I’m arriving very late to this party, far too late to call it fashionable. And, really, what would I know about being fashionable anyway? I am always on time. I’m usually so early that I have to drive around the block for 30 minutes so that I don’t bother the hostess by ringing the doorbell while she’s in the midst of hiding all of the toys and shoes and clutter (wait– maybe that’s just what I’m doing minutes before people arrive?) This is one reason that I always keep a book in the car, which brings me, at long last, to talking about the book itself. I enjoyed reading Water For Elephants and my husband can attest that I was inordinately excited to see an actual Ringling Bros train pass through the town we were visiting in Pennsylvania last month just after I finished the book. And now, for the discussion!
What is your favorite circus related memory?
It feels like so many of my memories from early childhood have evaporated each time I try to dredge them up, but as it turns out, I do specifically remember going to the circus with my parents. The memory is probably so vivid because an artifact from the occasion, a small white stuffed unicorn (gold horn, naturally, and teal blue hair for the mane and tail) still sits in among the odds and ends of my childhood possessions. My parents took me to the Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey circus at the coliseum in my hometown and left my younger sister and brother at home with a sitter. I loved having my parents to myself, eating pink cotton candy and seeing the “real” unicorn that was part of the show. Oh! And people riding motorcycles around in a metal cage. I was quite impressed with that part of the show.
On page 109, old Jacob complains about how his family keeps secrets from him: “And those are just the things I know about. There are a host of others they don’t mention because they don’t want to upset me. I’ve caught wind of several, but when I ask questions, they clam right up. Mustn’t upset Grandpa, you know… Why? That’s what I want to know. I hate this bizarre policy of protective exclusion, because it effectively writes me off the page. If I don’t know about what’s going on in their lives, how am I supposed to insert myself in the conversation?… I’ve decided it’s not about me at all. It’s a protective mechanism for them, a way of buffering themselves against my future death…” Reading this, I could see myself in both Jacob & in his family members, both in respect to our infertility situation and other matters. Whose viewpoint do you relate to most in this passage and why?
This is an interesting question. I mostly relate to being in Jacob’s position, of being excluded from receiving interesting or pertinent information, though my experience relates more to past events than current ones. My family’s way of coping with painful subjects is to try to bury them, usually without dealing with the emotional aspects of them first. Things don’t stay buried forever though and it is so frustrating to receives wisps of our history without knowing the whole, especially since those missing pieces of information are important, medically and emotionally. Over the years, my sister and I have been able to tease out the back story of several major events but we’re still missing pieces and clearly the trauma of those events is too great for us to ask any further questions. On the other hand, I respect and understand the need to close the door on something too painful to face everyday, and don’t want to force someone to discuss such things. More directly to the point of the passage above, I think that the failure to disclose upsetting things is possibly not so much to protect the family member from the pain of someone’s death, but out of embarrassment and trying to protect the way the person views them.
(From the discussion questions at the end of the book) Looking at himself in the mirror, the old Jacob tries “to see beyond the sagging flesh.” But he claims, “It’s no good….I can’t find myself anymore. When did I stop being me?” How would you answer that question for Jacob or for yourself?
This was one passage in the book that I related to strongly. I have experienced flashes of what Jacob describes, of looking into the mirror and not seeing myself, not recognizing myself, of realizing that I had so gradually lost myself that I hadn’t even noticed that I had disappeared. During my freshman year of college I slid into a deep depression so that by Thanksgiving, I was a shadow of myself and it wasn’t until a weekend with friends from home that I realized that I wasn’t myself anymore. It took several more months to find my regain my sense of myself. In my case, I stopped being me when I left the people and places that I made up my history, that had served as my touchstones. I was right to put my faith in those people, I’m still regularly in touch with them and in some ways they helped me rebuild myself, but I had to learn to be a whole person apart from them and to open myself to new relationships as well. It was character and life-skill building, but it isn’t something I ever want to experience again.
Hop along to another stop on this blog tour by visiting the main list at http://stirrup-queens.blogspot.com/. You can also sign up for the next book on this online book club: The Empty Picture Frame by Jenna Nadeau (with author participation because she’s a blogger!)