I'm sorry, this woman has not got ANY idea of clinical reality! I've just come off a ward round in the cancer centre. Many ppl with life-limiting illness but lots of active treatment. We have so many important matters to discuss&she wishes us to just casually place this bombshell
What? @kimleadbeater has just said that doctors MUST raise the issue of #assistedsuicide with terminally-ill patients, completely contradicting Clause 4(2) that does not obligate doctors to raise it. What a mess.
Noise.
Sorry, @kimleadbeater , I was willing to give you the benefit of the doubt. Calling this much needed debate 'noise', calling the voices of the disabled, marginalised or abused 'noise'. How dare you?
This is very wise. Danny, how I wish I had known of you before. I am merely a doctor who works with terminally ill pts on a daily basis. An incorrigible atheist (irrelevant, but also a bit inconvenient to black&white thinkers, I know, I know), with my petty concerns about aspects
This is very wise. I also think it will prove very difficult. I have been struck by the vehemence of opponents of assisted dying, who seem certain it will produce coercive deaths and are not much moved by the terrible stories of pain and suffering which motivate supporters. Nor
More than 60 organisations now raising concerns over this #AssistedDying Bill. Committee are failing to make them feel heard and trust is rapidly diminishing in the process
If this particular #AssistedDying Bill is voted through, there will be a public inquiry into failings within 5-10 ys. I have therefore kept notes of all correspondence with Government & MPs, so that there can't be doubt abt what they did & did not know now &what they let through
From @TheBMA "Assisted Dying is not a health activity and it must not take place in NHS or other health facilties" Motion 46
This has just been voted on and passed in the BMA consultant conference.
I get the feeling that some MPs haven't scrutinised the #AssistedDying bill& are voting for this because they feel that Kim Leadbeater is a good egg, which undoubtedly she is. But this is NOT voting 4 your favourite act at Eurovision, this is seismic law change at breakneck speed
A patient: ‘I do NOT want to talk about dying’
Me: ‘No problem, let’s talk about you living’
Pt: ‘Sounds good’
Followed by a long chat about preferences & #WhatMattersMost to them. D-word didn't have to feature
Made me think about how much conversations have to be individualised
Health Secretary Wes Streeting said part of the reason he could not vote for assisted dying was because palliative care was not good enough. Now is the time to fix that.
Instead of saying 'withdraw care', how about saying 'increase care' - but with different treatment focus? We DON'T stop caring, even in ITU settings, when the big machines/drugs don't succeed. Attention to words. #hpm#MedStudentTeaching #NoCeilingOfCare
With regard to #AssistedDying some reflections: a fairly large chunk of those people who may be expected to deliver this (geriatricians, GPs, oncologists, nurses, judges, courts, hospices) are either v actively opposed to it, or wouldn't want to be involved. 🧵
New: A study from Munich on #AssistedDying has raised concerns. Contrary to commonly held beliefs, the majority of service users were not terminally ill. And the majority were elderly females from more affluent backgrounds. A thread. 🇩🇪
blogs.bmj.com/spcare/2025/04…