I wasn’t originally going to post this since I didn’t know if it was a story or not. Well, since it made it to slashdot. I suppose somebody thinks it is. A gay/gay-friendly guild was given a warning about advertising in general chat under the Sexual Orientation Harassment policy. The GMs involved argued that because the phrase “LGBT” might incite a hostile response, it was inappropriate for general chat. Other GMs have defended the warning, saying that “sexual orientation has no place in the game’s ‘High Fantasy’ Setting.” (Yeah? Tell that to that guy stroking his Dwarven Hand Cannon.)
Personally, I’m of two minds on the subject; I think it’s misguided to disallow positive descriptions of LGBT people just because your GMs don’t want to deal with a homophobic response. Hello, welcome to our world; I suppose I should be reporting every “oh, that’s gay” and “don’t group with that fag” comment I overhear on channel 1, but I’d rather be playing the game than policing their TOS. Besides, I think everyone involved knows that a gay MMO guild will get some harassment. A gay anything in this country will get some harassment. The only way to get the harassment to stop is to confront it, right?
At the same time, this is Blizzard’s ball we’re playing with, and they have every legal right to go home with it. They have to cover their ass in the TOS, or else lawsuits would shut down Ironforge even faster than bad lag. Should we really expect a game company to push for anything more than better gameplay and greater profits? (The guild leader mentioned that Lambda Legal contacted her, and is checking if this policy violates California state law; Blizzard reps—who have finally stopped deleting forum posts about the controversy—say they are preparing a response as well, so expect at least a little more on the story.)
More fundamentally, though, I have a hard time supporting anyone spamming general chat with their guild promotional message. My ignore list is getting too full as it is. With that said, if I knew there was a gay guild on my main server, I’d probably drop my guild and join in a minute. Especially the one named “Fruits of Elune.” How can I resist a name like that?
And if guilds don’t advertise in game, where can they advertise? This might be a cue for someone to make an announcement of some kind, if he’s ready to do so.
Posted by Casey 


