell, almostl cadmusian in its details.
(saw some v. good public art, Yoruba murals on the side of a south African resturant, a horse made of farm implements, ekens glossy/blurry/glam/fuck you funny trophy cibrachromes as trophy art in the husky oil lobby/22 blackbirds carved, numbered and placed on a pole, etc.)
terse, wasp fight w. gramma about money, gave me my bday cheque early,
dependent on bryan’s car too much, found that out today, need to change it.
Sunday, December 28, 2003
bought a book this xmas, called queer pulp, a coffee table excuse to note the underground history of girl on girl action--i should have looked here, which has the immortal cover "satan was a lesbian"
queer day
queer day
I find John Currin to be reactionary, hateful, and not even a very good painter, but those who love art have declared him the next big thing.
David Cohen fucks with the hype, and also tells the world that yale thinks he is as good as botecelli.
mefi
David Cohen fucks with the hype, and also tells the world that yale thinks he is as good as botecelli.
mefi
Saturday, December 27, 2003
Franz Gehry is ego unchecked, refusing to acknowledge the beauty and diversity of human scale building, replacing it with garish spectacle. He is ruining deco, italianate renaissance revival, and other syles that make New York wonderful.
He did that with the King Alfred Center in Bristol which ignored the idea of pavillion and carnival, the Disney concert hall in Los Angeles, which made a rich persons cathedral on top of immigrant poverty, and the EMP in Seattle, which hoggishly took up almost 3/4s of a central public park.
I do not know why he is lauded in the manner he is.
Comment on this
on Satan's Laundramat who has original photos.
He did that with the King Alfred Center in Bristol which ignored the idea of pavillion and carnival, the Disney concert hall in Los Angeles, which made a rich persons cathedral on top of immigrant poverty, and the EMP in Seattle, which hoggishly took up almost 3/4s of a central public park.
I do not know why he is lauded in the manner he is.
Comment on this
on Satan's Laundramat who has original photos.
Wednesday, December 24, 2003
Tuesday, December 23, 2003
and almost 24 chicago area priests have called the vaticans gay position "vile and toxic", reminding us that the church is not the vatican, that many north americans and europeans are now in open revolt against the vatican on issues of sex and gender, and that if the next pope is as conserative on these issues as the last one, we may see schisms.
as for me and my house, i agree with the chicago 24
as for me and my house, i agree with the chicago 24
One of the strageties for winning the cold war was bleeding, basically out spending russia until it fell into economic collpase (cf Reagon and SSDS), it worked so well, and chinese might be trying it on america
Breaking down the red/blue state lines, these ten regions still mantain some of the elitist class discourse that surrounds red/blue, but reflects the complexity found in the demograpgics, also attempts to explain race, which is a factor over looked (and not only b&w but asian/hispanic, etc)
huge gallery of african photography, done by africans. interesting on aesthic and anthropological grounds.
Sunday, December 21, 2003
gorgeous paloethic art is found in southern germany, including the oldest anthropomorphic work in history...i wonder if we can call them totems, if the work had a ritual function outside its obv. aesthic care ?
making light
making light
Jury's
choosing death sentences are becoming less and less common.
i hope it means that americans have come to the realazation that death is a cruelty.
(it doesnt mean that prisons are any better)
talking left
choosing death sentences are becoming less and less common.
i hope it means that americans have come to the realazation that death is a cruelty.
(it doesnt mean that prisons are any better)
talking left
Americans phyiscally and emotionally abuse prisoners in their care, spec. arab immigrants detained post 9/11.
speaking of accountability, Arnie declares state of emergency so that he can push his cuts on a public with out the body of the legasture even discussing it.
This is what you get for using elections as grabs as opposed to forums, and this is what you get for electing a bully.
talk left
This is what you get for using elections as grabs as opposed to forums, and this is what you get for electing a bully.
talk left
Diebold has admitted that their machines went untested in 17 counties in California for the last two elections.
Fair and Free Elections are being ursurped by machines, and ursurped for political g ains. Enough to make one a luddite.
making light
Fair and Free Elections are being ursurped by machines, and ursurped for political g ains. Enough to make one a luddite.
making light
The gold Room, an atlanta strip club is now being used as a church, something about this moves me--making the profane sacred or something like that---the giant whirl pool in a champers glass is being used as a baptismal font.
fark
fark
Friday, December 19, 2003
i have been having gaps in my memory, sessions of two or three minutes when i blank out and do not respond to stimuli, this has been happening for months, i just went to a neurlogist, and he wants to do eegs, cat scans, etc + he has put me on meds that i cannot afford and may cause my thinking to become sluggish. i have been working on a couple of book projects, and some freelance stuff. i cannot afford to be sluggish, nothing scares me more then my mind going
Tuesday, December 16, 2003
maybe i was unfair to hill, is it not our job as christians to discomfort the comfortable and to call out the hypocisy(sp) of those in power ? Was she not working in the tradition of Christ in the Temple or Christ telling the rich man about the eye of the needle ?
What better place to tell the emporer of his nudity, then his own palace.
What better place to tell the emporer of his nudity, then his own palace.
America puts a bounty on Taylors head, UK mercanies say hey thats a good idea
the reason why the world court at the hauge exists is to deal with this sort of thing, i mean i know the us eschews treaties and likes unilateral deicsions, but come on.
the reason why the world court at the hauge exists is to deal with this sort of thing, i mean i know the us eschews treaties and likes unilateral deicsions, but come on.
France, in its attempts to march towards secuarism and avoid its muslim influx and catholic roots, has banned religous articles from class rooms.
i think its a singualarry (sp) bad idea, and diveristy should be encouraged.
bbc
i think its a singualarry (sp) bad idea, and diveristy should be encouraged.
bbc
As much as I have problems with the Church, there is a time and a place for this sort of thing, doing so at the vatican mid performance would be a bad time and place
ilx
ilx
One of the first criticisms of gehry inside architectual circles, Johnathon Clancey thinks they represent "the attack of the blog"
First Nations baskets, with their subtle and permating abstractions, moving between meaning and form, are like sand paintings or quilts, the beginning of a new, american art.
a huge exhibit at the musuem of the american indian, in dc shows hundreds of varriations and implications, and also extensive how tos.
check it out
mefi
a huge exhibit at the musuem of the american indian, in dc shows hundreds of varriations and implications, and also extensive how tos.
check it out
mefi
Monday, December 15, 2003
danielle came home and we collapse into old wonderful patterns, the only one i retained from high school, there must be something there.
she liked romaine brooks, i knew she would, its odd how much my taste has changed since and how much things have changed.
duncans show is up at fab, wall paintings, things propped up, things on floors, elegant complex wonderfully played out, nostalgic formalism, but he never calls himself a formalist.
and the show downstairs, seeping pigment thru white sheets, like if helen frankenthaler did right of the first night, and clumsy random paintings,which bored... and an installtion peice with honey and troughed canvas's that looked medical.
purple ink and red chalk make me as happy as mechanical penguins.
she liked romaine brooks, i knew she would, its odd how much my taste has changed since and how much things have changed.
duncans show is up at fab, wall paintings, things propped up, things on floors, elegant complex wonderfully played out, nostalgic formalism, but he never calls himself a formalist.
and the show downstairs, seeping pigment thru white sheets, like if helen frankenthaler did right of the first night, and clumsy random paintings,which bored... and an installtion peice with honey and troughed canvas's that looked medical.
purple ink and red chalk make me as happy as mechanical penguins.
I want to be more like Judith Butler than like Michel Foucault.
Madonna
She wants a PhD from Oxbridge in queer theory, womens studies and gender studies, does she even have high school ?
Madonna
She wants a PhD from Oxbridge in queer theory, womens studies and gender studies, does she even have high school ?
Sunday, December 14, 2003
Thursday, December 11, 2003
Top 5 Poetry Books of the year are all collections of cannonical writers. This makes me sad, that one of the nations leading papers thinks that poems are so moribund that only what was produced is worth looking at.
Homeland Sec. Head Tom Ridge wants to make illegals, legals...mostly to keep track of them, but even so, this might be an indication that things arent all bad.
a good summary of my aesthic feelings and practices, done by the fine folks at freaky trigger, in fact i think it is the manifesto i agree with most, with its refusal to view hi as better then lo, and its refusal to capitualte to history.
ilx
ilx
look you didnt like the badger cam, and i was sad--but i hope this is better...its a camera that measures contential drift!
Tuesday, December 09, 2003
Which Historical Lunatic Are You?
From the fecund loins of Rum and Monkey.
i wanted ludwig, thank josh
an acessiable, well written, clever and difficult history of the turner prize lavishly illustrated, with many hyperlinks.
worth a glance
worth a glance
Sexuality is ethically correct when it is done by two adults who consent, and are capable of consent, being on the same power base. The problem with this is when someone consents to be cannibalized.
when the inbred daughters of anglo upper classes tell the colonies to clean up their messes and work hard towards democracy do they not notice the irony ?
all africa
all africa
Encylopedia of Bawdy Song. all yr favourites
publoshed as broadsides and spoken in low whispers, these provide a new history of sexual and gender mores, and indicate what was thought about a number of things.
making light
publoshed as broadsides and spoken in low whispers, these provide a new history of sexual and gender mores, and indicate what was thought about a number of things.
making light
Stark, sleek and modern the building at 10 Columbia Circle has acted as a modernist setinal against the arcadia of central park. They are retrofitting it to make it prettier. This upsets me
Monday, December 08, 2003
Grayson Perry won the Turner.
I dont know what i think, aside from YEAH POTTERY.
Chris/Ryan/I were talking about video art, and how much we saw ar galleries and how little moved us, how dull or desperate or boring or retrograde it seemed. Carter might agree.
He's also a Transvestite, and his claire personae dresses in wonderous and strange dresses with embrodeiry that matches the themes of the pots and resembles victorian dolls gone conceptual.
I dont know what i think, aside from YEAH POTTERY.
Chris/Ryan/I were talking about video art, and how much we saw ar galleries and how little moved us, how dull or desperate or boring or retrograde it seemed. Carter might agree.
He's also a Transvestite, and his claire personae dresses in wonderous and strange dresses with embrodeiry that matches the themes of the pots and resembles victorian dolls gone conceptual.
Sunday, December 07, 2003
Petronius wrote his Satyricon in 66 AD, just as the glorious Roman Empire was crumbling, where the ideas of order, state control and public virtues were set aside replaced with a late decadence marked by chaos and debauchery. He was in the court of Nero, who rewarded literary success in so far that it did not exceed his own talents. The text of the Satyricon is one that has much to say about the nature of the republic at that time, telling us in a sly way that verges on transparent. It was written with the court in mind, episodic and intended to be preformed. The most obvious of these satires, and the one where much critical thought lies is the Dinner Party sequence, which shows the worst of Rome with a burlesque glee. This is the text that claimed Petronius, and he died soon after, in a dinner party where he slit his wrists and bound them tightly. Every time the guests failed to entertain him, he would loosen the bounds a little. This would be a good metaphor for Petronius in general and this work in general, a deadly serious satire.
Frederico Fellini adapted Satyricon to film between 1968 and 1969, finally releasing it in 1970. He thought that he was dying and he had a nervous breakdown in the middle of filming. This film was also the first he made after he had gained world wide fame and was acclimatizing to the spectacles that world wide fame could bring. When talking about this film, he claimed that he wanted to be in the spirit of the source text, rather then make any claims on literal truth. (Burke, 166). Part of that spirit could be the times. 1968 was an auspicious year in world history, with everything in flux, and the roles of power unsure. The adaptation to the spirit of the work instead of the text meant that he considered what happened in his own frame work, making the text as alive as the times.
Taking these two works together gives us context to talk about many of the issues that grounded Petronius in 66 and Fellini 1300 years later. In analyzing these works, the lenses I find most helpful are class and social breed, the documentary form in fictions and the nature of satire as a political and moral excercise. These texts allow a thorough examination of these lenses, talking about the larger contexts and purposes of the play and the film.
Starting with Class in Petronius is to understand how Nero played the upper classes against the lower. He was a Patrician, with the blood of emperors but did not act that way at all. He was a hero to the common man, because in the crudest sense, he kept them fed and entertained. The whole point of the spectacles that he put on was to make the lowest of the citizenry happy. In John Bishop's Nero the Man and his Legend, he describes how effective this
strategy could be:
"A considerable part of the people of Rome welcomed Nero...
and was frankly skeptical of the allegedly straight laced
properity of the Romans of an older generation." (119)
The problem then, was that Nero was too close to the common citzenry, and did not behave in a way expected of an emperor. This would also be the case in his "slumming", where he dressed himself as a slave, attended brothels and drinking places and looted stores with drunken thugs. This and a tendency to reward himself for acts of literary prowess (for example giving himself all of the laurels in the first Neronia, a poetry contest he founded and named after himself) isolated those in the senate. Being a poet at all, according to Bishop was "on the whole an object not of pride but of disgust" (114)
By even welcoming the pornography of Petronius into court, he brought the ideas of the street into rooms that had never seen them. This was not the clean and rigidly structured language of rhetoric but something else entirely. JP Sullivan explains it well in his Literature and Politics In the Age of Nero, saying that although "No literary minded emperor fails to include a considerable number of his friends among his courtiers", he "cared less about personal insults then most" and "libelous poems were a feature of court life" (154)
Fellini was slightly different when it came to class, not exactly in the court of the greatest power in the world, but respected and admired none the less. This was a time when art film was key, where movies with subtitles were watched with great interest, where immediate transportation and more disposable income made air travel common among the upper and lower classes, and where radical politics were combined with sexual freedom, especially among the very rich.
Fellini was especially rewarded for this, making a life style out of Le Dolce Vitae in 1960, and making a star out of Anita Ekberg in 1963's 8 1/2. The movies were shown on most american screens, colleges had film nights where these two films were shown, and the orgy scenes and attractive, almost superfluous nudity of the works would be a portent to the open marriages that seemed a trend in the 1970s.
Fellini saw this kind of sexual decadence in the mid 60s, before his production of the Satyricon, in the infamous New York Disco Electric Circus, he described it thusly:
"its dance floors were aswirl with multicoloured lights, there
were tropical fish, the floors were carpeted with nude bodies
and there were these enormous holes in the wall that had four
five, six pairs of feet, male and female, black and white protruded."
(quoted in Burke's Fellinis Films from Post War to Post Modern,172)
this sort of orgastic sexuality, with its openness to new avenues of discourse, lead many to abandoned other conventions, be it the family or the state. There was a reversal of order coming for Petronius and the Roman Empire as it was assumed the same case would be for the western democracies under Fellini.
Therefore a sense of reversal can be found in both Satyricons. In The dinner party scene in the original text Trimalchio is a country bumpkin playing at the rituals of the very rich, something that could not happen in really life. But if you reverse those scenes, and have an emperor playing at being poor, treating himself to common whores and cheap beer it would not lose it's satiric qualities. Petronius then preforms a double reversal, the more common one of the fool becoming a king and then a subtextual one, where in a shadow place the king becomes the fool. The shadow is dark however, because this was already occurring.
In Fellini it is much less clear. However there are two things that could mark this film as a reversal. The first is the production design and the second are the actors. In the production design of this film is deeply colourful and over the top, almost reaching camp porportions. The swirling colours, the odd camera angles, and the painterly aspects of the sets, all look like they belong in 1968 and not 66, by making aesthetic quotes of common themes in the design of that period, he is claiming a contemporary place for a modern text.
The second reversal is one of cast. One of the alternate titles for the film was the degenerates ,and Fellini's cast is filled with attractive and sexualized youngsters, with an older Nero voyeuristically looking on, trying to recapture the potency of youth. The actors that he chose were mostly untested, with credentials in exploitation or B Films. For example, Martin Finder, who played Encolpio's previous two credits were for 1962's The Year of the Sex Olympics and 1961's The Bone Grinder. This flip from low art to high art works as a reversal as radical as Tremalichio assuming power over the Dinner Party.
These reversals work in a very specific way, as textual signifiers that things have changed, the old order has been surplanted and a new order will reign, sometimes for the length of a performance and sometimes for much longer. The Satyricon of Petronius was intended to be a larger social critique, one which historian Emily Gowers discusses in The Loaded Table:Representations of Food in Roman Culture.
Petronius's dinner party is the smug wallowing
of an aristocrat, who wipes bodily fluids and
the product of a parasitic culture off on to the freed
men beneath him. (31)
This view of Petronius is in line with Roman Satire, which began traditions that still hold today. The require a reversal of values, with the gluttony of the Dinner Party being a mockery of Roman Values of temperance and restraint. With the conduct of a lower man towards those with higher status a reversal of strict status lines and honour between those lines, if this honour is lost then order is lost and chaos ensues.
