
Grove Koger
September 24 is the anniversary of the birth of francophone Swiss writer Charles-Ferdinand Ramuz, who was born on this day in Lausanne in 1878.
If you’re interested in classical music, you may know that Ramuz provided Igor Stravinsky with the libretto for his 1918 work Histoire du soldat. But Ramuz was also the author of a number of novels, chief among them Derborence (1934). I’ve just finished reading it, after having owned a copy for years, and it’s a striking and original piece of writing.

Since the original title was unlikely to resonate with English speakers, the novel was translated by Sarah Fisher Scott as When the Mountain Fell, a literal description of the catastrophic event it describes. It seems that, in 1714, the side of the Diablerets Massif collapsed near the village of Derborence in Switzerland, causing the death of 15 people and untold numbers of farm animals.
A second landslide, in 1749, created a rocky barrier behind which water rose to form what’s now known as Lake Derborence.
The summit of the Diablerets Massif lies on the border between the Swiss cantons of Baud and Valais and reaches an elevation of 10,530 feet. Ominously enough, its name means “abode of devils.” (That’s it you see below in a photograph by Zacharie Grossen, reproduced courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.) In looking for more precise geological information, I found a description in Landscapes and Landforms of Switzerland (Springer, 2021). There, Philippe Schoeneich and Emmanual Reynard write that the massif “is a striking structural landscape rising over 2000 m [6562 feet] above the valley bottom,” and add that “the historical Derborence rock avalanches … started from the southern rock walls of the summit area and form a spectacular rock avalanche deposit landscape.”

Ramuz’s short novel focuses on a small handful of characters, including old Seraphin, who’s been joined in his mountain abode for the summer by newly married Antoine. The latter is naturally anxious to be with his bride, but the custom in this part of the world is for the able-bodied men to spend the summer on the mountain heights with their herds. As Seraphin asks Antoine, “Are you at the other end of the world? Are you now? Anybody would think you were never going to see her again …” Which, of course, is precisely how Antoine feels.
Then, that night, the inexplicable happens: “[A]ll at once the roof fell in, and one of the beams, snapping off at one end, came crashing up against the bunk where Antoine lay.”
With seeming artlessness, Ramuz reproduces the scattered perceptions of his characters, who live in the shadow of the massif and the elements. “The lightning flashed again,” we read at one point. “Suddenly there was a window opposite her in the kitchen wall, then it was no longer there.
“A blinding white square, it sprang into being, vanished, flashed out again, and with it Therese too was first brilliantly lighted, then swallowed up in darkness, then lighted up again.”
This technique is particularly effective in describing the dilemma of the disaster’s one survivor, who must struggle, weeks later, to reassemble the reality that he took for granted before the mountain fell. “You see,” he explains, “I’ve got to learn everything all over again.”
As poet and diplomat Paul Claudel put it, “When the Mountain Fell is one of the summits of French prose.”
□□□
If you’d like to subscribe to World Enough, enter your email address below:
And if you’ve enjoyed today’s post, please share!












