absynthe–minded:
so today in “unexpected meta drops”: Sam might have been talking to Sauron in and around Mordor, and it’s very subtle, and it scares the shit out of me
okay
okay.
I can’t prove this is what Tolkien meant. I thought until This Month, after eighteen years with these books, that I was reading Sam having conversations with himself. but? now? I’m really not so sure.
this first happens in “The Choices of Master Samwise” in The Two Towers, after Sam has gone from rage and grief to dabbling with suicidal thoughts and despair:
He looked on the bright point of the sword. He thought of the places behind where there was a black brink and an empty fall into nothingness. There was no escape that way. That was to do nothing, not even to grieve. That was not what he had set out to do. ‘What am I to do then? ’ he cried again, and now he seemed plainly to know the hard answer: see it through. Another lonely journey, and the worst.
‘What? Me, alone, go to the Crack of Doom and all?’ He quailed still, but the resolve grew. ‘What? Me take the Ring from him? The Council gave it to him.’
But the answer came at once: ‘And the Council gave him companions, so that the errand should not fail. And you are the last of all the Company. The errand must not fail.’
‘I wish I wasn’t the last,’ he groaned. ‘I wish old Gandalf was here or somebody. Why am I left all alone to make up my mind? I’m sure to go wrong. And it’s not for me to go taking the Ring, putting myself forward.’
‘But you haven’t put yourself forward; you’ve been put forward. And as for not being the right and proper person, why, Mr. Frodo wasn’t as you might say, nor Mr. Bilbo. They didn’t choose themselves.’
‘Ah well, I must make up my own mind. I will make it up. But I’ll be sure to go wrong: that’d be Sam Gamgee all over.
‘Let me see now: if we’re found here, or Mr. Frodo’s found, and that Thing’s on him, well, the Enemy will get it. And that’s the end of all of us, of Lorien, and Rivendell, and the Shire and all. And there s no time to lose, or it’ll be the end anyway. The war’s begun, and more than likely things are all going the Enemy’s way already. No chance to go back with It and get advice or permission. No, it’s sit here till they come and kill me over master’s body, and gets It: or take It and go.’ He drew a deep breath. ‘Then take It, it is!’
Sam taking the Ring was absolutely the right choice, above all else. It was vital and necessary. It had to happen and it speaks to his bravery and determination.
But.
Sam has one of the most consistent character voices in Tolkien - you can look at him and know when he’s talking, just by reading his dialogue. (all credit to @nikosheba for reminding me of that, and pointing it out) And this?
‘And the Council gave him companions, so that the errand should not fail. And you are the last of all the Company. The errand must not fail.’
This isn’t Sam. He doesn’t talk that way. He doesn’t interact even with himself that way.
it happens again in Mordor proper, too, and I think the full quote speaks for itself.
To his dismay Sam realized that he had not got an answer to this. He had no clear idea at all. Frodo had not spoken much to him of his errand, and Sam only knew vaguely that the Ring had somehow to be put into the fire. ‘The Cracks of Doom,’ he muttered, the old name rising to his mind. ‘Well, if Master knows how to find them, I don’t.’
note the “in his own voice” rather than clarifying it’s from himself, and the fact that after he tells whoever he’s talking to off, the Mountain reacts.
this, again, isn’t Sam.
and I’m beginning to be convinced it never was meant to be seen as him.