Neros ignoring of these codes, and ignoring of the Patricians in general, is more decadent then the sexual and religious breaks. But a glutton is not a good solider, he does not deny pleasure for the sake of the republic, he puts himself above the larger whole. Rome required allegiance to an ideal about place, and of the symbols of that place. It was collective. On the opposite end, Neros infatuation with young boys for longer then teaching periods was viewed as perverse. To have a wife, was to have children, and with luck boys. To have boys was to carry on citizenship.
In the first scenes of the dinner party (15;26-28), the lack of procreative energy was shown, first in he playing ball with boys, a silly game where all were equal. There was no attempt at teaching and no indication that these boys were sons. In fact it seemed like all of the people in those scenes were the same age. Second was the mention of two eunuchs, who's lack of testicles make them servile, domestic and weak. The only men that have appeared in the text so far are the old, the infirm and the very young. There are no good examples of Roman virility.
If Petronius is a satire of Roman values, then Fellini could be considered a satire of his time, especially the year 1968, which had a huge variety of events that related to how the world saw itself. This was the year where students chose violent protest in Germany (The Badher Mienhoff Gang), France (The Situationists led general strikes in May) and America (Chicago Democratic National Convention, in August). In Two major American liberal leaders were assassinated (Martin Luther King Jr and Robert Kennedy). The colonial war that the americans inherited from the French has major setbacks (The Tet Offensive.) and the Vatican called the first council of Bishops since the Council of Trent.
Although Fellini claimed that the only reason why he did this movie was money, his politically aware stance and his new found fame put him in the middle of many of these fights. As an Italian, the Catholic Church was a state church, and these councils were tearing apart
many of the faithful in Italy. As a leftist he had to chose between a more radical anarcho-communist shift, found in the actions in Paris, Berlin and Chicago, and a Ghandian approach which seemed to be lost in the deaths of the two men who most prominently led it, and he had to decide who his art served. This was the time of his greatest public success, and there was a need for him to give the world an opinion about where exactly he stood.
The Satyricon is full of wholes, through censorship and neglect from Christian scholars, huge holes have appeared in the text. It is fractured and so any text that is adapted from it will become fractured. But Burke quotes Fellini about this text, and he makes the accidental lucane deliberate:
"The missing parts, that is, the blanks between
one episode and the next...that buisness of
fragments really fascinated me" (167)
the satire of Fellini then is a satire of the world at large, it is what happens when the world falls apart and to mock it must also be to document it.
That documentary energy is something that marks both Fellini and Nero. Part of it is that to get the tone and content of what you are satirizing right means a close reading of the texts nuances. The authour needs to know not only what the text says directly, but what it says indirectly and what goes unsaid because of audience assumptions. Both Satyricons do both well.
To document is not to record, these are not intended to be direct transcriptions of the time, but symbolic recreations of what is happening in the world at large. Although both Petronius and Fellini did that sort of reportage. Petronius, as his last act, was to record all of Nero's sexual perversions and who they were fulfilled with. Fellini did something much less exciting in the documentary Ginger and Fred, which was a visual essay on gender and sex roles using the dancers as example.
There were facts in the works though. Using Michael Grave's biography as example, he tells us that Nero "was not a great eater or an exceptional drinker" but that the "appurtences of his meals were tremendously luxurious" (195), and then spends the rest of the page telling us exactly how wasteful Nero was. Among them were the facts that he never wore the same robe twice , his cups came from Persia and were said to posses a delicate scent and he used an emerald as an eye glass to watch gladiators. Compare this with Tromachio's silver chamber pots (15,26); the linen towels and the robes of finest wool (15, 28), the description of the household altar in 15,30 and the description of the dining clothes being of genuine Tyriaian purple a little later in that section.
The documentary energy in Fellini is one of authenticity of emotion and experience.
Mentioning the chaos of the world is to underestimate exactly what was happening. Not only was he part of a world that respected "art films". He was also part of an academic circle that was calling for inner knowledge as guideline towards behaviour (the surrealists), for the persons biography to be as legitimate as history (the neo realists), the reclaiming of spectacle as a subversive tool (Guy Debord), the conflation of high and low (The New Wave), the loosening of bourgeois sensibilities of marriage and sex (Free Love), the calling for the overthrow of the government and for the lack of order (Weather Underground, Black Panthers, Bader Mienhoff). Everything was falling apart around him, both aesthetically and physically. The creation of a narrative that moved away from a leads to b leads to z, was a way to reflect the reality of that circumstance. His choice of Satyricon matched all of what was surrounding him, and amplified it into art.
Remember though, that neither of these were really revolutionaries, and in many ways these documents were meant for very specific audiences. Both authours of these texts were not radicals, calling for the blood of kings and presidents. Petronius was an elite, who made entertainments for the court and when dishonour came to him, he followed with a proper Roman stoic suicide. Fellini made art films for those who watched them, even the radicals from that time often came from upper class families. He made films of the decadent rich, sometimes to mock them, sometimes because he wanted to be them, but he did not buy into the whole package like some of his companions. He wa nothing like Goddard, who decided Maoist film made sense, and from the mid 60s to the late 70s created impenetrable agitprop for the next revolution.
This also explains the other role of satire, namely a nostalgic looking back at what once was. Petronius and Fellini can afford to be nostalgic, they can imagine the past as some glorious golden age because they do not have to toil the fields or work in the grocery store. Brecht's maxim "first bread, then ethics" applies here, if your thoughts during the day surround where to eat or where to sleep, then the problems with the nature of the system are secondary. But both of these authours lived in extreme times, and that extremism radiated from the sources of power as much as it did from the edges."
There are problems that occurs from this point, and they are expanded by EJB Charelswhite in Latin Satire: The Structure of Persuasion: "Nero's day was one of clearly articulated extremes; both Horace's inquires and Juvenals pathos orientated discourses , would find no audience there." (154), he later goes on to say that there is a lack of moralism in Petronius's work, and that makes him an entertainer and not a satirist. Petronius identifies the problems of the emperor's, catalogues the excesses and notes the more absurd elements of life with Nero, but in many ways his work seems taxonomic, even his last act was an act of taxonomy. In Chareslwhite's view the only way you can be a moralist is to have easily absorbed lessons at the end of every chapter, and if it gets extreme enough, those morals cannot be understood so they barely count. However there is a barely disguised disgust to the work of Petronius, somewhere between a disbelief and a sadness for the old republic. The cataloguing is an almost neutral way of pointing to a moral of temperance.
Fellini is a bit more difficult to unpack, being caught between two forces, namely Hollywood and the European Art Tradition. They both have been said to preserve the same values, namely the struggle between individual freedoms and collective need. The Americans resolve this through the fraternity of westerns and the comraderie of war films, and the romantic comedies where women learn to be married. The rise of the European film added an anti hero who refused to bend. What is Breathless but an ideologically correct rereading of The Treasures of the Serria Madre ? Fellini's problem was a distrust of both methods, and his films then are a narrow negotiation between the individual and the collective, in Satyricon, the fracturing occurs when the collective will becomes too skewed, too perverse, too cruel or just not functional. It is not a satire then and not really the taxonomy of Petronius, but something new.
That newness is one that makes reading of Petronius through Fellini useful. We cannot know what Petronius truly intended, and to write about him is to write with the knowledge of the ravages of time in the front of your mind. When you say that there is no real allegory or moral in the text, the reader has to say, but there may be, and a monk who was careless or censorious could have clipped it out. Fellini is different, it is a whole text intended to be fractionary and fragmentary. It may not lie to us, but it does not tell the truth either. Gaps placed in a work are still gaps, especially if the person who cut it refuses to tell the viewer the context or content that may or may not be there. Both of these caveats make the work difficult to write about, and requires a wider net.
I wrote this essay assuming that Fellini was keyed into 1968, because everyone else was. I assumed that the fragments of the work were fragments a larger fragmentation of society because my reading told me that was a reasonable extrapolation. Fellini is not Passolini, in that he was not loyal to reflecting textual accuracy on screen. This was among his few adaptations and he split it apart to see what was inside. A biographical reading would assume that the fracturing was about his nervous breakdown. A textual reading would point out the gaps in the source text. Both of these are valid, but I think they underestimate the complexity of his vision.
The Satyricon is about Nero. The Satyricon is about the world corrupt and on verge of destruction, the Satyricon is an entertainment and pornography, and a classic work of Roman Satire, and a reflection of a courtiers idle. It is a work that is as slippery as a live salmon,
grasp it and it will wriggle out of your hand, but that is the joy of the work, it teaches flexibility.
Frederico Fellini adapted Satyricon to film between 1968 and 1969, finally releasing it in 1970. He thought that he was dying and he had a nervous breakdown in the middle of filming. This film was also the first he made after he had gained world wide fame and was acclimatizing to the spectacles that world wide fame could bring. When talking about this film, he claimed that he wanted to be in the spirit of the source text, rather then make any claims on literal truth. (Burke, 166). Part of that spirit could be the times. 1968 was an auspicious year in world history, with everything in flux, and the roles of power unsure. The adaptation to the spirit of the work instead of the text meant that he considered what happened in his own frame work, making the text as alive as the times.
Taking these two works together gives us context to talk about many of the issues that grounded Petronius in 66 and Fellini 1300 years later. In analyzing these works, the lenses I find most helpful are class and social breed, the documentary form in fictions and the nature of satire as a political and moral excercise. These texts allow a thorough examination of these lenses, talking about the larger contexts and purposes of the play and the film.
Starting with Class in Petronius is to understand how Nero played the upper classes against the lower. He was a Patrician, with the blood of emperors but did not act that way at all. He was a hero to the common man, because in the crudest sense, he kept them fed and entertained. The whole point of the spectacles that he put on was to make the lowest of the citizenry happy. In John Bishop's Nero the Man and his Legend, he describes how effective this
strategy could be:
"A considerable part of the people of Rome welcomed Nero...
and was frankly skeptical of the allegedly straight laced
properity of the Romans of an older generation." (119)
The problem then, was that Nero was too close to the common citzenry, and did not behave in a way expected of an emperor. This would also be the case in his "slumming", where he dressed himself as a slave, attended brothels and drinking places and looted stores with drunken thugs. This and a tendency to reward himself for acts of literary prowess (for example giving himself all of the laurels in the first Neronia, a poetry contest he founded and named after himself) isolated those in the senate. Being a poet at all, according to Bishop was "on the whole an object not of pride but of disgust" (114)
By even welcoming the pornography of Petronius into court, he brought the ideas of the street into rooms that had never seen them. This was not the clean and rigidly structured language of rhetoric but something else entirely. JP Sullivan explains it well in his Literature and Politics In the Age of Nero, saying that although "No literary minded emperor fails to include a considerable number of his friends among his courtiers", he "cared less about personal insults then most" and "libelous poems were a feature of court life" (154)
Fellini was slightly different when it came to class, not exactly in the court of the greatest power in the world, but respected and admired none the less. This was a time when art film was key, where movies with subtitles were watched with great interest, where immediate transportation and more disposable income made air travel common among the upper and lower classes, and where radical politics were combined with sexual freedom, especially among the very rich.
Fellini was especially rewarded for this, making a life style out of Le Dolce Vitae in 1960, and making a star out of Anita Ekberg in 1963's 8 1/2. The movies were shown on most american screens, colleges had film nights where these two films were shown, and the orgy scenes and attractive, almost superfluous nudity of the works would be a portent to the open marriages that seemed a trend in the 1970s.
Fellini saw this kind of sexual decadence in the mid 60s, before his production of the Satyricon, in the infamous New York Disco Electric Circus, he described it thusly:
"its dance floors were aswirl with multicoloured lights, there
were tropical fish, the floors were carpeted with nude bodies
and there were these enormous holes in the wall that had four
five, six pairs of feet, male and female, black and white protruded."
(quoted in Burke's Fellinis Films from Post War to Post Modern,172)
this sort of orgastic sexuality, with its openness to new avenues of discourse, lead many to abandoned other conventions, be it the family or the state. There was a reversal of order coming for Petronius and the Roman Empire as it was assumed the same case would be for the western democracies under Fellini.
Therefore a sense of reversal can be found in both Satyricons. In The dinner party scene in the original text Trimalchio is a country bumpkin playing at the rituals of the very rich, something that could not happen in really life. But if you reverse those scenes, and have an emperor playing at being poor, treating himself to common whores and cheap beer it would not lose it's satiric qualities. Petronius then preforms a double reversal, the more common one of the fool becoming a king and then a subtextual one, where in a shadow place the king becomes the fool. The shadow is dark however, because this was already occurring.
In Fellini it is much less clear. However there are two things that could mark this film as a reversal. The first is the production design and the second are the actors. In the production design of this film is deeply colourful and over the top, almost reaching camp porportions. The swirling colours, the odd camera angles, and the painterly aspects of the sets, all look like they belong in 1968 and not 66, by making aesthetic quotes of common themes in the design of that period, he is claiming a contemporary place for a modern text.
The second reversal is one of cast. One of the alternate titles for the film was the degenerates ,and Fellini's cast is filled with attractive and sexualized youngsters, with an older Nero voyeuristically looking on, trying to recapture the potency of youth. The actors that he chose were mostly untested, with credentials in exploitation or B Films. For example, Martin Finder, who played Encolpio's previous two credits were for 1962's The Year of the Sex Olympics and 1961's The Bone Grinder. This flip from low art to high art works as a reversal as radical as Tremalichio assuming power over the Dinner Party.
These reversals work in a very specific way, as textual signifiers that things have changed, the old order has been surplanted and a new order will reign, sometimes for the length of a performance and sometimes for much longer. The Satyricon of Petronius was intended to be a larger social critique, one which historian Emily Gowers discusses in The Loaded Table:Representations of Food in Roman Culture.
Petronius's dinner party is the smug wallowing
of an aristocrat, who wipes bodily fluids and
the product of a parasitic culture off on to the freed
men beneath him. (31)
This view of Petronius is in line with Roman Satire, which began traditions that still hold today. The require a reversal of values, with the gluttony of the Dinner Party being a mockery of Roman Values of temperance and restraint. With the conduct of a lower man towards those with higher status a reversal of strict status lines and honour between those lines, if this honour is lost then order is lost and chaos ensues.
Neros ignoring of these codes, and ignoring of the Patricians in general, is more decadent then the sexual and religious breaks. But a glutton is not a good solider, he does not deny pleasure for the sake of the republic, he puts himself above the larger whole. Rome required allegiance to an ideal about place, and of the symbols of that place. It was collective. On the opposite end, Neros infatuation with young boys for longer then teaching periods was viewed as perverse. To have a wife, was to have children, and with luck boys. To have boys was to carry on citizenship.
In the first scenes of the dinner party (15;26-28), the lack of procreative energy was shown, first in he playing ball with boys, a silly game where all were equal. There was no attempt at teaching and no indication that these boys were sons. In fact it seemed like all of the people in those scenes were the same age. Second was the mention of two eunuchs, who's lack of testicles make them servile, domestic and weak. The only men that have appeared in the text so far are the old, the infirm and the very young. There are no good examples of Roman virility.
If Petronius is a satire of Roman values, then Fellini could be considered a satire of his time, especially the year 1968, which had a huge variety of events that related to how the world saw itself. This was the year where students chose violent protest in Germany (The Badher Mienhoff Gang), France (The Situationists led general strikes in May) and America (Chicago Democratic National Convention, in August). In Two major American liberal leaders were assassinated (Martin Luther King Jr and Robert Kennedy). The colonial war that the americans inherited from the French has major setbacks (The Tet Offensive.) and the Vatican called the first council of Bishops since the Council of Trent.
Although Fellini claimed that the only reason why he did this movie was money, his politically aware stance and his new found fame put him in the middle of many of these fights. As an Italian, the Catholic Church was a state church, and these councils were tearing apart
many of the faithful in Italy. As a leftist he had to chose between a more radical anarcho-communist shift, found in the actions in Paris, Berlin and Chicago, and a Ghandian approach which seemed to be lost in the deaths of the two men who most prominently led it, and he had to decide who his art served. This was the time of his greatest public success, and there was a need for him to give the world an opinion about where exactly he stood.
The Satyricon is full of wholes, through censorship and neglect from Christian scholars, huge holes have appeared in the text. It is fractured and so any text that is adapted from it will become fractured. But Burke quotes Fellini about this text, and he makes the accidental lucane deliberate:
"The missing parts, that is, the blanks between
one episode and the next...that buisness of
fragments really fascinated me" (167)
the satire of Fellini then is a satire of the world at large, it is what happens when the world falls apart and to mock it must also be to document it.
That documentary energy is something that marks both Fellini and Nero. Part of it is that to get the tone and content of what you are satirizing right means a close reading of the texts nuances. The authour needs to know not only what the text says directly, but what it says indirectly and what goes unsaid because of audience assumptions. Both Satyricons do both well.
