
Dear Danny. Today is the first of my two fiftieth pre-birthdays, because today would’ve been your fiftieth birthday if you’d lived. Mom very briefly told me about you when I was a kid, sitting me down and explaining that before I was born I had an older brother named Danny, that you were born on the first of September and died on the seventeenth, and that you died because your heart wasn’t fully formed. And she showed me a photo of you, an unfamiliar baby cradled in her arms in a hospital room, your eyes open.
I don’t remember whether she specified that you were born in 1975, the year before I was; nor do I recall her mentioning that your middle name is Scott, and that thus my first name is a necronym. I didn’t learn these facts until something like three decades later, in my late thirties, when I saw your names and dates listed on a cousin’s family tree document I found at Mom’s and Dad’s house in Florida. I delicately wondered in surprise to Mom about your inclusion in a family tree, to which she replied: Well … he was alive.
Mom and Dad didn’t otherwise talk about you, and I guess in childhood and early adulthood I thought of you as a kind of distant curiosity, a sad and gentle memory safely locked away in an indistinct past that had nothing to do with me. Huh, I almost had an older brother, how strange. But what started to dawn on me at some point in my twenties, and weighed increasingly on me as time went on, is that your death must in fact have been a cataclysmic life-shattering tragedy for our parents, and I’d grown up oblivious not just to the enormity of this tragedy but to my having been all this time a result and a reminder of it. Obviously I wouldn’t have been born if you hadn’t died. You are not my older brother. You could never have been older than me and I could never have been younger than you, since we could never have both been alive at the same time. Had you lived, Mom and Dad would’ve waited a few years to have a second child, and that child wouldn’t’ve been me. Your death is why I’m here! The reason for my very existence is that the absolute worst, most harrowingly awful thing that can happen to a parent happened to our poor parents only two and a half weeks into their even being parents!
That is of course just one way to look at it. Alternatively, we might say that Mom’s and Dad’s feelings of love for each other exceeded their feelings of bereavement over their loss of you and my birth was an uplifting expression of their resilience and hope for a joyous new beginning. Hallelujah, right?
Or we might imagine that once Mom and Dad emerged in anguished shock from the hospital and came home to their silent house and its unoccupied crib, they were advised by a great chorus of concerned family and friends and medical professionals to for heaven’s sake have another baby as soon as possible, a nice new healthy fully-formed-hearted baby to help them feel better and get over their grief, in which case I am what’s evidently known as a replacement child, conceived in sorrow, carried to term in dread, born into a vortex of panic-stricken parental fear that at any moment I may die in infancy too, and then raised by two quivering traumatized souls too numb to form secure attachments yet desperately counting on me to somehow heal them, rendering me disproportionately prone to emotional instability, mental unwellness, identity disturbance, relationship difficulties, and other delights, if the replacement child books I’ve read are to be believed. If.
(How dare I make it all about me. I didn’t die. I didn’t lose a baby. I have it easy.)
Still another thing to say might be that there is no birth and there is no death and matter is neither created nor destroyed but only transformed and you were me before I was alive and I am you back from the dead and I’m just talking to myself as usual but this time in more ways than one.
I don’t know. Perhaps simultaneously all of these are true and none of them are true and some of them are true sometimes except when they’re not or don’t seem to be. There is no correct answer. For correct answers we must turn to arithmetic. Arithmetic confidently states that as of today I have been alive for 17,849 days. You were alive for sixteen days. I’m more than a thousand times older than you ever were, Danny! And I fucking feel like it.
Happy fiftieth, old man. Even though it’s not that happy. From your older younger brother who’s half named after you. I love you. Permit me to do what’s become my sentimental 1 September ritual of putting on two songs from Johnny Cash’s The Man Comes Around: to reduce me to tears, track ten, “Danny Boy”; and then to lift me back up, track fifteen, “We’ll Meet Again.”