Debunking “Communists killed millions”

I’ll debunk this in two parts.

1. First I’ll mention the many millions killed by capitalist nations.  (Not the full list, but just some.)

2. Then I’ll just debunk everything we’ve all heard about the USSR/etc.

eg:

“The United States most likely has been responsible since WWII for the deaths of between 20 and 30 million people in wars and conflicts scattered over the world.”

http://www.countercurrents.org/lucas240407.htm

“The United States Has Killed At Least 8 Million People”

http://www.peaceonearth.net/8million.htm

etc.

Both of these are ignoring many more millions killed, eg the slavery/murder of Africans, genocide of Native Americans, loss of life from American eugenics, & many more killings.

Plus, capitalist famines generally (India, Africa, Ireland, etc) have killed hundreds of millions.

Winston Churchill:

 “I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with a beastly religion. The famine was their own fault for breeding like rabbits.”

Further, you could add assassination around the world (especially South America), & atrocities by capitalist & US funded states, like the anti-democratic regimes of Iran, the Congo Free State atrocity, colonialism, etc.

But capitalists ignore all of such when telling about the alleged “atrocities” of (eg) the USSR.

Next, practically everything we’ve all heard about the USSR & other communists is false.

1. Gulags.  Gulags are called killing camps on Fox News.

Reality: Over their entire history they had about a 95% survival rate.  (But lower during ww2.)  Which is expected with very limited resources & so on.  And those executed include many Nazi soldiers as well as alleged murderers/etc.

And “gulags” are just prisons.  Every large nation has a terrible corrupt prison system.

2. The Ukrainian famine is called “killing” in the West & is assumed to be an act of the state.

Reality: eg, the USSR sent emergency food & did other things to try to help.

“The 1932 reductions in state procurements and exports proved hopelessly inadequate.  So did the regime’s attempt to deliver food relief.  In a series of decisions in 1932-33, the Politburo reversed its policy to reserve grain relief for the cities.  In March 1932, it ‘substantially reduced’ the food rations… The urban death rate doubled in the main famine regions.  Between August 1932 and January 1933, the Politburo reluctantly reduced grain collection plans by 4 million tons, and the state failed to collect a planned 1 million more.  In 1932-33, it released 2-3.5 million tons of grain collections for rural consumption as food, seed, and fodder, of which 330,000 tons were for food… Most state agencies, even including the repressive apparatus, were largely overwhelmed by the scale of the famine tragedy.”

—  https://encrypted.google.com/books?id=Bc30ytJmwzMC&pg=PA502

Also:

“Western historian Dr. Mark Tauger, who concluded that the famine was not fundamentally ‘man-made’.[81][82] He says that rustic plant disease, rather than drought, was the cause of the famine.”

— wiki

3. Some people count the people Stalin drafted (and killed by the Nazis) as killed by Stalin. This is not honest.  And so on.

The people who deserve the blame (for troop deaths) are obviously the Nazis.

As for Mao:

1. There is no verification at all of the allegations made by Mao’s political opponents that (eg) 10m+ people died because the Great Leap Forward.

2. The truth is there were real natural disasters which (partially) led to the famine:

“The Encyclopædia Britannica yearbooks from 1958 to 1962 also reported abnormal weather, followed by droughts and floods. This included 760 millimetres (30 in) of rain in Hong Kong across five days in June 1959, part of a pattern that hit all of Southern China.

As a result of these factors, year over year grain production dropped in China. The harvest was down by 15% in 1959. By 1960, it was at 70% of its 1958 level.”

— wiki

Similarly:

> “According to the China Statistical Yearbook (1984), crop production decreased from 200 million tons (1958) to 143.5 million tons (1960).”