To document is not to record, these are not intended to be direct transcriptions of the time, but symbolic recreations of what is happening in the world at large. Although both Petronius and Fellini did that sort of reportage. Petronius, as his last act, was to record all of Nero's sexual perversions and who they were fulfilled with. Fellini did something much less exciting in the documentary Ginger and Fred, which was a visual essay on gender and sex roles using the dancers as example.
There were facts in the works though. Using Michael Grave's biography as example, he tells us that Nero "was not a great eater or an exceptional drinker" but that the "appurtences of his meals were tremendously luxurious" (195), and then spends the rest of the page telling us exactly how wasteful Nero was. Among them were the facts that he never wore the same robe twice , his cups came from Persia and were said to posses a delicate scent and he used an emerald as an eye glass to watch gladiators. Compare this with Tromachio's silver chamber pots (15,26); the linen towels and the robes of finest wool (15, 28), the description of the household altar in 15,30 and the description of the dining clothes being of genuine Tyriaian purple a little later in that section.
The documentary energy in Fellini is one of authenticity of emotion and experience.
Mentioning the chaos of the world is to underestimate exactly what was happening. Not only was he part of a world that respected "art films". He was also part of an academic circle that was calling for inner knowledge as guideline towards behaviour (the surrealists), for the persons biography to be as legitimate as history (the neo realists), the reclaiming of spectacle as a subversive tool (Guy Debord), the conflation of high and low (The New Wave), the loosening of bourgeois sensibilities of marriage and sex (Free Love), the calling for the overthrow of the government and for the lack of order (Weather Underground, Black Panthers, Bader Mienhoff). Everything was falling apart around him, both aesthetically and physically. The creation of a narrative that moved away from a leads to b leads to z, was a way to reflect the reality of that circumstance. His choice of Satyricon matched all of what was surrounding him, and amplified it into art.
Remember though, that neither of these were really revolutionaries, and in many ways these documents were meant for very specific audiences. Both authours of these texts were not radicals, calling for the blood of kings and presidents. Petronius was an elite, who made entertainments for the court and when dishonour came to him, he followed with a proper Roman stoic suicide. Fellini made art films for those who watched them, even the radicals from that time often came from upper class families. He made films of the decadent rich, sometimes to mock them, sometimes because he wanted to be them, but he did not buy into the whole package like some of his companions. He wa nothing like Goddard, who decided Maoist film made sense, and from the mid 60s to the late 70s created impenetrable agitprop for the next revolution.
This also explains the other role of satire, namely a nostalgic looking back at what once was. Petronius and Fellini can afford to be nostalgic, they can imagine the past as some glorious golden age because they do not have to toil the fields or work in the grocery store. Brecht's maxim "first bread, then ethics" applies here, if your thoughts during the day surround where to eat or where to sleep, then the problems with the nature of the system are secondary. But both of these authours lived in extreme times, and that extremism radiated from the sources of power as much as it did from the edges."
There are problems that occurs from this point, and they are expanded by EJB Charelswhite in Latin Satire: The Structure of Persuasion: "Nero's day was one of clearly articulated extremes; both Horace's inquires and Juvenals pathos orientated discourses , would find no audience there." (154), he later goes on to say that there is a lack of moralism in Petronius's work, and that makes him an entertainer and not a satirist. Petronius identifies the problems of the emperor's, catalogues the excesses and notes the more absurd elements of life with Nero, but in many ways his work seems taxonomic, even his last act was an act of taxonomy. In Chareslwhite's view the only way you can be a moralist is to have easily absorbed lessons at the end of every chapter, and if it gets extreme enough, those morals cannot be understood so they barely count. However there is a barely disguised disgust to the work of Petronius, somewhere between a disbelief and a sadness for the old republic. The cataloguing is an almost neutral way of pointing to a moral of temperance.
Fellini is a bit more difficult to unpack, being caught between two forces, namely Hollywood and the European Art Tradition. They both have been said to preserve the same values, namely the struggle between individual freedoms and collective need. The Americans resolve this through the fraternity of westerns and the comraderie of war films, and the romantic comedies where women learn to be married. The rise of the European film added an anti hero who refused to bend. What is Breathless but an ideologically correct rereading of The Treasures of the Serria Madre ? Fellini's problem was a distrust of both methods, and his films then are a narrow negotiation between the individual and the collective, in Satyricon, the fracturing occurs when the collective will becomes too skewed, too perverse, too cruel or just not functional. It is not a satire then and not really the taxonomy of Petronius, but something new.
That newness is one that makes reading of Petronius through Fellini useful. We cannot know what Petronius truly intended, and to write about him is to write with the knowledge of the ravages of time in the front of your mind. When you say that there is no real allegory or moral in the text, the reader has to say, but there may be, and a monk who was careless or censorious could have clipped it out. Fellini is different, it is a whole text intended to be fractionary and fragmentary. It may not lie to us, but it does not tell the truth either. Gaps placed in a work are still gaps, especially if the person who cut it refuses to tell the viewer the context or content that may or may not be there. Both of these caveats make the work difficult to write about, and requires a wider net.
I wrote this essay assuming that Fellini was keyed into 1968, because everyone else was. I assumed that the fragments of the work were fragments a larger fragmentation of society because my reading told me that was a reasonable extrapolation. Fellini is not Passolini, in that he was not loyal to reflecting textual accuracy on screen. This was among his few adaptations and he split it apart to see what was inside. A biographical reading would assume that the fracturing was about his nervous breakdown. A textual reading would point out the gaps in the source text. Both of these are valid, but I think they underestimate the complexity of his vision.
The Satyricon is about Nero. The Satyricon is about the world corrupt and on verge of destruction, the Satyricon is an entertainment and pornography, and a classic work of Roman Satire, and a reflection of a courtiers idle. It is a work that is as slippery as a live salmon,
grasp it and it will wriggle out of your hand, but that is the joy of the work, it teaches flexibility.
Friday, December 05, 2003
Sucide Bombing is a meme that has spread hard and fast in the last few months, the most recent attack featured Chechans and a train "between the towns of Mineralniye Vody and Kislovodsk." Tactically Sucide bombing is wise, there are a few casulties, but yr issue gets front play on the news papers. The long range moral, social and political consquences have not been adressed, though.
The Maciejowski Bible a lush, gothic illustrative text, from ca 1250 and paris. One of the most heartrending in its beauty.
the geometry of The Tower of Babel, and what it tells us about cathederal building, The Bloody violence in The Rescuing of Lot is like something out of Chanson Roland, The hanging of the King of Hai remarks on executions public spectacle..etc, etc
the geometry of The Tower of Babel, and what it tells us about cathederal building, The Bloody violence in The Rescuing of Lot is like something out of Chanson Roland, The hanging of the King of Hai remarks on executions public spectacle..etc, etc
good blog entry on where exactly pound fits among the other poets, with a bent towards french symbolists
Youve seen this everywhere, but there is something esp. cruel about making a childs mother obscene, and immoral.
via uffish, mefi
via uffish, mefi
Michael Tarintino was one of those rare currators who viewed a work in its whole context, and did not diffentrate between the high and low, his show on Hitchcock (called Nortious) featured sculpture, painting, drawing, installation and print making but also props, posters, and other items related to the films production. In Enclosed and Enchanted he took the english garden and reintroduced it to nature.
Anqays, brilliant and kind man, has died at 55
Anqays, brilliant and kind man, has died at 55
Small group of fundies tries to make history teacher Gary Cole avoid teaching about non christian civilations.
He views this as ridiculous, and sues.
via fark.
He views this as ridiculous, and sues.
via fark.
Henry Kissenger, the dark knight of the American Empire, bringing peace at the edge of an icbm, told Navy Adm. César Augusto Guzzetti of Argentina that he "would like them to suceed" in a rather ugly dirty war ca. 1970.
What did Suceed mean ? the "disappearence" of 30, 000 citizens (that word has always chilled me, because it is so ambigous, we can assume death but never prove it. )
we can add this to war crimes he has been accused of in east timor, laos, camdoia, vietnam, chile, and bangladesh
body and soul
What did Suceed mean ? the "disappearence" of 30, 000 citizens (that word has always chilled me, because it is so ambigous, we can assume death but never prove it. )
we can add this to war crimes he has been accused of in east timor, laos, camdoia, vietnam, chile, and bangladesh
body and soul
Tuesday, December 02, 2003
The US Central Intelligence Agency has acknowledged it "lacked specific information" about alleged Iraqi weapons of mass destruction when it compiled an intelligence estimate last year that served to justify the US-led invasion of Iraq
i think that we have killed thousands of guessing directed by certain economics, we are in orwells world of preptual war butressed with double speak.
via yahoo.
i think that we have killed thousands of guessing directed by certain economics, we are in orwells world of preptual war butressed with double speak.
via yahoo.
Monday, December 01, 2003
Saturday, November 29, 2003
this asshole should lighten the fuck up, if you dont want to read the cathcher in the rye, you shouldn't--its really not worth yr time or effort. But tell them its irrelavant(sp) or that it offends you asa class warrior, or that you think that the women depicted are sillhoute symbol or anything but the fact it contains the f word.
Bitter and hard edged, the work of Tom Sach makes twee and cute bare their carnvious teeth. Reclaiming consumer packaging and captalist detruius into bullying threats, including a hello kitty painting with the caption "chill out japan or you will be nuked again"
We want to stop men from treating us like sex objects, as they have always done. We want them to ignore our appearance and to be attentive to our personalities and mind. We want them to take us seriously and treat us as equals and not just chase us around for our bodies and physical looks.
from an article explaining the polical and social implications of the Hijab. Look, i know that this makes me racist, but the HIjab makes me uncomfortable. I do not know enough about muslim culture, and i think hiding bodies is like hiding light under bushels.
but what is the difference b/w a muslim woman wearing a hijab to please her culture and a western woman wearing a bikini to please hers ?
from an article explaining the polical and social implications of the Hijab. Look, i know that this makes me racist, but the HIjab makes me uncomfortable. I do not know enough about muslim culture, and i think hiding bodies is like hiding light under bushels.
but what is the difference b/w a muslim woman wearing a hijab to please her culture and a western woman wearing a bikini to please hers ?
online catalog of childrens book illustrations via ucla.
wonderfully odd and in places strangely cruel, from a time where kids were treated with much less delicacy.
wonderfully odd and in places strangely cruel, from a time where kids were treated with much less delicacy.
Andy Scott, New Brunswick MP, is fag bashed by a vocal detractor of gay marriage.
i think this is a good reason to be against it.
i think this is a good reason to be against it.
The New BMW is so wonderfully beautiful, that it is a shame that according to those in know dont think it is very fuctional.
the thing is, the amazing wonderful thing is, how deep these peoples love and ethusanism (sp) lie, they yell and blurt and ramble over hill and dale explaining why their passions are so nuriishing(sp)
like chris on charles ives sympthy no. 4
or ryan on sally mann, whose work before this i had considered cheap and explotive--he puts the full weight of his force arround the word beutiful (sp) and does not deny the obv. subtext, but renders it meaningless.
i also got to play with a digital camera, and took a couple of good shots--plus they think that i am a talented and clever photog.
like chris on charles ives sympthy no. 4
or ryan on sally mann, whose work before this i had considered cheap and explotive--he puts the full weight of his force arround the word beutiful (sp) and does not deny the obv. subtext, but renders it meaningless.
i also got to play with a digital camera, and took a couple of good shots--plus they think that i am a talented and clever photog.
chris and ryan are here and in the last 48 hours
we have talked about:
venturi
gehry
sally mann
tom berrigan
south park
the lds church
white on white in art
white and white churches
modernism
the meanings and purposes of venacualr
whether Baudilard (sp) would cream over WEM
John Cage
Charles Ives
Gertude Stein
Ezra Pound
The Raunchy Young Lepers
etc
We have done:
driving around edmonton
gone bowling
went to the mall and seen all the absurd big stuff
had a gig that went well except for the nil audience.
got drunk on gimlets
Listened to:
Ned Ragget-Reads the Alamanac
Raunchy Young Lepers Best Of
The Streets-Orignial Pirate Material
Marriane Faithful-Kissing Time
Bob Dylan-Slow Train Coming,
Momus-The Best of The Creation Years
John Cage-Atlas Eclipticalis
Lou Reed-Transformer
Beach Boys-Pet Sounds
FBH-one of the first eps.
and more.
im happy, drunk but happy.
we have talked about:
venturi
gehry
sally mann
tom berrigan
south park
the lds church
white on white in art
white and white churches
modernism
the meanings and purposes of venacualr
whether Baudilard (sp) would cream over WEM
John Cage
Charles Ives
Gertude Stein
Ezra Pound
The Raunchy Young Lepers
etc
We have done:
driving around edmonton
gone bowling
went to the mall and seen all the absurd big stuff
had a gig that went well except for the nil audience.
got drunk on gimlets
Listened to:
Ned Ragget-Reads the Alamanac
Raunchy Young Lepers Best Of
The Streets-Orignial Pirate Material
Marriane Faithful-Kissing Time
Bob Dylan-Slow Train Coming,
Momus-The Best of The Creation Years
John Cage-Atlas Eclipticalis
Lou Reed-Transformer
Beach Boys-Pet Sounds
FBH-one of the first eps.
and more.
im happy, drunk but happy.
Thursday, November 27, 2003
cascade
from oblique
cold
outside
down quick
drip drop drap
midmorningmelts
magpie on snowbound
pineboughs, and sees ice
white snow and slivers of silver ice
green bough, black bird shines against
all this darkness, coldness, i am inside and
i watch the bird, the bough, the ice, the snow
light melting coldness, pointless reflection on how it
all cascades into an almost nonesense meaning in my head
cause the bird is free, you see and i am not, here with out the cold
from oblique
cold
outside
down quick
drip drop drap
midmorningmelts
magpie on snowbound
pineboughs, and sees ice
white snow and slivers of silver ice
green bough, black bird shines against
all this darkness, coldness, i am inside and
i watch the bird, the bough, the ice, the snow
light melting coldness, pointless reflection on how it
all cascades into an almost nonesense meaning in my head
cause the bird is free, you see and i am not, here with out the cold
Flash Version of Oblique Strategies always too self concious a writer to use these, i really should start.
Criticism of the theory that superpowers at war can ever be humanist--i think that what pisses me off most about the iraqi war is how unbalanced the power is (cf isreal with fighter jets/Palestine with Petrol bombs; c/c Vietcong winning their war against the americans)
UK lets post op transsexuals to adopt and marry in the sex that they have assumed.
last two thnx to queer day
last two thnx to queer day
Co-ed Dorms are considered, which i think is a good idea, wy to deconstruct binaries, demythologize sex difference, encourage knoweldge of how much genders have in common.
Yukos hands 30k pages of info to the Russian Gvt, this thing will take years to sort out, and perhaps the first volly in a new kind of war
moscow times
moscow times
Joesph Cornell never left his house on long island, collected trash, was eccentric and had an odd realtionship with his mother. He still made it to the galleries almost weekly, and in the mean time made objects of such lonely strangeness, brief journeys into the way his mind worked.
They speak a different language, a language of obession and inelegance, a desperate whispering in a way to be heard.
He He would be 100 next year, Fiegel and Co. in NYC has a retrospective.
mysterium.
They speak a different language, a language of obession and inelegance, a desperate whispering in a way to be heard.
He He would be 100 next year, Fiegel and Co. in NYC has a retrospective.
mysterium.
Encylopedic site of illustration from 3 centuries.
Tender, and Beautiful, mostly concened with narrative or persuasion, there art sublimated by commerce or need of other authors, in many ways the exact opposite of andre.
Tender, and Beautiful, mostly concened with narrative or persuasion, there art sublimated by commerce or need of other authors, in many ways the exact opposite of andre.
Look, I know most people who read this do not really care about Carl Andre, but he moves me deeply, so do me a favour and read this long article on bricks and art, then tell me what you think about these:
Wednesday, November 26, 2003
Josh put up a rather legalistic list of what makes a person a Chrsitian, and I would like to respond with my definition:
A Christian is a person who belives in the contuining mission of Christ.
and on that note, Frances Kesling on women in ministry:
...What it would do is make Catholicism similar to the church that Jesus Christ established -- a church in which men and women were acknowledged as equals. If one really looks at the history of the gospels, one sees that women played the most central ministerial roles in the church's early days. After all, Jesus Christ was born to a woman, Jesus Christ was anointed to his own ministry by a woman. It was the women who stood at the cross with Jesus when he was crucified and to whom Jesus first appeared when he rose from the dead and said 'Go forth and let others know of this.'"
