There is nothing else in the Gospels like today’s story from the ninth chapter of John. Throughout the Gospels, Jesus heals people. Reactions range from joy to skepticism. Some people love Jesus for his healings; others despise him. Once Jesus is called Beelzebub, the prince of demons, for his ability to cast out demons.[i] But nowhere other than John 9 is there such an extensive effort to figure out from where Jesus’ power comes and how it is that Jesus heals. It is fascinating.
The story begins by making clear that the blind man has been blind from birth. He doesn’t have scales on his eyes—cataracts—as do some other blind people healed in scripture. This man’s eyes have never functioned. His blindness has been and is permanent.
The spiritual economy of Jesus’ day also leads the man’s community to assume that his blindness is either the result of his own sin or the sin of his parents. Like the friends of Job in another context, they think that any physical malady must be a punishment, and they want Jesus to tell them who is at fault.
But Jesus breaks the rules of their game. He discards the community’s reasoning off hand, he heals the man born blind.
After Jesus heals the man, his neighbors are incredulous. How can a man born blind now see? They take him to the experts in the Mosaic law, the Pharisees, for an explanation. And that’s when the dispute arises. From where does Jesus’ power to heal come? It must not come from God, the Pharisees say, because Jesus heals on the sabbath. Tempers flare. The man’s family gets caught up in the melee. The man himself is cast out of his community. One would think the man would be crushed by this turn of events, but instead he giggles like a child. The man says to those he has known all of his life—upon whom he now looks for the first time with eyes that see them, who now ostracize him because he has been healed, says to them—he says to them, “Here is an astonishing thing! You do not know where he comes from, and yet he opened my eyes. Never since the world began has it been heard that anyone opened the eyes of a person born blind. If this man were not from God, he could do nothing.”
I’ve always been deeply intrigued by this story. It is by far the lengthiest healing story in the Gospels. It involves so many twists and turns. Like reading a good Agatha Christie mystery story, I always felt like I was missing something, like some tantalizing clue was right in front of me but, ironically, I could not see it.
Then I visited Jerusalem and spent some time at the Pool of Siloam. It is a small, rectangular pool at the base of the hill below the Old City. A trickle of water enters it. Frankly, it’s not much to look at. But I vaguely remembered having heard of it before, and I went to my bible, sure enough, there it is in the ninth chapter of John: “Jesus spat on the ground and made mud with the saliva and spread the mud on the man’s eyes, saying to him, ‘Go, wash in the pool of Siloam.’ Then the man went and washed and came back able to see…The neighbors kept asking him, ‘How were your eyes opened?’ He answered, ‘The man called Jesus made mud, spread it on my eyes, and said to me, “Go to Siloam and wash.” Then I went and washed and received my sight.’”
I had never noticed before that Jesus doesn’t actually heal the blind man, not directly. Jesus puts a poultice on the man’s eyes, but the healing comes only after the man washes in the Pool of Siloam.
That was a clue, but it didn’t shed light for me. The Pool of Siloam didn’t seem to me to have any overt miraculous properties. It appeared to be mundane. I left the pool, forgot the story, and carried on.
A day or so later, I toured underground, subterranean cavern beneath the slope of the City of David. As we walked the cavern, our guide reminded us why King David originally wanted Jerusalem for his capital. Jerusalem sits that the western edge of the Wilderness, one of the dryest deserts in the world. It is not self-evidently a good place to settle. But underneath Jerusalem three thousand years ago there gushed and flowed the Gihon Spring, which provided and endless source of water to the people of Jerusalem. Even when besieged, the city would not thirst.
Jerusalem was a walled, impregnable city, and the way David originally conquered it was by sneaking up the spring’s water course and emerging in the middle of the city, Trojan Horse-style. Once Jerusalem became Judea’s capital, the Gihon Spring allowed the city to sustain over thousands of years, through countless attacks and sieges. Even in times of peace, the Gihon Spring saw the people through vicious droughts. For ancient Jerusalem, the Gihon Spring was, quite literally, the saving water of life.
As our guide told this story, we could hear rumbling in the distance. We kept walking until we came upon a gushing torrent of water that flowed through the rock and cascaded down the slope. With a smile, our guide explained that the same spring that slaked the thirst of King David still flows from the desert rock, endlessly providing water in a parched land. And that same torrent eventually makes its way all the way to the plateau to feed…the Pool of Siloam.
My mind immediately returned to John 9 and the story of the man born blind. I read John’s account of the healing as if for the first time. Jesus doesn’t actually heal this man at all. Hear again the scripture:
“Jesus said to the man born blind, ‘Go, wash in the pool of Siloam.’ Then the man went and washed and came back able to see.” Jesus prepares the man for healing, but the man is granted his sight when Jesus sends him to the rushing, gushing, torrential water that had preserved, saved, healed, and sustained the people of God since practically the dawn of history.
Like Ms. Marple revealing the mystery, the story of the man born blind revealed itself in wonder. I understand why the man giggled like a child, even when his community cast him out. The man says, “He put mud on my eyes. Then I washed, and now I see.”
John 9 shows us the futility of religious arguments about who is right, who is wrong, who sins, and who has God’s favor. As we fuss and fight, castigating those with whom we disagree and claiming sure knowledge we do not have, all the while the torrential power of God flows just beneath us, living water that can cleanse us, heal us, and slake our spiritual thirst. If you listen closely with spiritual ears, you can hear it rumbling, in the subterranean places, in the heart of the world, in the core of our souls, eternally and endlessly. When we are parched, God is there. When we are besieged, God is there. When we are blinded, God is there, overflowing like a torrent, cascading out of bounds to find us through desert and rock. Jesus points us to that source, that living water that sustains the world. All we have to do is open our eyes to see.
[i] Matthew 12:24-27 and parallels

