— wiki

And grain/etc shortages used to be common, & such a long history of famine was very much pre-Mao & something he inherited:

– Worldinfo.org:

““China has been living in the shadow of famine for centuries”  (Ashton, 620).  1876-79: drought in north China led to famine, which resulted in between 9.5 and 13 million deaths”

http://worldinfo.org/2012/01/famine-in-china/

Next:

– 2) Even if Mao’s actions did more harm than good during the famine, that has to be understood while also knowing Mao era vaccine programs saved tens of millions of lives.

– 3) When we see population numbers which are not as high as expected, we have to remember that during famine times millions of women don’t marry & have kids.  Part of such numbers are birth related, not starvation.

It’s fair to assume any politicians/rulers had mistakes, so it’s likely that Mao did some during the famine.

In the West what we see, instead of balanced debate or criticism about Mao era policies, is more like a religious mob- people  are taught to believe (via faith) any allegations made against about Mao era China.

Next, the Khemer Rogue.

We were taught they were communists.  Really Pol Pot & his VP (equivalent to VP) said they weren’t communists, & that they wanted Cambodia to belong to the west.  (ie, capitalism.)

Leng Sary:

“We are not communists … we are revolutionaries’ who do not ‘belong to the commonly accepted grouping of communist Indochina.”

— said in 1977, quoted by Vickery, Cambodia: 1978-1983, p. 288

Pol Pot:   

“When I die, my only wish is that Cambodia remain Cambodia and belong to the West. It is over for communism, and I want to stress that.”

brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/p/polpot184779.html

They were ex-communists who flipped sides, & became paid by the West/capitalist side (who they endorsed) to fight communist Vietnam.

  • Communists defeated the Khmer Rogue.
  • Capitalists funded the Khmer Rogue.

Debunking Western hypocrisy about political dissidents oppressed in the USSR, Cuba, etc.

Even if the allegations are true about the USSR (and Cuba etc) the USA has gone far beyond that, killing many millions in attempts at political censorship:

  • The Vietnam war was an attempt to censor communists/socialists via mass murder & establishing yet another capitalist police state.
  • The many assassinations of elected socialist leaders, especially in South America
  • Plus leaders world wide who had the philosophy that the nation’s oil should help it’s own people, not Western corporations.

And even if we ignored all the activists in jail in the USA, there is almost full censorship of political speech via about six corporations owning the media.

This censorship/ownership is violently enforced by the capitalist’s state and yet they manage to fool people into thinking there’s far more free speech allowed than there is.

Basically, yes you can speak online, except they’re spying on you to intimidate you.

Debunking almost everything about the “Katyn Massacre”

YSK the Polish were helping the Nazis: violently taking over other countries with the Nazis & protecting the Nazis from Soviet invasion.

The USSR had plans to invade Germany & Poland was protecting the Nazis:

“Papers which were kept secret for almost 70 years show that the Soviet Union proposed sending a powerful military force in an effort to entice Britain and France into an anti-Nazi alliance. “

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/russia/3223834/Stalin-planned-to-send-a-million-troops-to-stop-Hitler-if-Britain-and-France-agreed-pact.html

And who was against it?  The Polish.

“The new documents, copies of which have been seen by The Sunday Telegraph, show the vast numbers of infantry, artillery and airborne forces which Stalin’s generals said could be dispatched, if Polish objections to the Red Army crossing its territory could first be overcome.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/russia/3223834/Stalin-planned-to-send-a-million-troops-to-stop-Hitler-if-Britain-and-France-agreed-pact.html

The Polish weren’t just protecting Germany, but had joined with the Nazis in invading other countries.

Winston Churchill:

“Great Britain advances, leading France by the hand, to guarantee the integrity of Poland — of that very Poland which with hyena appetite only six months before, joined in the pillage and destruction of the Czechoslovak state.”

This doesn’t mean the USSR was flawless, it means they were fighting to defeat the Nazis and the Polish were at the time protecting them (etc.)  The fact that some of their military leaders, lawyers, etc were killed is often described on TV like they were totally innocent.

If people heard “Military leaders who’s nation was helping the Nazis were killed” it would not be considered such a big event in the media.