Kesling is the leader of Catholics for Free Choice, a radically inclusive org. that matches most of my politics, found here--coming from an article about priests and nuns in el salvador found here
A Christian is a person who belives in the contuining mission of Christ.
and on that note, Frances Kesling on women in ministry:
...What it would do is make Catholicism similar to the church that Jesus Christ established -- a church in which men and women were acknowledged as equals. If one really looks at the history of the gospels, one sees that women played the most central ministerial roles in the church's early days. After all, Jesus Christ was born to a woman, Jesus Christ was anointed to his own ministry by a woman. It was the women who stood at the cross with Jesus when he was crucified and to whom Jesus first appeared when he rose from the dead and said 'Go forth and let others know of this.'"
Kesling is the leader of Catholics for Free Choice, a radically inclusive org. that matches most of my politics, found here--coming from an article about priests and nuns in el salvador found here
POP FOCUS TIME !!
Ultrabeat - Pretty Green Eye 3
If Crystal Gale sang it with Autoharp by June Carter Cash the words would be prefect.
As it is, it reminds me of A Night at the Roxbury, which makes it just pathetic.
S Club 8 – Sundown 8
The absolute robotic perfection of this suggests that the English have a secret factory somewhere in the midlands designed to pump out self referential plastic pop stars. This is a good thing.
The Rapture - House of Jealous Lovers 7
Garbage cans percussion that pounds and propulses violent, ugly noise. Reminding the Garage Rock Stars how dangerous Rock and Roll used to be. The scream, the lack of control, the paranoid terror, it’s all here. What is missing is a siren, it needs a siren.
Rachel Stevens - Sweet Dreams My LA Ex 9
Happy on the outside and sad on the inside like most of the really excellent Brill Building song s but built for the 21st century. She has perfected when to be silent and when to speak, her phrasing is exquisite.
Pharrell feat Jay Z – Frontin 9
Really minimalist, in the way that the percussion and electronic effects are used to support a narrative which is surprisingly beautiful. Breaks wide open when Jay Z comes in and it becomes a discussion between “singing” and “rapping”
Nelly P Diddy Murphy Lee - Shake Ya Tailfeather 5
A single so obsessed with making sure that it is a number one that it manages to stuff everything in with out meaning anything, or even being very memorable.
Mark Owen - Four Minute Warning 1
Marc Almond’s urban grime cleaned off before he goes into another studio loft.
Lumidee - Never Leave You (Uh Oh) 9
Fucking gorgeous. They enter my brain and haven’t left for weeks, I sing it in the shower, I sing it on the bus, and I hum it under my breath in class. I wish love were as happy and optimistic as this song.
Jamelia – Superstar 5
Generic dance hit, with scratching, inoffensive.
Girls Aloud - Life Got Cold 5
Deeply lonely, frustrating, and sad. Who knew there was a dark side to texting.
Dido - White Flag 10+10
This has a tenderness that recalls early Joni Mitchell but the sheer self-loathing of these single makes the listener want to love her as best as they can
Daniel Bedingfield - Never Gonna Leave Your Side 2
Sweet and gentle, but nothing special.
Busted - Sleeping With The Light On 0+0
Mawkish and sentimental, emotion by focus group.
Blu Cantrell feat Sean Paul – Breathe 9
it reminds me that dancehall was street music, where the one with the most powerful voice would win.
The sound effects come straight from the Shangri Las.
Blu Cantrell has the pipes to be another Roberta Flack, why does she not have a larger Career.
Black Eyed Peas - Where Is The Love? 10
A definite lovely beat that does not overwhelm, and a refrain that becomes more and more haunting with each repetition.
Ultrabeat - Pretty Green Eye 3
If Crystal Gale sang it with Autoharp by June Carter Cash the words would be prefect.
As it is, it reminds me of A Night at the Roxbury, which makes it just pathetic.
S Club 8 – Sundown 8
The absolute robotic perfection of this suggests that the English have a secret factory somewhere in the midlands designed to pump out self referential plastic pop stars. This is a good thing.
The Rapture - House of Jealous Lovers 7
Garbage cans percussion that pounds and propulses violent, ugly noise. Reminding the Garage Rock Stars how dangerous Rock and Roll used to be. The scream, the lack of control, the paranoid terror, it’s all here. What is missing is a siren, it needs a siren.
Rachel Stevens - Sweet Dreams My LA Ex 9
Happy on the outside and sad on the inside like most of the really excellent Brill Building song s but built for the 21st century. She has perfected when to be silent and when to speak, her phrasing is exquisite.
Pharrell feat Jay Z – Frontin 9
Really minimalist, in the way that the percussion and electronic effects are used to support a narrative which is surprisingly beautiful. Breaks wide open when Jay Z comes in and it becomes a discussion between “singing” and “rapping”
Nelly P Diddy Murphy Lee - Shake Ya Tailfeather 5
A single so obsessed with making sure that it is a number one that it manages to stuff everything in with out meaning anything, or even being very memorable.
Mark Owen - Four Minute Warning 1
Marc Almond’s urban grime cleaned off before he goes into another studio loft.
Lumidee - Never Leave You (Uh Oh) 9
Fucking gorgeous. They enter my brain and haven’t left for weeks, I sing it in the shower, I sing it on the bus, and I hum it under my breath in class. I wish love were as happy and optimistic as this song.
Jamelia – Superstar 5
Generic dance hit, with scratching, inoffensive.
Girls Aloud - Life Got Cold 5
Deeply lonely, frustrating, and sad. Who knew there was a dark side to texting.
Dido - White Flag 10+10
This has a tenderness that recalls early Joni Mitchell but the sheer self-loathing of these single makes the listener want to love her as best as they can
Daniel Bedingfield - Never Gonna Leave Your Side 2
Sweet and gentle, but nothing special.
Busted - Sleeping With The Light On 0+0
Mawkish and sentimental, emotion by focus group.
Blu Cantrell feat Sean Paul – Breathe 9
it reminds me that dancehall was street music, where the one with the most powerful voice would win.
The sound effects come straight from the Shangri Las.
Blu Cantrell has the pipes to be another Roberta Flack, why does she not have a larger Career.
Black Eyed Peas - Where Is The Love? 10
A definite lovely beat that does not overwhelm, and a refrain that becomes more and more haunting with each repetition.
Tuesday, November 25, 2003
Ultrabeat - Pretty Green Eyes
So Solid Crew - Broken Silence
S Club 8 - Sundown
Richard X feat Kelis - Finest Dreams
The Rapture - House Of Jealous Lovers
Rachel Stevens - Sweet Dreams My LA Ex
Pharrell feat Jay Z - Frontin
Outkast - Ghettomusick
Nelly P Diddy Murphy Lee - Shake Ya Tailfeather
Mark Owen - Four Minute Warning
Lumidee - Never Leave You (Uh Oh)
Jamelia - Superstar
Girls Aloud - Life Got Cold
Elton John - Are You Ready For Love?
Dido - White Flag
The Darkness - I Believe In A Thing Called Love
Daniel Bedingfield - Never Gonna Leave Your Side
Busted - Sleeping With The Light On
Blu Cantrell feat Sean Paul - Breathe
Black Eyed Peas - Where Is The Love?
So Solid Crew - Broken Silence
S Club 8 - Sundown
Richard X feat Kelis - Finest Dreams
The Rapture - House Of Jealous Lovers
Rachel Stevens - Sweet Dreams My LA Ex
Pharrell feat Jay Z - Frontin
Outkast - Ghettomusick
Nelly P Diddy Murphy Lee - Shake Ya Tailfeather
Mark Owen - Four Minute Warning
Lumidee - Never Leave You (Uh Oh)
Jamelia - Superstar
Girls Aloud - Life Got Cold
Elton John - Are You Ready For Love?
Dido - White Flag
The Darkness - I Believe In A Thing Called Love
Daniel Bedingfield - Never Gonna Leave Your Side
Busted - Sleeping With The Light On
Blu Cantrell feat Sean Paul - Breathe
Black Eyed Peas - Where Is The Love?
Monday, November 24, 2003
Sunday, November 23, 2003
Paul Celan, a poet i have always meant to research, would have been 83 today.
here is one of my favourites:
0 little root of a dream
you hold me here
undermined by blood,
no longer visible to anyone,
property of death.
Curve a face
that there may be speech, of earth,
of ardor, of
things with eyes, even
here, where you read me blind,
even
here,
where you
refute me,
to the letter.
here is one of my favourites:
0 little root of a dream
you hold me here
undermined by blood,
no longer visible to anyone,
property of death.
Curve a face
that there may be speech, of earth,
of ardor, of
things with eyes, even
here, where you read me blind,
even
here,
where you
refute me,
to the letter.
The methods that that almost worked in Paris '68 and Seattle '99 might have worked in Georgia this month.
queer zines, an underground for radical socio-sexual information, just at the cusp of the internet.
deeply vital, and beatuiful at the same time.
Chris from Uffish found this archive.
deeply vital, and beatuiful at the same time.
Chris from Uffish found this archive.
Culture Jammer, Art Warrior and Camp Follower Banksy will make you want to fuck Queen Vic and orchestrate liberation raids for Baloo.
. . . there is now a professional, well-trained elite, supported by large institutions, that is adept and willing to use corrupt practices to accumulate wealth. Despite assurances from game-theorists and anthropologists that the criminal cadre in the species remains a constant percentage over time, I believe today's mainstream, sanitized, and institutionally sanctioned financial crime rackets are being run by a new breed of crook. There have always been scandals and crooks in the history of American money, but our predator class is a distinct creation of the late 20th century.
I believe there is no way the counter-class made up of regulators, watchdogs and do-gooders and hack columnists can match wits with the predator class. Today's piles of money are so huge, great fortunes can be amassed by swiping the tiniest of slices in the wiliest of ways long before picked pocket
from the head of CBS News.Com
6 different ways
700 russians who are trying out for the Duma are hiding their millions , as an attempt to be more populist.
(its like John Kerry ignoring his Forbes family mother--or Dean forgetting exactly how much he made last year, or Dubya pretending to be the good 'ol (cow)boy
(its like John Kerry ignoring his Forbes family mother--or Dean forgetting exactly how much he made last year, or Dubya pretending to be the good 'ol (cow)boy
Bryan's Orgination theory holds that traditonal structures of power have their roots so intertwinned that they cannot be removed. When the Death Sqauds drink with the police in columbia, i think he might be right.
Body and Soul
Body and Soul
Thursday i told my therapist i wanted to kill myself.
Thursday evening Andrew and Bryan took me to the hospital, the safe ward.
Thursday Night bryan bought me wendys and picked up some things for me.
Thursday later night the doctors gave me pills.
Friday I ate and slept and read, its the worst ive ever been, and the closest. I asked for Bittner cause I thot I would need last rites.
Saturday morning Bittner came and took confession.
Jeff and Michelle brought books
Mom bought newspaper and Reese peanut butter cups.
AJ and Dad Came.
Trevor came, a surprise, with Lindt chocolotes and his new son (Caleb, Blond and Blue eyed, 8 mos. that inquistveness(sp) and joy between them too.)
I left sunday at noon.
I have new drugs, wellbutrin and a cousin to risperdone.
Bryan made me lunch.
Thursday evening Andrew and Bryan took me to the hospital, the safe ward.
Thursday Night bryan bought me wendys and picked up some things for me.
Thursday later night the doctors gave me pills.
Friday I ate and slept and read, its the worst ive ever been, and the closest. I asked for Bittner cause I thot I would need last rites.
Saturday morning Bittner came and took confession.
Jeff and Michelle brought books
Mom bought newspaper and Reese peanut butter cups.
AJ and Dad Came.
Trevor came, a surprise, with Lindt chocolotes and his new son (Caleb, Blond and Blue eyed, 8 mos. that inquistveness(sp) and joy between them too.)
I left sunday at noon.
I have new drugs, wellbutrin and a cousin to risperdone.
Bryan made me lunch.
He used to meditate between the orientalism of the west and the fetishizing of western progress found in Japan. With the mushroom cloud deaths head bunny he asked Japan if they could make anything cute, with My Lonesome Cowboy , the 12 foot anime wanker with a cum lasso he asked “if I make your obsessions large enough, will you pay attention, with Mr Dobbs , his post colonial Mickey Mouse with teeth, he whispered “you will buy this consumer product, you no longer care about content.”
He then dropped politics, and made lovely pictures and strange spectacles. There was the flower wallpaper paintings in bright colours that did not say anything but this is pretty to look at or the Francis Bacon paintings which made existential fury into a sci-fi wonderland thanks to his army of courtiers
Finally there is the latest style, an abstract pattern of eyes and circles, made to envelop Louis Vuitton Handbags, Cadillac Escalades, portraits of Kate Moss and 10 foot canvases with equal vapidness. He has become a designer and his anger dissipated into money.
Which makes his latest sculptures, featuring a new character named Mr Cloud, so disappointing and so liberating. They have a super specific joy about them, the open candy apple mouth, the stuffed animal wide eyes, the amorphous huggable shape, the hard plastic of hip designed consumables. It is an icon of Nintendo aestheics,a triumph of late era decadent design,
It’s the hello kitty of superflat.
I wrote this 6 weeks ago for brown wedge
Artnet posted this today under the title "the fraudalence of Murakami
He then dropped politics, and made lovely pictures and strange spectacles. There was the flower wallpaper paintings in bright colours that did not say anything but this is pretty to look at or the Francis Bacon paintings which made existential fury into a sci-fi wonderland thanks to his army of courtiers
Finally there is the latest style, an abstract pattern of eyes and circles, made to envelop Louis Vuitton Handbags, Cadillac Escalades, portraits of Kate Moss and 10 foot canvases with equal vapidness. He has become a designer and his anger dissipated into money.
Which makes his latest sculptures, featuring a new character named Mr Cloud, so disappointing and so liberating. They have a super specific joy about them, the open candy apple mouth, the stuffed animal wide eyes, the amorphous huggable shape, the hard plastic of hip designed consumables. It is an icon of Nintendo aestheics,a triumph of late era decadent design,
It’s the hello kitty of superflat.
I wrote this 6 weeks ago for brown wedge
Artnet posted this today under the title "the fraudalence of Murakami
Thursday, November 20, 2003
A notice from local people who read this blog.
True Spirit North will host Edmonton’s first Trangender Day of Remembrance on Thursday, November 20 at 7:00 p.m. at Garneau United Church, 11148 – 84 Avenue. The event features a candlelight service to remember and honour those who have died. Several speakers will also focus on the challenges trans-identified people face as well as the issues that we must address including the need for solidarity within the queer community. The event is sponsored by True Spirit North (TS/TG Support Group), Lambda Christian Community Church, Garneau United Church, GLCCE (Gay & Lesbian Community Centre of Edmonton), Times .10 Magazine and Bad.
From
here
True Spirit North will host Edmonton’s first Trangender Day of Remembrance on Thursday, November 20 at 7:00 p.m. at Garneau United Church, 11148 – 84 Avenue. The event features a candlelight service to remember and honour those who have died. Several speakers will also focus on the challenges trans-identified people face as well as the issues that we must address including the need for solidarity within the queer community. The event is sponsored by True Spirit North (TS/TG Support Group), Lambda Christian Community Church, Garneau United Church, GLCCE (Gay & Lesbian Community Centre of Edmonton), Times .10 Magazine and Bad.
From
here
Wednesday, November 19, 2003
When I was in relationships, i had them with older men. a freudian would say that i was replacing an absent father, and maybe there was. how did I see myself ? I saw myself as a boy, who looked up at those who chose to love him and marvelled. I was a bottom. Not a physical bottom, but a psychological one.
I remember Edmund who sent white flowers to school on valentines, calla lilies, orchids, tulips (that slender small miracle of tulips in February, and slick greenery. That evening, as I walked off a bus, i was attacked. Blood commingled with snow and flowers, it hurt, but it was cinematic, and he was prone to large gestures. I was then a set piece, one who followed cues well.
I remember Kevin, who seduced me when he was on a missionary. There was a long slow seduction that I thought was religious, and then sexual and now i realize is both. He was sent back home to California after he begged the stake president and jesus to forgive him. I didn't realize what needed to be shameful, or forgiven. I got church court and excommunication. He has three kids and a house in Clovis, a suburb of Fresno. I was the acolyte, and the priest betrayed me.
I remember Adam. Who I was going to marry in a big pink tent, with John Coltrane as the music to go down the aisle to and the Magnetic Fields as our anthem of retreat. I loved his gentle, casual care. He would leave cinnamon buns on the counter in the morning after our encounters. He would hold my hand at lunch and put my foot on his foot at supper. He was tall, and I was not scared in his shadow. His presence became my refuge, until he left. I was the patsy there, playing house and thinking i was doing my duty as loyal wife.
