March 15, 2026
John 9:1-41
We have quite a cast of characters in today’s story, don’t we? We have Jesus, the Healer. We have the disciples whose only real contribution today is to ask a rather indelicate question. We have the man born blind, who Jesus gave sight, in more ways than one. We have the blind man’s neighbors who know him… but then don’t. We have the blind man’s parents, who basically throw their son under the bus. And we have the Pharisees who had sight… but spend the entire story today trying to prove that they didn’t. As we think about today’s text, I’d like first to take a few moments to recap the story, but then I really want to take some time to think about what it means to be offered sight. And specifically, I’d like for us to think about what it means for the blind man to be offered sight, what it means for the blind man’s parents to be offered sight, and what it means for the Pharisees to be offered sight.
As our story begins, Jesus has just left the temple when He encounters a man who was born blind. The disciples, apparently forgetting that the man was blind and not deaf, ask Jesus, “Who sinned that this man was born blind? Was it him or was it his parents?” It was, and I believe in many ways still is, common for individual suffering to be attributed to individual sin… we need look no further than the concept of karma to see this thought in action today. But Jesus soundly rejects this idea. “Neither this man nor his parents sinned,” said Jesus, “but this happened so that the works of God might be displayed in him.”
It seems that, for humans, the idea of the causes of individual suffering being self-inflicted is somehow less unsettling than the idea of individuals suffering without reason. And so, here the disciples seek some comfort in finding somewhere to assign the blame for this man’s blindness. But life doesn’t always work that way. We know, as Christians, that God graciously and faithfully forgives sin. But we also know that He does not tend to remove us from the consequences of our sin. And so, there may be times when individual suffering is a direct result of individual sin, but the truly distressing thing about sin is the fact that sin has a ripple effect. Like a stone dropped in water, the effects of sin emanate from the event and can adversely affect people who are in no way related to the sin that is now causing their suffering. And so, what Jesus wants the disciples, and us, to understand here is that God is never… ever the source of sin or suffering, but that God can use even the most unfortunate of circumstances to make good things happen. And we will shortly see that in the life of this man who was born blind.
Next, Jesus takes a handful of dirt, mixes it with saliva and makes a small amount of mud that he puts on the blind man’s eyes, then, He commands the man to go and wash his eyes in the pool of Siloam (Sy-lów-umm). When the man does that, he is able to see. He returns to the place where Jesus had healed him and Jesus is gone. But his friends are still there, and I think it is safe to assume that they are perplexed, to say the least. This person that they have known to be blind from birth can now see. And incredibly, some of his friends claim that he is not who he is. When our formerly blind friend assures them that he is indeed the same man that they know who had been born blind, they, of course, want to hear the story… what happened? And so, for the first of multiple times in today’s story, the formerly blind man explains, factually, truthfully, and succinctly, exactly what happened. “The man they call Jesus made some mud and put it on my eyes. He told me to go to Siloam and wash. So, I went and washed, and then I could see.”
For reasons that the text doesn’t make entirely clear, his friends brought him to the Pharisees. And here is where we find out that this healing happened on the Sabbath. And so, according to the Pharisees, this healing was illegal. Now, this isn’t the first time that Jesus has chosen to do something on the Sabbath that He knew the Pharisees weren’t going to like. You see, the Pharisees had this thing called the Mitzvot. And the Mitzvot was the result of literally hundreds of years of rabbinic thought. It was a list of 613 rules and regulations that were rabbinic interpretations of how God’s law should be applied in everyday situations and for the Pharisees, these interpretations, though not from the Bible, carried the weight of the Law itself. And Jesus had not only healed on the Sabbath, but He had broken the Mitzvah that prohibits work when He made the mud out of dirt and saliva. The Pharisees asked the formally blind man to explain what happened and he told them exactly what he had told his friends, Jesus, mud, wash, see.
And this event actually caused a bit of a disagreement among the Pharisees. Because some claimed that Jesus could not possibly be from God because He broke the Law in violating the Sabbath, while others asked how a sinner could possibly perform such signs. And so, the Pharisees turned to the formally blind man to ask his opinion, and he responded that Jesus is a prophet. Now, some of the Pharisees thought that this was all a trick, that this wasn’t the man who was originally born blind, but was an imposter, and so, they summoned his parents.
And here is where I need to step away from today’s story for a minute so that we can understand something. In Jesus day, the temple wasn’t just about religion. It was government, it was school, it was the source of social relationships, it was everything. And to be put out of the temple was more than just to be excluded from your faith community. It was to be ostracized. Being thrown out of the temple would likely cost you your job, your friends, possibly even your family. For a first century Jew to be cast out of the temple would be catastrophic. And the Pharisees had decided some time previously, that anyone who was a follower of Jesus would be cast out of the temple. And so, returning to our story, the formerly blind man’s parents must have been terrified to have to stand before the Pharisees. The parents confirmed that this was their son. They confirmed that their son had indeed been blind since birth and then here comes the part where they threw their son under the bus. When asked how it is that he can now see, they replied, “He is of age; ask him.” The parents apparently wanted no part of an argument with the Pharisees. The last thing that they needed would have been to be cast out of the temple.
