An excellent guest posting by JC from The New Vinyl Villain
The Midnight Organ Fight – Frightened Rabbit (2008, Fat Cat Records)
‘The Midnight Organ Fight’ was the second album to be released by Frightened Rabbit, on Brighton-based Fat Cat Records, in April 2008. At the time, the band was just beginning to have a bigger impact on audiences outside of Scotland, largely thanks to their June 2006 debut, ‘Sing The Greys’ that had initially only been available through a very small independent Glasgow-based label, having a re-release in late 2007.
I had been lucky enough to catch the band as they made their way up, playing all sorts of small venues in Glasgow, either as support or as headliners. It led to me being able to pick up much sought after tickets for the two gigs which launched ‘The Midnight Organ Fight’ on Friday 11 April and Saturday 12 April 2008, the first at Monorail, the venue attached to the Mono record shop that is part-owned by Stephen McRobbie (aka Stephen Pastel) and the second at King Tut’s Wah Wah Hut, the venue where Alan McGhee had (in)famously first set eyes on Oasis.
Both gigs, indeed like all Frightened Rabbit shows back in those days, were outstanding and went a long way to me instantly falling for the album. The new songs represented a quantum leap from the debut, of the sort that hasn’t ever been matched in all my years of listening to music and following bands. The debut had been a very fine listen – one that would have scored 8 or 9 out of 10 – but the follow-up turned out to be an album that, even all these years later, I can’t really find the perfect words to describe in the way I want to.
One of the most endearing things about frontman Scott Hutchison was that he had, from the very beginning, given freely of his time to music bloggers, which is why, somewhere in cyberspace there’s a fantastic piece written in 2008 for a blog that no longer exists (and whose name I can’t remember!) in which he broke down the album, song-by-song.
In essence, ‘The Midnight Organ Fight is a break-up album, but kind of unusual in that it isn’t written by the person who been chucked; instead the songs reflect the confused and horrendous emotions Scott was going through once he realised that his decision to bring a long-distance relationship to an end had been a huge mistake, but such was the mess he had made of the break-up that there was no chance of a reconciliation.
The songs, lyrically and musically, are intense and passionate. The Monorail gig turned out to have moments among the most emotionally gut-wrenching I have ever witnessed on a stage, none more so than when the rest of the band left Scott alone to deliver a solo rendition of this:-
Frightened Rabbit – Poke (2008, Fat Cat Records)
Scott’s brother, Grant, was also in the band, as the drummer. All he could do when he stepped back onto the stage was give his sibling a long hug in which they leaned in closely with Grant whispering something that seemed to have Scott believe things were now just a bit better.
Excuse me, it’s got a bit dusty in here just now as I think back to that night.
For all that it’s a break-up album dealing with all sorts of gut-wrenching emotions, there are actually a lot of upbeat tunes on the album. It was only afterwards, when the CD was played back at home, did I pick up that the lyrics encompass just about every emotion that will be experienced during a relationship, including a song, later released as a single, which celebrates fantastic and mind-blowing sex.
Frightened Rabbit – Fast Blood (2008, Fat Cat Records)
I’ve long remembered a quote from Scott which he gave in an interview with a local listings magazine in March 2018 when he was looking back on the album from a distance of 10 years, with plans in place with the band to have a celebratory tour:-
“The process of writing the album was the equivalent of being sick on yourself then picking through the bits of carrot and sweetcorn to find interesting shapes and tiny colourful items that you didn’t know could exist in the bile and lining of a stomach.”
It’s a helluva metaphor, and with hindsight, can be seen that the very idea of the 10th Anniversary was causing Scott all sorts of mental health issues that he was unable or unwilling to talk about. Fans and critics alike had not stopped raving about the album, with many people actually taking time to tell Scott, in person, how much it had helped them get through difficult break-ups.
Maybe for the first time in a decade, Scott was increasingly thinking back to the events that had caused the songs to be written in the first place, and maybe he was coming to the conclusion that he’d never really get over things.
Two months after that interview mentioned above, he took his own life, choosing to jump from a bridge into the freezing waters of the Firth of Forth, something that he had actually imagined happening when the relationship had broken up and had led to him writing and recording a song whose tune was far from mournful but whose lyric was filled with despair and whose closing lines later became a self-fulfilling prophecy.
‘And fully clothed, I float away
(I’ll float away)
Down the Forth, into the sea
I’ll steer myself
Through drunken waves
These manic gulls
Scream it’s okay
Take your life
Give it a shake
Gather up
All your loose change
I think I’ll save suicide for another year.’
Frightened Rabbit – Floating In The Forth (2008, Fat Cat Records)
I have regarded The Midnight Organ Fight as a masterpiece from the moment I got my CD back in 2008. But since Scott’s death, I’ve only once ever managed to play it in its entirety, and that was when I finally picked up a vinyl copy after it was repressed in 2022.
‘Floating In The Forth’ is the second-to-last song and is followed by a short instrumental number. The needle never reaches those particular grooves nowadays. Maybe one day in the future……
But let’s not leave things on such a downbeat note. The album deserves better.
There’s a song that has nothing to do with love breaking down. It’s one which, without fail, always got the crowds bouncing at live gigs. As can be heard on this version, akin to a Glasgow acoustic hoe-down, recorded in October 2008, at a tiny basement venue in front of maybe 100 fans, with the gig later being released as the album ‘Liver! Lung! FR!’
Frightened Rabbit – Old Old Fashioned (live) (2008, Fat Cat Records)
I make no apologies that this is a much longer piece than is normally found over here at NBR, and I’d like to thank SWC for asking me to contribute to such a fantastic and long-running series. And I never got round to even mentioning the album’s most enduring song, one that with Scott no longer with us, James Graham of The Twilight Sad (with the blessing of the Hutchison family) has added to his band’s setlists.
Frightened Rabbit – Keep Yourself Warm (2008, Fat Cat Records)
Thanks for reading.
SWC adds – I’ve long been a fan of this record and when it came up via the random album selector, I started to write what I thought about it– and not a single word of it was a patch on what JC has written here. Thanks JC for this piece – and for everyone who has not heard ‘The Midnight Organ Fight’ you should rectify that as soon as possible.