Men leave. They are not to be trusted. They are silly, over obvious, take the safe root, promise to protect you and then do not. They are brutish, sometimes. But then I am at fault here, with my desire to be protected instead of loved. Two halves of the same whole never seems to happen, and the system of balance tilts to those who want power more. These are the relationships that lasted past the night or were somewhat more advanced then the adolescent fumblings of boarding schools at 13 and hospitals at 14. These were my proof that I was queer, that it was not theory and abstraction but a devoted practice, which had few rewards. Theory is safer. Foccualt is dead, he can never really hurt me.
I am queer. I am Catholic. I love men. I love Jesus. I arrived at these thoughts very early, just as i was becoming isolated from the Latter Day Saints. People do not understand, as a general rule. They wish I wasn't, and some days I agree with them.
I am celibate now, have been for a year and a half. I did so because I wanted to be a priest, and wanted to prove that I could do it. I did it cause i was not sure that I was happy looking for a relationship and I needed a break. I did it because I wanted to make sure I knew what love was before I climbed on board with the whole thing. I did it because I was becoming a cynic, and I thought that not thinking about it would make me happier. I never was truly celibate, desire that was supposed to drop away like leaves of a maple stayed forever. I can never avoid desire, and am no longer sure that I want to deny it or even re-channel it.
I wonder what Christ would say now about the issue. I wish that I did not have to pick through the bible looking for verses that i can use as narrow claims for a liberating agenda. Sometimes I think that the celibacy came because I internalized the homophobia of the church and bought into the idea that I am objectively disordered and that I could not have sex. There is a documentary called Trembling Before G-d about queer orthodox and Hasidic jews, which just won a few GLAAD awards. There was someone who said there "I am gay, that is what God made me, I cannot practice it, though. He did not make that mistake" (I am paraphrasing it) Conservative Christians who like to pretend compassion call it my Cross to bear. I think that Sex is a gift, but gifts need to be used, and I am not sure that by denying his gift I am showing proper thanks.
It is not the sex i mix, even now masturbation seems obligatory, something to do to relive anxiety or boredom or to go to sleep. An ineffective and inexpensive substitute for gin. It is the sense of communion, the resting my head in the clavicle of a lover, hearing his breathing and coming into an awareness that this is among the voices of God. I think also of my queer brothers as priests and queer sisters as nuns. Do they think of these issues or are they closeted to the point of denial ?
There is a cruel binary at work here. There are two options, marriage or priestly orders. We are not allowed to be fully and honestly either. So what do I do, continue in this romanticized ideal sexuality, away from the compilations, beg forgiveness and pretend my agitation means nothing.
I know that the Spirit does not mean the Church, I know that spirituality is different from religion, but at the end of the day who I cast my spiritual lot with was the Mother Church. They have grips on my soul, and they are making it very difficult to move. Even the loopholes feel like hangman's nooses.
What vision of myself ? There are a few of them. There is the one terrified of the wrath of God. There is the one who wants love. There is the one who would be satisfied by touch, and the one who wants just sex. There is the one who wants to be the bridegroom of Christ and the one who never wants to see Christ again. There is the one who wants to be Alexander to the Vaticans Gordian knot. There is the scared and obedient little boy. There is the one who capitulates to authority and the one who engages in punk nihilism for the hell of it.
I can best live out the vision of Gods wrath by being aware of it. God may be love, but it is the love of profound disappointment. To obey the rules but avoid legalism is the best way to do this but that requires knowing what exactly the source of the universe thinks about things. There are two commandments that Christ gives, to love god and love your fellow man. But that deals with the implications of agape not eros.
I can best live out the desire for love by loving myself. Cliched I know and rather an obvious cliche at, but its a difficult task for me, as my life seems to be a series of banal failures.
Within Christianity touch is easy to come by, if i bother showing up to mass, then the passing of the peace does wonders. But sex is another matter altogether. From Paul onward, Christianity has enough problems with simple sex between husband and wife, trying to view queer sex as sacred seems an impossibility. Maybe I could use Daoism or Hinduism but respect can turn into idolatry, which can turn into adultery. Christ requires monogamy.
There were nuns who wore wedding rings, and there were nuns who had orgasms thanks to the Lord's hand. I want both. Maybe I do in other ways, but it's easier to make a man a husband when he doesn't have to worry about the dishes or putting the toilet seat down. Having Christ as a husband is ideal, and ideal is not where the world runs.
Never wanting to see Christ again is bitterness and despair, both of which are mortal sins. Tell this to the priest and its worth a fair penance. Maybe thats enough ?
They would have to let me in to cut the knot, and they are not going to do that anytime soon. I become tired of beaurocracy quickly, and the exhaustion may suggest a break and then another go. I do not know in what forms this break would take.
Being a scared and obedient boy does not happen very often, and really it is a good thing in many ways, keeping me humble and keeping me aware of the awesome power of both God and his servants. Sometimes it changes over quickly, and I become the disobedient boy not being nice and making sure to point out that the pope is naked. This is when the punk nihilism comes in, it is refreshing to say "sod off" sometimes, refreshing and nessecary.
I think that marriage is about property and propriety, what is expected by lovers instead of any of the other options. I think that the possibility of gay marriage is heteronormative, a way to usurp the subversive powers of being a sexual others. I do not want our culture to be destroyed in a clambering attempt to be exactly like man and wife.
If human sexual practice is a buffet, then maybe marriage should be an item in it, something you can take or leave depending on preference or taste. Maybe if you are raising children it is more stable. Germaine Greer said this about love though: "Love, love, love -- all the wretched cant of it, masking egotism, lust, masochism, fantasy under a mythology of sentimental postures, a welter of self-induced miseries and joys, blinding and masking the essential personalities in the frozen gestures of courtship, in the kissing and the dating and the desire, the compliments and the quarrels which vivify its barrenness" and i think it applies to marriage. I think of how trapped Betty Friedan felt, and how my grandmother had to go back to school to avoid killing my grandfather. I realized how my mother tried to escape and never did. I remember generations of women who stayed together for the kids, and what special kind of heartbreak that must of been, the emotional equivalent of a backroom abortion.
This might be bitterness on my part though. My friends leave into a hermetic bubble after they get married and I lose them forever: Thomas and Mindy got married and I have not talked to them in months; the same applies to Tara and James, Erin and Garrett, and others. But thats not a marriage thing. My best friend Glenys fell in love with a wonderful girl, and now i talk to her once a month rather then once a week. I do not want to lose the community that i have pushed forward. But they seem happy and content and wonderfully together. It might last a life time, and that must be something to look forward to.
Maybe instead of theory, there is something else. I think one of the reasons I hate marriage is that I view myself too difficult to be a good catch, that no one would love me in a way that could be forever. The Mormons have a hymn that goes"families can stay together forever, according to Heavenly Fathers plan" and I remember talking to a church youth meeting just before I left the church, and I said the line "Some families cannot be together forever, mine for example"
So I don't know, my ideas about marriage is somewhere between being a hurt child of divorce, a profound series of loneliness, a theoretical understanding of heterosexuality, an isolation from the way the rest of the way the universe works and a cynical bitterness.
I remember Edmund who sent white flowers to school on valentines, calla lilies, orchids, tulips (that slender small miracle of tulips in February, and slick greenery. That evening, as I walked off a bus, i was attacked. Blood commingled with snow and flowers, it hurt, but it was cinematic, and he was prone to large gestures. I was then a set piece, one who followed cues well.
I remember Kevin, who seduced me when he was on a missionary. There was a long slow seduction that I thought was religious, and then sexual and now i realize is both. He was sent back home to California after he begged the stake president and jesus to forgive him. I didn't realize what needed to be shameful, or forgiven. I got church court and excommunication. He has three kids and a house in Clovis, a suburb of Fresno. I was the acolyte, and the priest betrayed me.
I remember Adam. Who I was going to marry in a big pink tent, with John Coltrane as the music to go down the aisle to and the Magnetic Fields as our anthem of retreat. I loved his gentle, casual care. He would leave cinnamon buns on the counter in the morning after our encounters. He would hold my hand at lunch and put my foot on his foot at supper. He was tall, and I was not scared in his shadow. His presence became my refuge, until he left. I was the patsy there, playing house and thinking i was doing my duty as loyal wife.
Men leave. They are not to be trusted. They are silly, over obvious, take the safe root, promise to protect you and then do not. They are brutish, sometimes. But then I am at fault here, with my desire to be protected instead of loved. Two halves of the same whole never seems to happen, and the system of balance tilts to those who want power more. These are the relationships that lasted past the night or were somewhat more advanced then the adolescent fumblings of boarding schools at 13 and hospitals at 14. These were my proof that I was queer, that it was not theory and abstraction but a devoted practice, which had few rewards. Theory is safer. Foccualt is dead, he can never really hurt me.
I am queer. I am Catholic. I love men. I love Jesus. I arrived at these thoughts very early, just as i was becoming isolated from the Latter Day Saints. People do not understand, as a general rule. They wish I wasn't, and some days I agree with them.
I am celibate now, have been for a year and a half. I did so because I wanted to be a priest, and wanted to prove that I could do it. I did it cause i was not sure that I was happy looking for a relationship and I needed a break. I did it because I wanted to make sure I knew what love was before I climbed on board with the whole thing. I did it because I was becoming a cynic, and I thought that not thinking about it would make me happier. I never was truly celibate, desire that was supposed to drop away like leaves of a maple stayed forever. I can never avoid desire, and am no longer sure that I want to deny it or even re-channel it.
I wonder what Christ would say now about the issue. I wish that I did not have to pick through the bible looking for verses that i can use as narrow claims for a liberating agenda. Sometimes I think that the celibacy came because I internalized the homophobia of the church and bought into the idea that I am objectively disordered and that I could not have sex. There is a documentary called Trembling Before G-d about queer orthodox and Hasidic jews, which just won a few GLAAD awards. There was someone who said there "I am gay, that is what God made me, I cannot practice it, though. He did not make that mistake" (I am paraphrasing it) Conservative Christians who like to pretend compassion call it my Cross to bear. I think that Sex is a gift, but gifts need to be used, and I am not sure that by denying his gift I am showing proper thanks.
It is not the sex i mix, even now masturbation seems obligatory, something to do to relive anxiety or boredom or to go to sleep. An ineffective and inexpensive substitute for gin. It is the sense of communion, the resting my head in the clavicle of a lover, hearing his breathing and coming into an awareness that this is among the voices of God. I think also of my queer brothers as priests and queer sisters as nuns. Do they think of these issues or are they closeted to the point of denial ?
There is a cruel binary at work here. There are two options, marriage or priestly orders. We are not allowed to be fully and honestly either. So what do I do, continue in this romanticized ideal sexuality, away from the compilations, beg forgiveness and pretend my agitation means nothing.
I know that the Spirit does not mean the Church, I know that spirituality is different from religion, but at the end of the day who I cast my spiritual lot with was the Mother Church. They have grips on my soul, and they are making it very difficult to move. Even the loopholes feel like hangman's nooses.
What vision of myself ? There are a few of them. There is the one terrified of the wrath of God. There is the one who wants love. There is the one who would be satisfied by touch, and the one who wants just sex. There is the one who wants to be the bridegroom of Christ and the one who never wants to see Christ again. There is the one who wants to be Alexander to the Vaticans Gordian knot. There is the scared and obedient little boy. There is the one who capitulates to authority and the one who engages in punk nihilism for the hell of it.
I can best live out the vision of Gods wrath by being aware of it. God may be love, but it is the love of profound disappointment. To obey the rules but avoid legalism is the best way to do this but that requires knowing what exactly the source of the universe thinks about things. There are two commandments that Christ gives, to love god and love your fellow man. But that deals with the implications of agape not eros.
I can best live out the desire for love by loving myself. Cliched I know and rather an obvious cliche at, but its a difficult task for me, as my life seems to be a series of banal failures.
Within Christianity touch is easy to come by, if i bother showing up to mass, then the passing of the peace does wonders. But sex is another matter altogether. From Paul onward, Christianity has enough problems with simple sex between husband and wife, trying to view queer sex as sacred seems an impossibility. Maybe I could use Daoism or Hinduism but respect can turn into idolatry, which can turn into adultery. Christ requires monogamy.
There were nuns who wore wedding rings, and there were nuns who had orgasms thanks to the Lord's hand. I want both. Maybe I do in other ways, but it's easier to make a man a husband when he doesn't have to worry about the dishes or putting the toilet seat down. Having Christ as a husband is ideal, and ideal is not where the world runs.
Never wanting to see Christ again is bitterness and despair, both of which are mortal sins. Tell this to the priest and its worth a fair penance. Maybe thats enough ?
They would have to let me in to cut the knot, and they are not going to do that anytime soon. I become tired of beaurocracy quickly, and the exhaustion may suggest a break and then another go. I do not know in what forms this break would take.
Being a scared and obedient boy does not happen very often, and really it is a good thing in many ways, keeping me humble and keeping me aware of the awesome power of both God and his servants. Sometimes it changes over quickly, and I become the disobedient boy not being nice and making sure to point out that the pope is naked. This is when the punk nihilism comes in, it is refreshing to say "sod off" sometimes, refreshing and nessecary.
I think that marriage is about property and propriety, what is expected by lovers instead of any of the other options. I think that the possibility of gay marriage is heteronormative, a way to usurp the subversive powers of being a sexual others. I do not want our culture to be destroyed in a clambering attempt to be exactly like man and wife.
If human sexual practice is a buffet, then maybe marriage should be an item in it, something you can take or leave depending on preference or taste. Maybe if you are raising children it is more stable. Germaine Greer said this about love though: "Love, love, love -- all the wretched cant of it, masking egotism, lust, masochism, fantasy under a mythology of sentimental postures, a welter of self-induced miseries and joys, blinding and masking the essential personalities in the frozen gestures of courtship, in the kissing and the dating and the desire, the compliments and the quarrels which vivify its barrenness" and i think it applies to marriage. I think of how trapped Betty Friedan felt, and how my grandmother had to go back to school to avoid killing my grandfather. I realized how my mother tried to escape and never did. I remember generations of women who stayed together for the kids, and what special kind of heartbreak that must of been, the emotional equivalent of a backroom abortion.
This might be bitterness on my part though. My friends leave into a hermetic bubble after they get married and I lose them forever: Thomas and Mindy got married and I have not talked to them in months; the same applies to Tara and James, Erin and Garrett, and others. But thats not a marriage thing. My best friend Glenys fell in love with a wonderful girl, and now i talk to her once a month rather then once a week. I do not want to lose the community that i have pushed forward. But they seem happy and content and wonderfully together. It might last a life time, and that must be something to look forward to.
Maybe instead of theory, there is something else. I think one of the reasons I hate marriage is that I view myself too difficult to be a good catch, that no one would love me in a way that could be forever. The Mormons have a hymn that goes"families can stay together forever, according to Heavenly Fathers plan" and I remember talking to a church youth meeting just before I left the church, and I said the line "Some families cannot be together forever, mine for example"
So I don't know, my ideas about marriage is somewhere between being a hurt child of divorce, a profound series of loneliness, a theoretical understanding of heterosexuality, an isolation from the way the rest of the way the universe works and a cynical bitterness.
Tuesday, November 18, 2003
Dear President Bush,
I'm sure you'll be having a nice little tea party with your fellow war criminal, Tony Blair. Please wash the cucumber sandwiches down with a glass of blood, with my compliments.
Harold Pinter
Playwright
Gaurdain
from bookslut
I'm sure you'll be having a nice little tea party with your fellow war criminal, Tony Blair. Please wash the cucumber sandwiches down with a glass of blood, with my compliments.
Harold Pinter
Playwright
Gaurdain
from bookslut
FearsomePirate: it's not like they're giong to invade the US or something. if they want their socialist utopia, they can have it.
FearsomePirate: and when it fails, i will make fun of it.
PinkMoosePearl: i think that the eu is the future and the nation state is dead or dying, and when america perishes i will chuckle with quaint nostalgia
FearsomePirate: Eh, EU is just nation-state 2.0
FearsomePirate: and when it fails, i will make fun of it.
PinkMoosePearl: i think that the eu is the future and the nation state is dead or dying, and when america perishes i will chuckle with quaint nostalgia
FearsomePirate: Eh, EU is just nation-state 2.0
Bush uses obscure 19th Century Law to stymie green peaces efforts at stopping illegal logging.
Come on guys, this kind of research costs cash, and smacks of looking for a reason, in the old days you'd kick up the patriot act, call the terrorists, make some half belives statement about free markets equally free lives and then kick off by 5.
Do you really want the library rats to have their asthma agitated by a new way of doing things ?
Come on guys, this kind of research costs cash, and smacks of looking for a reason, in the old days you'd kick up the patriot act, call the terrorists, make some half belives statement about free markets equally free lives and then kick off by 5.