And at this point, let’s not judge the Pharisees too harshly. And don’t worry, I’ll judge them harshly later. In a world that was predominately polytheistic, the Jews were uncompromising defenders of their faith. Through the years the Jews had encountered a multiple of men who had claimed to be the Messiah and, of course, were not. And so, the Jews were quite experienced in tenaciously opposing wannabe Messiahs. But this time was different, this time there were signs and wonders that confirmed the Messiahship of Jesus to anyone who had eyes to see. But as we all know, it ended up that the Pharisee’s zeal to defend their faith caused them not to see. Even though it was their own God standing right before them.
And so, now a SECOND time the Jews summoned our formerly blind friend. “Give glory to God” the Pharisees said. This was the equivalent of someone today asking, “Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?” (I learned that from TV.) And then, the Pharisees asked our formerly blind friend all of the same questions all over again, only now, the witness was under oath. But this time the Pharisees indulged in a little bit of what lawyers today would call “Leading the witness”. The Pharisees, referring to Jesus, say, “We know this man is a sinner”. Our formerly blind friend responds to this by saying, “Whether he is a sinner or not, I don’t know. One thing I do know. I was blind but now I see!”. When the Pharisees demand that he tell them AGAIN how this all happened, he once again repeated his story, but then he provided a surprisingly snarky question of his own. “Do you want to become his disciples too?” he asked. Incensed, the Pharisees expelled him from the temple.
When Jesus heard that the formerly blind man had been expelled from the temple, Jesus found him and asked him if he believed in the Son of Man. “Who is he, sir?” the man asked. “Tell me so that I may believe in him.” Jesus identified Himself to the man, and the man said “Lord, I believe”, and then he worshipped Jesus.
As we follow our formerly blind friend’s story today, we see a progression. We see a man who doesn’t know Jesus, who is afflicted with physical blindness, but the fact that he doesn’t know Jesus makes his blindness spiritual as well. Jesus heals the physical blindness but as our story unfolds, his spiritual blindness is gradually brought into the light as well. From not knowing Jesus we find that his healing and his subsequent questioning by the Pharisees bring him to the realization that Jesus is a prophet. From realizing that Jesus is a prophet we find him to be defending Jesus against the Pharisees’ mistaken claims. Then, when Jesus comes to him again, we find the man calling Him “Lord” and worshipping Him. You see, Jesus hadn’t just given the man his physical sight, He had given Him spiritual sight as well. Our formerly blind friend had found an eternal saving faith as Jesus worked through the difficulties that our formerly blind friend had faced in his lifetime and turned those ashes of his life into beauty.
Our formerly blind friend’s parents had the same opportunity so see the work of Jesus for what it was… but were unable to see because of fear. Fear of the Pharisees. Fear of the disruption in their lives that would have occurred had they been banned from the temple. Fear of the rejection that they would face from their friends and neighbors if they ran afoul of the Pharisees. The parents were given the same offer of sight that was given to their son. But, though physically seeing, they remained in spiritual darkness; passing on the opportunity to become a beloved part of God’s family because they were afraid of what others may think.
The Pharisees? Well, they were offered the same opportunity for sight too, weren’t they? In fact, the Pharisees had been investigating Jesus for quite some time, and so this miracle wasn’t a first for them. They had heard of quite a few and clearly, some had witnessed Jesus’
miracles firsthand. Because the Bible tells us that Pharisees were present at some of Jesus’ miracles. And so, the Pharisees had to ignore the evidence that was literally right in front of them. And I think that this can only lead us to one of two conclusions. Either they were so entrenched in their theological beliefs that they left no room to see the incredible wonder of God; the magnificence of what God was doing in their lives, out of His great love for them, and doing these things entirely for their benefit. Or they were so protective of their privilege and their authority that they couldn’t stand the thought of someone taking any of that away from them.
Regardless of why, what remains is… in my mind… sadness. Sadness that people actually allowed the stuff of this life to stand in the way of an eternal relationship with the God, who knows them, loves them in ways beyond their capacity to understand, and relentlessly seeks to draw them into relationship with Him.
My dear friends… in a world filled with distractions and anxiety. in a world that chooses to make faith uncomfortable or uncool, in a world that is filled with misunderstanding and misinformation, let us keep our vision clear. Let us continue, day by day, to see the beauty and the majesty of what God is doing in our lives and in the lives of our brothers and sisters the whole world over. And let us all call on the Name of the Lord and say “Lord, I believe”.