So, I have this friend who's in the middle of a crisis. And, because she's not me, and this is not her blog, I'm going to call her Kate. She is not
this Kate, and she is not
ugly cake (who, if you haven't guessed by now, is actually me, surpirse, surprise, I know, I know, I'm awfully clever).
Kate is very emotionally involved with a man overseas. I won't say she's in love, but she has said things like "I want to marry him and have babies with him," so it's your call on how you think she feels. Recently, however, he's been really distant. As in, I-used-to-email/text/call-you-once-a-day-(at-least)-and-now-I've-let-five-days-go-by-without-any-kind-of-real-contact-whatsoever. Which, if he hadn't already established the precedent of being in touch everyday, might not be so bad.
But what's hurting Kate is something that resounds quite heartily with me: a communication breakdown. Which can happen between any two people at any time, and invariably leaves both feeling crappy, but can really hurt the one who's being shut out. It's fascinating (and frightening), and I can't figure out what drives a man (like Mr. Overseas) to pull back in such a way that poor Kate feels completely dismissed, ignored and heartbroken.
I have a few ideas, but I think they're incomplete. The first (and, to me, cop-outiest) answer is The Holidays. People behave differently over Christmas and New Year's. Christmas brings up huge issues for a lot of people -- religion, family, childhood regressions, alienation, anger, bad parents, good parents, dead parents... whatever it is, any kind of tradition (and Christmas is the traditioniest of all holidays, I'd say) can smack us back into patterns we thought we were good and done. (Like the time this year when my sister was hanging a wreath over the mantle, and even though her husband and I both said it was a bad idea to put it over the picture frame, she did it anyway. Trivial, I know, but instead of being angry at her for completely ignoring me, like I have in the past, I intentionally let it go. And ate more candied pecans. Not everyone's Christmas crises are quite so simple, though.)
And then, once you get over Christmas, BAM!, it's new year's and people feel an obligation to behave differently once again. To make resolutions to change. To start fresh. To disrupt whatever order may or may not have been established before.
I get the holidays excuse. I understand
that this happens, even if I don't always understand why. And I think the best way to navigate the holidays is to be in communication with your partner/date/crush(/family/friends/blog readers) about what's going on. "I need some space right now to get through the holidays" is a far better message than the "fuck you" a girl hears when you don't call her on new year's. "I don't understand why you need this" is much easier to navigate than "no, I won't" (whatever is at stake).
But let's say it's not the holidays. Let's say it's another woman making him distant, as Kate fears. How do you handle that -- especially if it's not something serious? I don't think you can say "oh, I need a little space right now to make out with someone else." But I do think something needs to be said. Whatever the cause (e.g., work, stress, illness, family, whatever), the drop off in communication needs to be addressed. Ignorance is not bliss, at least not in a relationship.
So why doesn't Kate step up and ask him about this, you're asking? Good point. And I think she will (or may even be in the process of it now). But there's a very delicate balance set up between a loving woman and the emotionally skittish man she cares about. We women feel the need to play it "cool as a cucumber" (
as my sister advised me in the posh country club bathroom) and let our men make their decisions, but at some point (I've decided), it's important to step up and say "less communication than this is not ok, and I'm prepared to leave if that's all I get," or something similar.
What's odd is that the more you focus on communicating clearly, the more you sound like a psychology textbook. Sometimes, though, sounding like an therapy-quoting emotional nerd actually helps the situation.
Kate is angry and hurt and bereft. I told her that everything she feels is completely valid, but that in confronting Mr. Overseas, she needs to remember what she wants out of all of this -- resumed communication, not an end to the relationship. Her impulse is to say (and I quote) "what the fuck, [insert last name only]?" I told her that maybe an approach more along the lines of "I have something I'd like to talk to you about because I'm feeling angry and frustrated and would like your help in trying to resolve it" might actually lead her nearer to where she wants to be.
I don't know. Maybe I'm overthinking all of this. Maybe there is no such thing as a communication breakdown, and it's just one person pulling back because he doesn't care as much anymore. Maybe, as the evil evil book says,
he really is just not that into you, and no matter what you do, you won't be able to change his mind or behavior.
I have no answers. Really, all I care about is Kate. Both Kates. All Kates.