Do you really want the library rats to have their asthma agitated by a new way of doing things ?
background on haliburton
and haliburton responds via the washington post.
still think its conflict of interest, but then im a cynic like that
and haliburton responds via the washington post.
still think its conflict of interest, but then im a cynic like that
Black resigns rumours of finical irregulites (sp), insider trading and usual biz practices unearthed as unethical have emerged.
the arrogance of this man, the obsession with feudal sources of power, and his head first barrelling into fake advertising, scandal, free copies on trains and general sliminess make me want this asshole to go down hard.
the arrogance of this man, the obsession with feudal sources of power, and his head first barrelling into fake advertising, scandal, free copies on trains and general sliminess make me want this asshole to go down hard.
more basil woverington this time focusing on 50s grotesquries (sp) (the jesus shit was 60s--would be interested in how he came to the lord)
Monday, November 17, 2003
If you could flip a magic switch and turn off every gigabyte of Internet pornography, you would still not stop young men from masturbating every day. I agree with your authors that young adults are having less sex today, and that they have more anxiety about the sex they are having. I only wish you had ditched this porno-addict canard. Pornography is not the culprit behind such loneliness and isolation. There’s no doubt about it: As a group, college-age adults have less—and worse—sex than they did ten or twenty years ago. This generation has been raised on abstinence, body shame, and AIDS-cautionary moralism, in which sex is linked to death, poverty, and dissolution.
Susie Bright
Letter in Response to the Wolf Article on Porn
New York Mag via Daze Reader.
Susie Bright
Letter in Response to the Wolf Article on Porn
New York Mag via Daze Reader.
about the misuse of irony:
thinking about alex ross and mythology/then talking to pat, i expressed this thot.
he isnt being ironic or camp, but he is fully aware of how he feels about his subject, he knows what constructions are behind it but he loves it anyways.
then i thot pomo is accused of having a lack of earnestness, but isnt this honest love/warierness of subject, this tangle of intention and desire as enarnest as anything ?
constant self awareness, and deconstruction is an overdose of earnestness not a lack of it.
(madonna kissing britney, dykspoltation, reenactment of the mother/crone or lesbian vampyres vis a vis christabel ?)
thinking about alex ross and mythology/then talking to pat, i expressed this thot.
he isnt being ironic or camp, but he is fully aware of how he feels about his subject, he knows what constructions are behind it but he loves it anyways.
then i thot pomo is accused of having a lack of earnestness, but isnt this honest love/warierness of subject, this tangle of intention and desire as enarnest as anything ?
constant self awareness, and deconstruction is an overdose of earnestness not a lack of it.
(madonna kissing britney, dykspoltation, reenactment of the mother/crone or lesbian vampyres vis a vis christabel ?)
Shitty weekend, to cap off a shitty month. Missing personal news from me im sure, so here is a brief rundown.
Jeff
Hasn’t called me in weeks, off to Calgary with his main squeeze this weekend, need to go down, said he would talk to me if he did. Mildy pissed, no real reason to be
God
Avoided church for weeks, haven’t really been to mass, haven’t been to morning prayers, done the saints thing as needed, churlish and exhausted at her, really.
Black Dog
Back with a vegence. Makes me a chore to be around, blows things out of porption, makes me want to avoid the real world.
Gateway.
Fired me. My Fault. Fucked up a feature’s photos and a news story, not the best communicator, a bit obtuse, not the style they want or need. Always wanted to be part of the family, thot I was, realized I was mostly being mocked. Stil not sure how I feel, and I think they read this, so my worst vitriol will be saved for later. (censoring content to make sure the plebes get it, I can be a gateway writer after all—ok not all of the vitriol has left)
Comp Lit
26 per cent on the mid term, not going to class as often as I should, got cornered into going to ssds so that they can charge me to get the special services, feels like a scam, but then it always does. Wonder if my conflating aspie with moral failing is a scots presybterian thing.
Christian Sex and Marriage
Kieser loved my essay, got it in under the wire, seemed pleased to see me, always a touch of teachers pet around me, should work on that , its marriage week and I’m not sure how much of it is hating breeders and how much of it is feeling discomfort and how much of it is genuine concern about how the instuiton is run, but having the discussion tomorrow will be unpleasant.
Aspie.
Churchill wants me to be more concetious about my condition, to feel less guilt about it. I went to disability services this week and am trying not to think of it as special privileges, but as level playing fields. As out as I am about almost everything else, I am deeply quiet about my aspergers, the article in the journal made me deeply scared & it is interlaced with self loathing. I fear it is laziness and coasting instead of medicine.
Bryan
Bryan and I are having the same arguments about being a solider and the nature of violence/power we did three months ago. He wants to be a soilder, I think he is capituling to a corrupt power struggle. He was cruel today, when I said that I prayed for him, he replied, don’t ask yr god to do me any favours, but then I have been cruel to him, refusing to acknowledge the thot that goes into his philosophy, thinking that it is little more then comic fueled adolscent wish fulfillment. I want the 9 to 5 job. I want to work at Richmond mini. Having him give up stability for some nihilist pipe dream seems fucked up. But then I read celine at 15, and gave it all up at 20.
Suicide.
The only reason I haven’t done anything drastic this month is exhaustion.
Chris
18 phone calls to venues, 16 nos, 2 maybes, need something today. Thinks that I will fuck it up, today is do or die, don’t want sean to be around for meeting him, scared that the house isn’t good enough, the food wont taste decently, that everything will be awkard, etc. general social anxiety but pretty fucking heavy.
Dear Catosprhe Waitress.
Belle and Sebastion’s latest, k-good. Trevor horn sure knows how to make things catchy. Track 4 and Track 10 v. v. good. Good to hear Lord Anthony out side of a bootleg, bit of a mag fields feel. Need to add them to a top ten im doing for stylus re:stealth Christians.
Testimony.
Should come out this week, may be a bit of pr, Andrew will be back from van on tues. will ask him.
$
peprutally short, overspending, fucked up banks, miscommuncation and a need to budget better.
Jeff
Hasn’t called me in weeks, off to Calgary with his main squeeze this weekend, need to go down, said he would talk to me if he did. Mildy pissed, no real reason to be
God
Avoided church for weeks, haven’t really been to mass, haven’t been to morning prayers, done the saints thing as needed, churlish and exhausted at her, really.
Black Dog
Back with a vegence. Makes me a chore to be around, blows things out of porption, makes me want to avoid the real world.
Gateway.
Fired me. My Fault. Fucked up a feature’s photos and a news story, not the best communicator, a bit obtuse, not the style they want or need. Always wanted to be part of the family, thot I was, realized I was mostly being mocked. Stil not sure how I feel, and I think they read this, so my worst vitriol will be saved for later. (censoring content to make sure the plebes get it, I can be a gateway writer after all—ok not all of the vitriol has left)
Comp Lit
26 per cent on the mid term, not going to class as often as I should, got cornered into going to ssds so that they can charge me to get the special services, feels like a scam, but then it always does. Wonder if my conflating aspie with moral failing is a scots presybterian thing.
Christian Sex and Marriage
Kieser loved my essay, got it in under the wire, seemed pleased to see me, always a touch of teachers pet around me, should work on that , its marriage week and I’m not sure how much of it is hating breeders and how much of it is feeling discomfort and how much of it is genuine concern about how the instuiton is run, but having the discussion tomorrow will be unpleasant.
Aspie.
Churchill wants me to be more concetious about my condition, to feel less guilt about it. I went to disability services this week and am trying not to think of it as special privileges, but as level playing fields. As out as I am about almost everything else, I am deeply quiet about my aspergers, the article in the journal made me deeply scared & it is interlaced with self loathing. I fear it is laziness and coasting instead of medicine.
Bryan
Bryan and I are having the same arguments about being a solider and the nature of violence/power we did three months ago. He wants to be a soilder, I think he is capituling to a corrupt power struggle. He was cruel today, when I said that I prayed for him, he replied, don’t ask yr god to do me any favours, but then I have been cruel to him, refusing to acknowledge the thot that goes into his philosophy, thinking that it is little more then comic fueled adolscent wish fulfillment. I want the 9 to 5 job. I want to work at Richmond mini. Having him give up stability for some nihilist pipe dream seems fucked up. But then I read celine at 15, and gave it all up at 20.
Suicide.
The only reason I haven’t done anything drastic this month is exhaustion.
Chris
18 phone calls to venues, 16 nos, 2 maybes, need something today. Thinks that I will fuck it up, today is do or die, don’t want sean to be around for meeting him, scared that the house isn’t good enough, the food wont taste decently, that everything will be awkard, etc. general social anxiety but pretty fucking heavy.
Dear Catosprhe Waitress.
Belle and Sebastion’s latest, k-good. Trevor horn sure knows how to make things catchy. Track 4 and Track 10 v. v. good. Good to hear Lord Anthony out side of a bootleg, bit of a mag fields feel. Need to add them to a top ten im doing for stylus re:stealth Christians.
Testimony.
Should come out this week, may be a bit of pr, Andrew will be back from van on tues. will ask him.
$
peprutally short, overspending, fucked up banks, miscommuncation and a need to budget better.
Basil Wolverton, British, did pulp sci fi in the 40s, horror and grostequries in the 50s and then a whole illustrated bible, heavy on the apoclyptic in the 60s (ran in plain truth, which i picked up as a kid on vacations in calgary, long after his work was no longer)
this comes from the 40s.
anyone know anything else ?
Sunday, November 16, 2003
'"The intellectual isolation here is enormous," Brecht compained. "Compared to Hollywood, Svendborg was a world center." His ideas, such as "the production, distribution and enjoyment of bread," were not taken seriously by movie moguls. In 1947 Brecht was accused of un-American activities...
id kill to see what brecht (first bread, then ethics) could do with a film about bread
momus
both from the same ilx thread .
id kill to see what brecht (first bread, then ethics) could do with a film about bread
momus
both from the same ilx thread .
Friday, November 14, 2003
I think that the middle east is more complicated then blood for oil (though looking at the connections b/w Rose, Unicol and Haliburton might help), i think it is also about our God versus There God, and what looks good on television and opedial conflict and one nasty motherfucker who likes to kill lots and lots of Kurds.
But UN Under Secretary General for Humanitarian Affairs, Jan Egeland
has a v. good point when she notes for sheer number of bodies and the ability to make an area unstable, Uganda has iraq beat.
But UN Under Secretary General for Humanitarian Affairs, Jan Egeland
has a v. good point when she notes for sheer number of bodies and the ability to make an area unstable, Uganda has iraq beat.
The intelligence process is a bit like virginity," says Ray McGovern, who worked as a CIA analyst for 27 years. "Once you prostitute it, it's never the same. Your credibility never recovers.
"Watching what has happened with Iraq over the past several months has been like watching your daughter being raped."
From this story on how much Bush and the inteliigence community hate each other.
a couple of things: there is rumours about that the yellow cake conterversory was planted by the cia as a way to discredit Bush, who they find problematic and a bit of a hothead.
if you fuck over the cia, yr adminstration is toast. they work independent, and can do real and permanat damage if care is not taken.
silence is being broken in a place where secerts are held dear, this thing is unravelling at the seams.
"Watching what has happened with Iraq over the past several months has been like watching your daughter being raped."
From this story on how much Bush and the inteliigence community hate each other.
a couple of things: there is rumours about that the yellow cake conterversory was planted by the cia as a way to discredit Bush, who they find problematic and a bit of a hothead.
if you fuck over the cia, yr adminstration is toast. they work independent, and can do real and permanat damage if care is not taken.
silence is being broken in a place where secerts are held dear, this thing is unravelling at the seams.
ok lets say that homosex or transsex is a choice or a construction, even if thats the case, the work on that construction, the effort, struggle. violence to create self (any self, this could apply to breeders), needs to be directed inward. to attempt to cure gender or sexual abnorms is to rob people of their embodied soverignty.
Don't Ask, Don't Tell, that thouroghly unworkable force in modern culture has hit Hate the Sin, Not the Sinner in a boys school in florida
the thing is, that even if it is a construction, then people should be allowed to sort&discourse on their own.
the thing is, that even if it is a construction, then people should be allowed to sort&discourse on their own.
Certain Pentacostal churches and the Salvation Army are handing out condoms in africa. While there are a number of cultural practices that make handing out the things not nearly enough, they are good to have arround.
Avant Garde Art usually is destroyed by recessions, in hard times it is a select group of modern blue chips, impressionists and old masters.
Is it a sign of economic recovery that obscure contempary artists have done exceptionally well, and that people like John Currian and Murakami have gotten boom reps ?
Is it a sign of economic recovery that obscure contempary artists have done exceptionally well, and that people like John Currian and Murakami have gotten boom reps ?
Thursday, November 13, 2003
interactive map of fund raising with the democratic candidates and George W Bush, by state, electoral maps, and telephone code.
mefi
mefi
Adam Morrell, 14, was left with more than 280 injuries by the gang who tortured him in November 2002.
interesting thing is the gender make up, with at least one girl involved.
Gaurdian
interesting thing is the gender make up, with at least one girl involved.
Gaurdian
The Morning News walks the entire length of Manhattan . Again kind of Sentimental, but then im in that kind of mood
gawker
gawker
This is most likely a hipper, cooler version of inspirational messages, but i love Taylor Mali's poetry, and how much sheer effort he puts into teaching.
Wednesday, November 12, 2003
Kimberly Peirce's 1999 film Boy's Don't Cry is a touchstone takes new concepts of gender and sex out of the academy and places it into a mythological context, the filmed depiction of transgendered Brandon Teena is the creation of a new secular saint, and to fully understand the radical implications of this, it might help to compare him to others who transgress gender, especially in a context that is easily both cinematic and theological. Is Brandon Teena a new kind of warrior, and if he is, then where would his genealogy come from? Symbolically, the most obvious precedent is Joan of Arc, and if we treat the films that they were both treated as texts seperate from their biographical legends then the connections between these two boy warriors tells us much about how gender is treated, even in a theological context.
To begin is to define terms, especially important in a field which is so new, seminal texts are still being written and ur-texts are about ten years old1) What is meant by Transgender is simply those who transgress gender. There is an assumption in this culture that gender is sex, and that only two sexes occur, namely man and women. Those who are not readily identifable as either man or women, those who feel isolated by those categories, those who wish to move into the other side of that binary or those who reject either outright could be considered as transgendered. There are cultures2) who allow more then one category, and it could be argued that those who follow a proper exception would not be consdiered trasngendered.
Transexuals are a difficult case in this kind of theorotical reading, as they capitulate to the binary, trying to fix their transgressions clinically or socially. This is accepted as a standard and approite response to ambigous gender, and often sex. There are two problems with this. The first is a process of clinicazation, Transgendered and pedophiles are the are the only sexual other left where a surgerical correction is not only considered an option, but one of the more effective ones. The second problem with passing is a contiuntion of traditional gender norms, and by that method the prison of gender normality is maintained for generations of gender outlaws.
There are problems with this line of thinking, among them certain biological conjectures and a deconstruction of male power that problematizes assuming masculine power. The concept of the modern transsexual was brought into full awareness by an endcironlogist by the name of Henry Benjamin, who still has a makor foundation named after him, this approval has meant that research done around gender transgressors has centered on hormones and their role in sex devolepment. For example in Mary Duvalls mammoth study on Female To Male Transexuals1), she discusses for five pages (60-65) the nature of hormones on transexuals, making claims like "A possible basis for transexualism has been thought in studies of of the histo- compabilty-Y(H-Y) antigen status of transexuals. The HY antigen can be found in the bodies of males but not females..."2) or there has been evidence, however, to suggest that female-to-male transexuals have a higher inicidene of menestural difficulties and polycystic ovarian disease, both of which suggest hormanal abnormaolities" 3)
Like studies on the biological nature of homosexuality, inconclusive evidence, small sample sizes and a medical agenda forces a prescriptive attitude towards these phemonae, that may be away from their experinces. The other arguement is put forward by femminsts like Germiane Greer and Janice Raymond. In The Whole Woman, Greer talks about male to female transexuals, arguing that the nature of being female is one of a birth culture, it cannot truly be learnt, because it is imposed on you. She considers men who become transexuals impossible and ludcrious imposters of real women, their manners and desires patonrizing.1) In The Transexual Empire2), Janice Raymond argues that assuming male personae, and later personhood, is to abondanon women and to cross into male privelge. It is an affront against sisterhood or a common liberation struggles among women. For both Greer and Robinson, even if gender was constructed, then it was constructed against women and not by them.
