cypher: (my aim is true)
marsupial fruitcake ([personal profile] cypher) wrote2017-10-02 09:09 pm
Entry tags:

Fated, Apocryphally

So Fate/Grand Order has been an excellent gateway drug, dragging me into the franchise wholesale. I had watched the Fate/Zero anime a few years ago and liked about 40% of it but felt like too much of the story was focused on the things that interested me least, and that was that... and then I got into FGO and started driving all these losers around and wanting to know more about them, and. yep.

I've now read the four available volumes of Fate/strange fake, I'm working on a playthrough of the first route of Fate/stay night, I've read the first volume of the Lord El-Melloi II Case Files, and I'm watching the Fate/Apocrypha anime as it comes out.


The short version of my reaction is I love every Servant in this bar, and some of the Masters can come along too. Holy shit. Each writer who takes a stab at Fate seems to have a different focus, and the writer for Apocrypha is into a lot of shit I love, about the nature of personhood and free will and who has the right to self-determination and how that's gained or lost. Plus bonus gender ambiguity.

Anyway yeah -- Sieg's journey is wonderful. Astolfo's brave determined optimism deserves all the hugs. Having Jeanne face off against Tokisada as martyred teenage zealots who have the same faith but very different goals was a fantastic choice. Watching each of the servants in the Red and Black factions try to negotiate how they're going to face this unconventional war is so neat, with all the things it reveals about each one's priorities and moral code. I can't believe this show had me going oh no, augh, poor thing about Vlad the motherfucking Impaler. A+

And then there's MORDRED. HOLY SHIT. Mordred is the Saberface of my heart, no question—from the moment they drew first drew their sword on Sisigou to warn him not to gender them again I was dead. (I have been told that according to fandom it is "correct" to gender Mordred female anyway but FANDOM CAN BITE ME.) I haven't asked for Mordred/Sisigou in exchanges yet because I think what I want is the version I would write myself, but goddamn. They have this amazing relationship of "I trust you to be badass, so don't fuck up," and then he goes and sneaks in a little extra pettins for their brittle ego and they try not to get too overwhelmed by how good that feels and I LOVE THEM TOGETHER? Also I love the kind of guy who brings a shotgun to a mage fight, especially when he then fires dead men's fingers out of it.


I don't even know where a body goes to get DW icons anymore but I really want some Fate/ ones.
crossfortune: enkidu, fate (something in your fabric ties you here)

[personal profile] crossfortune 2017-10-03 05:07 am (UTC)(link)
FGO really is the best gateway drug: I bounced off the F/Z anime after like three episodes, hard, but FGO has dragged me back in (so now here I am with Apoc, F/SF, and crying over inaccessible Prototype Blue-Silver Fragments).

Amakusa Shirou Tokisada is like my fucking catnip, 1000% my type: I too love everyone, but Shirou is like tailor made for me to the point where my boyfriend (who I dragged into Apoc with me) figuratively looks at me in voice chat the second he first had lines and went "isn't he basically a character you've tried to play in my games before?" to which I Very Cleverly replied "I've never played a shady priest in one of your games before." I have so many feelings and I really want to write fic.


Mordred is the best. i love them so much, perfect child. also fuck Fate fandom as a whole re: gendering of characters, they are super awful at that. (though really, "fuck fate fandom" can just about...sum it up, really. like seriously).

Uhh...probably look for Fate roleplay accounts? That's where I got the few I have, though if you want I could ask my plurk friends if they have any ideas on where to get some. I really want a Shirou icon.
crossfortune: dan heng, honkai star rail (for i see what i destroy)

[personal profile] crossfortune 2017-10-04 05:23 am (UTC)(link)
I knew the basics of the period + his historical stuff, but I ended up falling into researching some, especially around the same time I fell into reading a really strange josei manga from the early 2000s that also made use of Amakusa Shirou, though...in a very different direction. And it really is - I'm really curious to see where Apoc goes with it.

I'll drop you a request: I'm crossfortune on there.
crossfortune: dan heng, honkai star rail (tell us why we must suffer)

[personal profile] crossfortune 2017-10-04 03:44 pm (UTC)(link)
It's called Amakusa 1637, and the basic premise is that 7 graduating teenagers from a Japanese Catholic school are unexpectedly thrown back in time (are mostly separated, too). The main character, Hayami Natsuki, who ends up in the Amakusa islands in 1637 (some time before the Shimabara Rebellion), discovers two things: 1), that everyone in the village she ends up in keeps mistaking her for Masuda Shirou (Amakusa Shirou before he would be known as Amakusa Shirou), as she is a dead ringer for him, and 2) the real Shirou is dead, having died some time ago in a drowning accident, and everyone thinks she's either him come back out of a miracle or an angel sent by God that took his form. So she takes his place and is trying to prevent the Shimabara Rebellion.

There are things I definitely like about the manga - Natsuki is the best and all the girls are a delight, the premise is interesting, and while the real Shirou only shows up in really sad, awful flashbacks in a couple of chapters, being dead and all, I really like him and want to fic shit.

There are definitely things that annoy the fuck out of me: Natsuki's best friend Eri does the "if you were a boy I'd be in love with you" shit (For fuck's sake!) and one of the characters who she does reveal herself to is all "no way you're a woman, women can't sword things that well" casual misogyny, to which I was hoping for her to beat the shit out of him (I stopped reading because something else came up that was dealbreaking for me, though skimming further on seems to indicate that he got the fuck over that at least).

I was also still trying to work out how I felt about certain things in the main premise, too.





lassarina: (Balthier)

[personal profile] lassarina 2017-10-11 04:30 am (UTC)(link)
*paws gently at this* I so badly need more time to experience more canons ;; I do so love listening to you talk about Fate though.