Viewing this in a theological lens is to enter through a rabbit hole. The basic theory has barely been done, most churches have not produced any statements, and if they did they tend towards the prohibitive, using the essential complimetary theology extroploted from Genisis, a good example of which is found in the Latter Day Saint Proclamation of the Family, whose only line on the transgender does not seem to understand the word and states "Gender is an essential characteristic of individual premortal, mortal, and eternal identity and purpose" or the Jewish law found in Deut. 22:53), something that prohibits ritual tranvestism but not other forces of Gender amibguity. The discussion of liberation of transgendered indviudals runs towards the same historio-critical view of the scripture that liberated many homosexuals, namely thought thst does not rise above "we are not ancient isrealites."
To allow the idea that we are blank from birth is a radical notion that may upend notions of the body in judeo-christian theology. Even such a radical notion as embodiment theology, which celebrates God's creation as good and holy would feel awkard at a body that was born with out a core idenity. If we moved that type of theological thinking forward and thought that exploring the logical extensions of what it means to be human in God's world might be useful. Think of the body not worth correcting, but embracing how it is corrected.
If we take this view with Brandon Teena we have a different set of consquences concerning what occured. The story is fairly simple, a male to female transexual with little money and fewer prospects moved from home to Lincon Falls Nebraska, where he fell in with a crowd of similar misfits, including Lana Tisdel, who he fell in love with and John Lotter and Tom Nissen who raped and killed him. This story was turned into a conventional love story by grad student and first time director Kimberly Peirce. In the press surrounding Brandon himsel,. he is constantly refered to in press as transgressive, with terms like female bodied1) ,a sexual misfit2) , male impresontor3) and that she had actually been a woman.4) Even in his eulogy, Fthr Wittig, the priest residing claimed that she was "a very confused young lady"5).
But Brandon had taken a mans name and forged a new idenity6), he had wooed women the way heterosexual men were supposed to, and drank with the boys. He never slipped, and photos of him show a person who had adopted masculine signals , the hand over the crotch, the wide open legs, the standing askance, the cowboy shirts and posing with a mobsters tommy gun for halloween. There is even a photo of him, smiling shirtless, post shower. Kimberly Peirce qoutes a conversation second hand, through Lana, where Brandon Teena says "i am not a lesbian, i'm not going to New York or LA. I am going to be a straight man here in Lincon. "1) He was not allowed to approach an embodied theology, because his body was such a dangerous object that it needed to be corrected by rape and murder, the irony of this was the rape occured at Christmas, an act of evil on a day whose intentions were to note the birth of a man who was also a god.
There are two films, one a basic documentary produced in 1994, produced with movie-of-the-week whiplash speed. The other one was a poetic medatation on the nature of desire, metioned earlier as Boys Don't Cry. This film was a political document intended to make Brandon Teena a marytr, just before the film went into preproduction a radical group of transsexuals, founded on the Debard inspired specatcles of groups like Act-Up and Queer Nation marched on Lincon. 40 of them from the United States and Canada went through town sqaure, yelling with rage at the violence that Teena endured. Pierce was part of that group. 2)
There are scenes that act as geographical sigifer, noting the beauty in plain Nebraska, the joys of gas stations, factories, high ways, tract homes, trailer parks, dive bars playing MTV and karoke machines gathering dust in the corner. The sheer pyshicality of Hilary Swanks preformance shows a joy in creation, she lopes through these banalities with a coltish grace and when she falls in love with Lana, the novelty is heartbreaking.
Because there was no suspense in the movie, the story well disessmatied by popular media, the film ascended like a religous melodrama. There is a segment where Brandon's vagina is found out, she talks to the sheriff, as the forced undressing is shown in broad cuts, the way that he is broken resembles a medieval descent from the cross, and the authorities invading this process has obvious Chrisitan metaphors.
In a scene soon after they take her to the factory where he met Lana, they remove her clothes, and take turns . She is presenting and claiming a phallus, they are claiming a penis. They force penetration on her, trying to teach her the meaning of being a woman, putting her in place, reminding her that she posseses's a subservient vagina. The signifer meets signified, and on a dark road where no one can see, theory is shattered into reality. Afterwords though, presentation returns. They take her into the car, get her dressed, call her good buddy, and drive to an apartment where they offer her a beer and a bath. She is once again he, one of the boys. There is a conflation of the outsider, the boy who steals the girl, the boy who has ideas above his station, homophobia, transphobia and all nature of ambigous idenity is presented here. Brandon Teena is as much of a victim of attempting to posesses the wrong kind of woman, as he is a marytry for queer causes. This was Christ, who died for hersey, politics, conveience, and for theological reasons.
Her murder then becomes an anti climax, where her gender does not seem to matter. In making the film a heteronormative narrative, the end shoot out resembles any number of american endings. It is Bonnie and Clyde in the Caddaliac, or John Dillinger at the movies. Brandon stole Tom's girl. Brandon is restored as a boy.
If Brandon Teena is about how to make a boy, then the filmed depictions of Joan of Arc are about how to lose a boy. Joan of Arc was not transgendered until she died. Born and raised as a conventional women, who learnt sewing, weaving and other handicrafts1), when she recived the first visions at a young age they came from two women(Catherine and Margriete) and one man (Michael), by the presence of these two women, she placed herself in a tradition of female mysticism that marked mediveal christianity, when she decided that she was called by God to defend France from England she got tacit premission from the Dauphin and later Charles VI, anyone who gets premission from the king who gave Joan her first set of armour. Transgender requires Transgression, there was none here. Even her death sentence, for witch craft and heresy, was done in a way befitting a woman.
Their are hundreds of films of Joan of Arc, and she was one of the first stories to be filmed with the 1895 Alfred Clarke production being the orignator. and the history of Joan of Arc could be considered a history of how women could be depicted in film, especially erotically. They range from the deeply religous to the deeply secular but if four could be considered represntive, they could be Carl Dreyer's 1926 Passion of Joan of Arc, Victor Flemings 1948 production with Ingrid Bergman, Otto Premingers discovery of Jean Seberg in St Joan and Luc Bresson's action disaster The Messanger. Each one says something about how females are constructed in film, and none of them features the 14 year old in armour, her hair cut in a savere pageboy.
Carl Dreyer uses trial transcripts, but aside from that it is not documentary as much as a radical and expressionist1) treatise on manic faith. The mayrtrydom has cleared parrells to the crucifixon, with the jailing, mocking gaurds, crown of thorns, Joan collpasing under the weight of torture, and calling it a passion itself. The mortifaction of the flesh, and pain itself is viewed as a way to elimanate self and come c loser to God. Compare this to Pierces film, who makes a marytr without any sense of the Divine. Humanity as left Joan, God has left Lincon, Nebraska. The most ambigous scene in Dreyers film is the scene where she is cut for bloodletting, which could be considered a restoriaon of Joan's vagina if she did not look so much like a mater delorsea already. It could also be a draining of the masculine essence and a qoute of the wounds of Christ as reflected in the stigmata. It is thought that the blood depicted on Joan of Arc was really Maria Falconetti's. That small, tight scene talks so much about the destructive tendecies in the nature of saint's, to the atheist Dryer, martyrdom is sucide with a divine agenda.
If Dreyer's is a knotty and confusing european art peice, then Victor Flemming directing Ingrid Bergman is the exact opposite. She is a sex symbol in the midst of an alduterus sex scandal, the armour in the battle scenes is cut to accuentate her breasts and hips, the burning is done in a white dress. This is not a Joan we recognize, she is not boyish, she is not a girl. But this is a director who tried to turn Judy Garland into a naive farm girl1) and supervised the greatest renovation of racial myths in american history2). He did not care about accuracy as much as spectacle.
The source texts of these movies where bascially the same, mostly medival legend, with some transcripts thrown in but Otto Preminger remade Shaw's St Joan, although he substutited Shaw's inventioned death. The films starred Jean Seberg, who was discovered in her home town in Iowa after a national cattle call. Much like Falconetti was made to bleed and Swank walked arround Beverly Hills pretending to be a boy, Seberg suffered serious burns after a malfunction on the set. It was not the most damage that she did though, the film was a disaster and it was mostly blamed on a combonation of Serbeg's sexualized gamine qaulities and a script that lacerated Catholicisms history of complacency. She soon moved to France, founded the new wave by starring in Breathless and became heavily involved in Maoist politics. She was found dead in a vineyard away from Paris facing Orleans. Her struggles internally and externally matched Joan's on fervour and in devotion, her tendecy away from the church seemed generational.
Luc Bresson's The Messengar is the last of the Arc movies, made in the same year as Boys Don't Cry, and continues a '90s trend of crazy women and female action stars. Here Joan is stripped of the holy, made hysteric and deluded, her rituals considered obsessive-compulsive. In Dreyer's film the mortifaction is holy, the mayrtrydom is considered Christ like, in Flemming's the spectacle overwhelms any sense of Divine, in Preminger it is a political and social text and in Flemming it's an action movie led by a star. There are no real hero's in Bresson films, they finish their work with a calcuated effiency. It is the exact opposite of a film like Boy's Don't Cry, even the moody atmospheric touches are meant to excuse womens violecene That both of these films appeared at the same time, perhaps shows a new understanding of the concept of sex, allowing for men to be raped and oppressed as much as women can be grand martial leaders. This may not be progressed, but it does tie the nature of power and idenity, the sheer core of naming into violence. When one yeilds a sword, no matter how crazy, one can name price, privelege, station or idenity, especially if called by God.
What does it mean then, to be Brandon or Joan ? Joan did not transgress gender, even in her filmic dections, the women who played her and how they played her fit into the general milleu of the time. She is eroticized without being exoticised, and much of the work that surrounds her deals with issues aside from religion. Ironically, it is difficult to find a Joan movie that is about Joan, that is historcally accurate, that depicts her as real and does not have any political baggage. She has become a very really sexual type, a holy amazon. Brandon Teena is in the beginnings of mythology. His name has been codifed, his life has been made clear. In Boys Dont Cry, his petty vandalism, his car theft, his peccadillos and his confusions become secondary to his rape and murder which become the beginnings of a new kind of liberation, where nothing needs correcting and biology can be transcended. More importantly, Lana's continued life is not depicted, how she feels about Brandon's gender, and how she feels about the families interference. Brandon is made into a heterosexual cowboy who falls in love like a sensitive new age man.
Gender constructed becomes Gender Confused. To embody it is to recognize with in ourselves is a bit of the formless void that YHWH was supposed to have eliminated in the very first chapters of Gensis. I am not a man. I am not a woman. I see myself like Brandon, even though I have broad shoulders, a wide carriage, a penis and a beard, because I remember being on the razor edge of reading signals. I grew up with factories and chemical plants, teenage boys up to no good on a friday night. I remember coming home and seeing them from the corner of my eye and thinking how much I would like to be them. In high school my desire to make love to men was a desire to aborb their manner and way of being. Brandon did not know how to be a man, even though at this core he was one. I do not know how to be a man, and at my core I am not sure I am one. If Brandon is my secualr saint, remembered in the same mental spaces as the bashings and death threats i got in Sherwood Park, then Joan is my religous one.
The catholic church accepts weirdness at its corners, perhaps it comes from vacuuming pagan rituals where ever they encountered them, but Joan embodies many of those for me. She was loved by the church, she was given refuge and succour. They trusted her to provide statehood and she delivered. She was as much a man as a woman could be there, she was loved and respected for those reasons. But when she failed, when she was killed as a woman. 19 years later she was restored and hundreds of years after that she was cannonized. 1926, the same year as the Dreyer film. How many saints have we burned or silenced, and when will the church regret it ? These two people are about voice and the wilderness, not the wilderness of Moses and Aaron, but the interior wilderness of self.
To begin is to define terms, especially important in a field which is so new, seminal texts are still being written and ur-texts are about ten years old1) What is meant by Transgender is simply those who transgress gender. There is an assumption in this culture that gender is sex, and that only two sexes occur, namely man and women. Those who are not readily identifable as either man or women, those who feel isolated by those categories, those who wish to move into the other side of that binary or those who reject either outright could be considered as transgendered. There are cultures2) who allow more then one category, and it could be argued that those who follow a proper exception would not be consdiered trasngendered.
Transexuals are a difficult case in this kind of theorotical reading, as they capitulate to the binary, trying to fix their transgressions clinically or socially. This is accepted as a standard and approite response to ambigous gender, and often sex. There are two problems with this. The first is a process of clinicazation, Transgendered and pedophiles are the are the only sexual other left where a surgerical correction is not only considered an option, but one of the more effective ones. The second problem with passing is a contiuntion of traditional gender norms, and by that method the prison of gender normality is maintained for generations of gender outlaws.
There are problems with this line of thinking, among them certain biological conjectures and a deconstruction of male power that problematizes assuming masculine power. The concept of the modern transsexual was brought into full awareness by an endcironlogist by the name of Henry Benjamin, who still has a makor foundation named after him, this approval has meant that research done around gender transgressors has centered on hormones and their role in sex devolepment. For example in Mary Duvalls mammoth study on Female To Male Transexuals1), she discusses for five pages (60-65) the nature of hormones on transexuals, making claims like "A possible basis for transexualism has been thought in studies of of the histo- compabilty-Y(H-Y) antigen status of transexuals. The HY antigen can be found in the bodies of males but not females..."2) or there has been evidence, however, to suggest that female-to-male transexuals have a higher inicidene of menestural difficulties and polycystic ovarian disease, both of which suggest hormanal abnormaolities" 3)
Like studies on the biological nature of homosexuality, inconclusive evidence, small sample sizes and a medical agenda forces a prescriptive attitude towards these phemonae, that may be away from their experinces. The other arguement is put forward by femminsts like Germiane Greer and Janice Raymond. In The Whole Woman, Greer talks about male to female transexuals, arguing that the nature of being female is one of a birth culture, it cannot truly be learnt, because it is imposed on you. She considers men who become transexuals impossible and ludcrious imposters of real women, their manners and desires patonrizing.1) In The Transexual Empire2), Janice Raymond argues that assuming male personae, and later personhood, is to abondanon women and to cross into male privelge. It is an affront against sisterhood or a common liberation struggles among women. For both Greer and Robinson, even if gender was constructed, then it was constructed against women and not by them.
Viewing this in a theological lens is to enter through a rabbit hole. The basic theory has barely been done, most churches have not produced any statements, and if they did they tend towards the prohibitive, using the essential complimetary theology extroploted from Genisis, a good example of which is found in the Latter Day Saint Proclamation of the Family, whose only line on the transgender does not seem to understand the word and states "Gender is an essential characteristic of individual premortal, mortal, and eternal identity and purpose" or the Jewish law found in Deut. 22:53), something that prohibits ritual tranvestism but not other forces of Gender amibguity. The discussion of liberation of transgendered indviudals runs towards the same historio-critical view of the scripture that liberated many homosexuals, namely thought thst does not rise above "we are not ancient isrealites."
To allow the idea that we are blank from birth is a radical notion that may upend notions of the body in judeo-christian theology. Even such a radical notion as embodiment theology, which celebrates God's creation as good and holy would feel awkard at a body that was born with out a core idenity. If we moved that type of theological thinking forward and thought that exploring the logical extensions of what it means to be human in God's world might be useful. Think of the body not worth correcting, but embracing how it is corrected.
If we take this view with Brandon Teena we have a different set of consquences concerning what occured. The story is fairly simple, a male to female transexual with little money and fewer prospects moved from home to Lincon Falls Nebraska, where he fell in with a crowd of similar misfits, including Lana Tisdel, who he fell in love with and John Lotter and Tom Nissen who raped and killed him. This story was turned into a conventional love story by grad student and first time director Kimberly Peirce. In the press surrounding Brandon himsel,. he is constantly refered to in press as transgressive, with terms like female bodied1) ,a sexual misfit2) , male impresontor3) and that she had actually been a woman.4) Even in his eulogy, Fthr Wittig, the priest residing claimed that she was "a very confused young lady"5).
But Brandon had taken a mans name and forged a new idenity6), he had wooed women the way heterosexual men were supposed to, and drank with the boys. He never slipped, and photos of him show a person who had adopted masculine signals , the hand over the crotch, the wide open legs, the standing askance, the cowboy shirts and posing with a mobsters tommy gun for halloween. There is even a photo of him, smiling shirtless, post shower. Kimberly Peirce qoutes a conversation second hand, through Lana, where Brandon Teena says "i am not a lesbian, i'm not going to New York or LA. I am going to be a straight man here in Lincon. "1) He was not allowed to approach an embodied theology, because his body was such a dangerous object that it needed to be corrected by rape and murder, the irony of this was the rape occured at Christmas, an act of evil on a day whose intentions were to note the birth of a man who was also a god.
There are two films, one a basic documentary produced in 1994, produced with movie-of-the-week whiplash speed. The other one was a poetic medatation on the nature of desire, metioned earlier as Boys Don't Cry. This film was a political document intended to make Brandon Teena a marytr, just before the film went into preproduction a radical group of transsexuals, founded on the Debard inspired specatcles of groups like Act-Up and Queer Nation marched on Lincon. 40 of them from the United States and Canada went through town sqaure, yelling with rage at the violence that Teena endured. Pierce was part of that group. 2)
There are scenes that act as geographical sigifer, noting the beauty in plain Nebraska, the joys of gas stations, factories, high ways, tract homes, trailer parks, dive bars playing MTV and karoke machines gathering dust in the corner. The sheer pyshicality of Hilary Swanks preformance shows a joy in creation, she lopes through these banalities with a coltish grace and when she falls in love with Lana, the novelty is heartbreaking.
Because there was no suspense in the movie, the story well disessmatied by popular media, the film ascended like a religous melodrama. There is a segment where Brandon's vagina is found out, she talks to the sheriff, as the forced undressing is shown in broad cuts, the way that he is broken resembles a medieval descent from the cross, and the authorities invading this process has obvious Chrisitan metaphors.
In a scene soon after they take her to the factory where he met Lana, they remove her clothes, and take turns . She is presenting and claiming a phallus, they are claiming a penis. They force penetration on her, trying to teach her the meaning of being a woman, putting her in place, reminding her that she posseses's a subservient vagina. The signifer meets signified, and on a dark road where no one can see, theory is shattered into reality. Afterwords though, presentation returns. They take her into the car, get her dressed, call her good buddy, and drive to an apartment where they offer her a beer and a bath. She is once again he, one of the boys. There is a conflation of the outsider, the boy who steals the girl, the boy who has ideas above his station, homophobia, transphobia and all nature of ambigous idenity is presented here. Brandon Teena is as much of a victim of attempting to posesses the wrong kind of woman, as he is a marytry for queer causes. This was Christ, who died for hersey, politics, conveience, and for theological reasons.
Her murder then becomes an anti climax, where her gender does not seem to matter. In making the film a heteronormative narrative, the end shoot out resembles any number of american endings. It is Bonnie and Clyde in the Caddaliac, or John Dillinger at the movies. Brandon stole Tom's girl. Brandon is restored as a boy.
If Brandon Teena is about how to make a boy, then the filmed depictions of Joan of Arc are about how to lose a boy. Joan of Arc was not transgendered until she died. Born and raised as a conventional women, who learnt sewing, weaving and other handicrafts1), when she recived the first visions at a young age they came from two women(Catherine and Margriete) and one man (Michael), by the presence of these two women, she placed herself in a tradition of female mysticism that marked mediveal christianity, when she decided that she was called by God to defend France from England she got tacit premission from the Dauphin and later Charles VI, anyone who gets premission from the king who gave Joan her first set of armour. Transgender requires Transgression, there was none here. Even her death sentence, for witch craft and heresy, was done in a way befitting a woman.
Their are hundreds of films of Joan of Arc, and she was one of the first stories to be filmed with the 1895 Alfred Clarke production being the orignator. and the history of Joan of Arc could be considered a history of how women could be depicted in film, especially erotically. They range from the deeply religous to the deeply secular but if four could be considered represntive, they could be Carl Dreyer's 1926 Passion of Joan of Arc, Victor Flemings 1948 production with Ingrid Bergman, Otto Premingers discovery of Jean Seberg in St Joan and Luc Bresson's action disaster The Messanger. Each one says something about how females are constructed in film, and none of them features the 14 year old in armour, her hair cut in a savere pageboy.
Carl Dreyer uses trial transcripts, but aside from that it is not documentary as much as a radical and expressionist1) treatise on manic faith. The mayrtrydom has cleared parrells to the crucifixon, with the jailing, mocking gaurds, crown of thorns, Joan collpasing under the weight of torture, and calling it a passion itself. The mortifaction of the flesh, and pain itself is viewed as a way to elimanate self and come c loser to God. Compare this to Pierces film, who makes a marytr without any sense of the Divine. Humanity as left Joan, God has left Lincon, Nebraska. The most ambigous scene in Dreyers film is the scene where she is cut for bloodletting, which could be considered a restoriaon of Joan's vagina if she did not look so much like a mater delorsea already. It could also be a draining of the masculine essence and a qoute of the wounds of Christ as reflected in the stigmata. It is thought that the blood depicted on Joan of Arc was really Maria Falconetti's. That small, tight scene talks so much about the destructive tendecies in the nature of saint's, to the atheist Dryer, martyrdom is sucide with a divine agenda.
If Dreyer's is a knotty and confusing european art peice, then Victor Flemming directing Ingrid Bergman is the exact opposite. She is a sex symbol in the midst of an alduterus sex scandal, the armour in the battle scenes is cut to accuentate her breasts and hips, the burning is done in a white dress. This is not a Joan we recognize, she is not boyish, she is not a girl. But this is a director who tried to turn Judy Garland into a naive farm girl1) and supervised the greatest renovation of racial myths in american history2). He did not care about accuracy as much as spectacle.
The source texts of these movies where bascially the same, mostly medival legend, with some transcripts thrown in but Otto Preminger remade Shaw's St Joan, although he substutited Shaw's inventioned death. The films starred Jean Seberg, who was discovered in her home town in Iowa after a national cattle call. Much like Falconetti was made to bleed and Swank walked arround Beverly Hills pretending to be a boy, Seberg suffered serious burns after a malfunction on the set. It was not the most damage that she did though, the film was a disaster and it was mostly blamed on a combonation of Serbeg's sexualized gamine qaulities and a script that lacerated Catholicisms history of complacency. She soon moved to France, founded the new wave by starring in Breathless and became heavily involved in Maoist politics. She was found dead in a vineyard away from Paris facing Orleans. Her struggles internally and externally matched Joan's on fervour and in devotion, her tendecy away from the church seemed generational.
Luc Bresson's The Messengar is the last of the Arc movies, made in the same year as Boys Don't Cry, and continues a '90s trend of crazy women and female action stars. Here Joan is stripped of the holy, made hysteric and deluded, her rituals considered obsessive-compulsive. In Dreyer's film the mortifaction is holy, the mayrtrydom is considered Christ like, in Flemming's the spectacle overwhelms any sense of Divine, in Preminger it is a political and social text and in Flemming it's an action movie led by a star. There are no real hero's in Bresson films, they finish their work with a calcuated effiency. It is the exact opposite of a film like Boy's Don't Cry, even the moody atmospheric touches are meant to excuse womens violecene That both of these films appeared at the same time, perhaps shows a new understanding of the concept of sex, allowing for men to be raped and oppressed as much as women can be grand martial leaders. This may not be progressed, but it does tie the nature of power and idenity, the sheer core of naming into violence. When one yeilds a sword, no matter how crazy, one can name price, privelege, station or idenity, especially if called by God.
What does it mean then, to be Brandon or Joan ? Joan did not transgress gender, even in her filmic dections, the women who played her and how they played her fit into the general milleu of the time. She is eroticized without being exoticised, and much of the work that surrounds her deals with issues aside from religion. Ironically, it is difficult to find a Joan movie that is about Joan, that is historcally accurate, that depicts her as real and does not have any political baggage. She has become a very really sexual type, a holy amazon. Brandon Teena is in the beginnings of mythology. His name has been codifed, his life has been made clear. In Boys Dont Cry, his petty vandalism, his car theft, his peccadillos and his confusions become secondary to his rape and murder which become the beginnings of a new kind of liberation, where nothing needs correcting and biology can be transcended. More importantly, Lana's continued life is not depicted, how she feels about Brandon's gender, and how she feels about the families interference. Brandon is made into a heterosexual cowboy who falls in love like a sensitive new age man.
Gender constructed becomes Gender Confused. To embody it is to recognize with in ourselves is a bit of the formless void that YHWH was supposed to have eliminated in the very first chapters of Gensis. I am not a man. I am not a woman. I see myself like Brandon, even though I have broad shoulders, a wide carriage, a penis and a beard, because I remember being on the razor edge of reading signals. I grew up with factories and chemical plants, teenage boys up to no good on a friday night. I remember coming home and seeing them from the corner of my eye and thinking how much I would like to be them. In high school my desire to make love to men was a desire to aborb their manner and way of being. Brandon did not know how to be a man, even though at this core he was one. I do not know how to be a man, and at my core I am not sure I am one. If Brandon is my secualr saint, remembered in the same mental spaces as the bashings and death threats i got in Sherwood Park, then Joan is my religous one.
The catholic church accepts weirdness at its corners, perhaps it comes from vacuuming pagan rituals where ever they encountered them, but Joan embodies many of those for me. She was loved by the church, she was given refuge and succour. They trusted her to provide statehood and she delivered. She was as much a man as a woman could be there, she was loved and respected for those reasons. But when she failed, when she was killed as a woman. 19 years later she was restored and hundreds of years after that she was cannonized. 1926, the same year as the Dreyer film. How many saints have we burned or silenced, and when will the church regret it ? These two people are about voice and the wilderness, not the wilderness of Moses and Aaron, but the interior wilderness of self.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
03
(1253)
-
►
11
(111)
- Kimberly Peirce's 1999 film Boy's Don't Cry is a t...
- This is most likely a hipper, cooler version of in...
- The Morning News walks the entire length of Manha...
- Adam Morrell, 14, was left with more than 280 inju...
- interactive map of fund raising with the democrat...
- Avant Garde Art usually is destroyed by recessions...
- Certain Pentacostal churches and the Salvation Arm...
- daze reader
- Don't Ask, Don't Tell, that thouroghly unworkable ...
- ok lets say that homosex or transsex is a choice o...
- various vintage signs photo'd from 14-42nd St. Mefi
- bunnies
- The intelligence process is a bit like virginity,"...
- I think that the middle east is more complicated t...
- speaking of kurds, the americans are clashing with...
- It is because they are the product of so many dete...
- '"The intellectual isolation here is enormous," Br...
- Basil Wolverton, British, did pulp sci fi in the...
- Shitty weekend, to cap off a shitty month. Missing...
- about the misuse of irony: thinking about alex ro...
- got chris gig, world good.
- If you could flip a magic switch and turn off ever...
- France fights anti semitism after a jewish school ...
- more basil woverington this time focusing on 50s g...
- and some good old fashioned apocolypse
- Black resigns rumours of finical irregulites (sp),...
- background on haliburton and haliburton respond...
- extensive photo series of british song birds mefi
- Bush uses obscure 19th Century Law to stymie green...
- a further continutition(sp) of the american confl...
- ludicrosity splits abortions binary into 9 peices...
- FearsomePirate: it's not like they're giong to inv...
- Dear President Bush, I'm sure you'll be having a...
- When I was in relationships, i had them with older...
- A notice from local people who read this blog. Tr...
- He used to meditate between the orientalism of the...
- Thursday i told my therapist i wanted to kill myse...
- Bryan's Orgination theory holds that traditonal st...
- 700 russians who are trying out for the Duma are h...
- Why we need domestic partner rights.
- . . . there is now a professional, well-trained ...
- Culture Jammer, Art Warrior and Camp Follower Ban...
- big book on Alex Ross and the New Book, via vv.
- queer zines, an underground for radical socio-sexu...
- The methods that that almost worked in Paris '68 a...
- Paul Celan, a poet i have always meant to research...
- Two Pollock Drawings, Two Years Apart
- No title
- automatic/amorphus bimorphic abstraction non objec...
- Ultrabeat - Pretty Green Eyes So Solid Crew - Brok...
- POP FOCUS TIME !! Ultrabeat - Pretty Green Eye 3 ...
- No title
- Josh put up a rather legalistic list of what makes...
- No title
- its Frances Kissling, sorry
- No title
- good article on the problems with state marriage ...
- Look, I know most people who read this do not real...
- Encylopedic site of illustration from 3 centuries...
- Joesph Cornell never left his house on long island...
- anti porn hypocrite loves porn.
- Gen. Tommy Frank looks forward to the end of the c...
- the last two thnx to body and soul
- western dependence on petro chemicals cause thous...
- Yukos hands 30k pages of info to the Russian Gvt,...
- The British Foreign Office in Istanbul is expectin...
- Co-ed Dorms are considered, which i think is a go...
- UK lets post op transsexuals to adopt and marry in...
- Criticism of the theory that superpowers at war c...
- Flash Version of Oblique Strategies always too sel...
- cascade from oblique cold outside down quick dr...
- chris and ryan are here and in the last 48 hours ...
- the thing is, the amazing wonderful thing is, how ...
- CBC tells a dozen stories about iraq that are unde...
- Images of Ship Breaking in Bangladesh
- The New BMW is so wonderfully beautiful, that it i...
- Andy Scott, New Brunswick MP, is fag bashed by a v...
- Some of Paul Martin's ships leak toxic sludge, an...
- online catalog of childrens book illustrations via...
- insanely large collection of English Lit created ...
- We want to stop men from treating us like sex obje...
- Bitter and hard edged, the work of Tom Sach makes ...
- Church leaders test themselves for hiv/aids as a w...
- this asshole should lighten the fuck up, if you do...
-
▼
12
(73)
- ITs international AIDS day, in the words of moth...
- A good article on the use of anti semetic dialecti...
- Ayn Rand Dating Service The world is absurd. mefi
- The US Central Intelligence Agency has acknowledg...
- 1.7 million children in Uganda are AIDS Orphans mefi
- Henry Kissenger, the dark knight of the American E...
- Small group of fundies tries to make history teach...
- Michael Tarintino was one of those rare currators ...
- Youve seen this everywhere, but there is somethin...
- good blog entry on where exactly pound fits among ...
- The Maciejowski Bible a lush, gothic illustrative ...
- Sucide Bombing is a meme that has spread hard and ...
- Petronius wrote his Satyricon in 66 AD, just as th...
- Grayson Perry won the Turner. I dont know what i ...
- Stark, sleek and modern the building at 10 Columbi...
- streaming video of badgers BADGERS via fark
- Encylopedia of Bawdy Song. all yr favourites publo...
- when the inbred daughters of anglo upper classes ...
- Hindus and Muslim's kill each other, BBC reports
- its a t shirt via ship of fools
- Sexuality is ethically correct when it is done by ...
- an acessiable, well written, clever and difficult ...
- warhol suicide 1962
- William Trost Richards i did a google search, but...
- Which Historical Lunatic Are You?From the fecund l...
- saint johns dream last night, first time in years....
- look you didnt like the badger cam, and i was sad-...
- will martin make us yearn for the days when creite...
- a good summary of my aesthic feelings and practic...
- Homeland Sec. Head Tom Ridge wants to make illegal...
- Top 5 Poetry Books of the year are all collection...
- i am glad that they captured sadaam, i look forwar...
- I want to be more like Judith Butler than like Mic...
- danielle came home and we collapse into old wonder...
- bryan and i are fighting, and this time it looks m...
- First Nations baskets, with their subtle and perma...
- One of the first criticisms of gehry inside archit...
- As much as I have problems with the Church, there ...
- France, in its attempts to march towards secuarism...
- America puts a bounty on Taylors head, UK mercanie...
- Jesus hates it when you smoke
- Rumsfiled will be trying Sadaam, and he claims not...
- maybe i was unfair to hill, is it not our job as c...
- i have been having gaps in my memory, sessions of ...
- robbed last nite, glad i dont work tomorrow. got ...
- The gold Room, an atlanta strip club is now being...
- Diebold has admitted that their machines went unte...
- speaking of accountability, Arnie declares state o...
- Maoist record reviews, they hate pop so you dont ...
- queer reading of LOTR, still overrought and over r...
- Americans phyiscally and emotionally abuse prison...
- Jury's choosing death sentences are becoming less ...
- gorgeous paloethic art is found in southern german...
- last night i had a three minute blank out, and tod...
- huge gallery of african photography, done by afric...
- Ballard offered CBE Ballard tells queen to fuck off.
- Breaking down the red/blue state lines, these ten ...
- queer and pacifist events cut from montages of eve...
- One of the strageties for winning the cold war was...
- and almost 24 chicago area priests have called the...
- before i forget, had a 3 minute black out at rache...
- the damage that jack white can do is not only to...
- winter pastorals, alberta magpie loosens snow o...
- Franz Gehry is ego unchecked, refusing to acknowle...
- digital camera for xmas, good for shooty, does thi...
- submitted a handful of haiku to flanuer--those new...
- marin county feels yr pain.
- Mozambique may execute detainees summairly. if t...
- I find John Currin to be reactionary, hateful, and...
- bought a book this xmas, called queer pulp, a coff...
- tris mccoll deconstructs holiday favourites
- cowtown I saw a statue of the buddha, with sunken...
- before i forget, my grandmother also said this "i ...
-
►
11
(111)
AWESOME BLOGGERS, BLOGGING AWESOMENESS
About Me
- Anthony
- i am a sixteen foot sasquatch.