Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Christmas Eve

It is still not high enough for the child to pass under

On Christmas Day 2021, a BBC Radio Wales special hosted by Michael Sheen featured a brand new Manics song, specially commissioned for the program. The music was a brand new composition, but the lyrics were adapted from R.S. Thomas’ poem “Christmas Eve”. Thomas, an old favourite of the Manics (his poem “Reflections” acts as the sleeve quote for This Is My Truth Tell Me Yours), was not only a Welsh nationalist and one of the country’s most famous poets, but also a priest by trade: many of his poems bear a spiritual context, and he wrote several poems specifically about Christmas. It’s no wonder though that it’s “Christmas Eve” specifically that the Manics decided to use for this competition. The short poem (extended into three verses by the Manics by repeating the first at the end) is critical of a greed-oriented society and whilst the Manics are unlikely to resonate with the implication that the greed has blocked the religious heart of the season, the first verse’s detailed description of the capital’s opulence isn’t too far away from the exaggerated detail that Wire and Richey used to use as a weapon.

Where the Manics’ previous seasonal outing “Ghost of Christmas” was a rowdy office Christmas party rocker, “Christmas Eve” follows the other time-hallowed Christmas song tradition of a hushed acoustic number, ready for the quiet candle lit evenings in the middle of the dark winter. James’ twangy acoustic guitar holds the lead line while Wire’s minimal bass and a delicate piano accompany it; every now and then, a triumphant trumpet (presumably played by Sean) arrives to bring a festive pomp. There’s even a brief “choral” part composed of a few vocal layers singing in harmony, that veers very close to a typical Yuletide choir in what is most certainly a very intentional move. But though there’s a bit of grandeur to its aura, it’s a gentle mood number at heart – one to appreciate during the less hectic moments of the season, rather than one you’d tap your foot to on an Xmas playlist. All the better for it: as a romantic melancholic I have a soft spot for these types of hushed Christmas scene-setters, and though you can’t accuse “Christmas Eve” for being among the Manics’ catchiest songs, it has a rather captivating grip for its three minutes. The arrangement offers a few surprises by way of the trumpet and the vocal harmony, and in some way it’s simply enjoyable to hear James practically recite a piece of poetry instead of a standard, more song-like lyric. Been a while since the last time.

As of December 2025, “Christmas Eve” is yet to surface officially and only a radio rip exists for those who seek to hear it; as a result, this has flown under most people’s radars and even many hardcore Manics fans have little knowledge of it. One can only hope we’ll receive a proper copy to call our own one day – it would make a good companion to “Ghost of Christmas” in a Manics fan’s Christmas compilation.

Advert break

Hey everyone!

Given whoever follows this blog is clearly interested in minute trivia about Manic Street Preachers songs, I figured I ought to make everyone aware of the recent release of the book 168 Songs of Hatred and Failure by Keith Cameron, which came out this September. Cameron’s book runs through the Manics’ history by exploring 168 songs of theirs from “Suicide Alley” to “Johatsu” – it’s based on not just historic data, but also brand new interviews with James and Wire solely for this book. Suffice to say it’s an absolute goldmine of information, revealing whole new facets of not just the big songs we thought we couldn’t know anything more about, but also uncovering lots of neat tidbits and hidden knowledge on many of the band’s deep cuts and b-sides – and it confirms and debunks a few persistent fan theories and rumours too! It’s a fantastic book and I would heartily recommend it to anyone who reads this blog regularly.

I also wanted to confirm that I’m not going to do a whole site-wide sweep of the entries based on the book, because then I’d just be replicating the book. What I have done is just fix a few errors here and there, remove caveats from the confirmed rumours and in a couple of instances add a tiny bit of text where I felt the new information warranted it (the plot twist of “The Soulmates”, for example…). Whilst this site does pretend to act as an information source (and let’s face it, Cameron puts me to shame here), it is still as much a repository for my own opinions and those don’t need updating after the book.

Critical Thinking updates will follow next year. I was hoping to finally get around writing about some of the solo works this year but unfortunately my life has been… a bit much in 2025 and some projects have taken a backseat. Maybe after Critical Thinking

Thank you for reading the blog!

Lifeblood updates

I’ve gone and done a few tweaks across the Lifeblood era entries following the 20th anniversary reissue earlier this year. Nothing too radical (no great shifts in opinion or anything, you know I’ve worshipped this album for two decades) and some songs have had more notable updates than others, but we are again sort of up to date.

(shameless plug of my own site but if you want to read my thoughts on the reissue as a whole and a summary of everything detailed across several pages here, why not check the full review?)

In other Manics news, “Decline and Fall” was released last month and the current rumours about the new album date its release to early next year, likely around February time. I won’t be making a post about the new song ahead of my overall entries for the new album, and as per usual those likely won’t be done until roughly a year from the album. The reason for that is to not only let the songs grow (or the honeymoon phase to wane off) naturally over time where it’s possible, but also to let the era itself unfold i.e. the full range of promo interviews, any potential additional releases, the tour, etc. Anything that would add context and reveal the hidden truths behind the songs.

Thank you for reading the blog, as well as thank you for everyone who emails me and who comments on the posts!

Brief Q2 2024 update

Hi everyone!

The reach of this blog still continues to amaze me – so many of you have sent me emails asking if I’m going to write about any of the new revelations brought on by the Lifeblood reissue (and I’m delighted that I seem to have built this – wholly accurate, mind you – reputation as a fanatic devotee of that album). The answer is yes, I am. I haven’t wanted to rush into it, you know my slow and steady pace by now plus I’ve been a little busy IRL and with some other projects, so I haven’t had the spare time either. However, I’m looking to add some new commentary across the Lifeblood song articles where I deem it’s interesting in the next couple of months. I’ll make a new post about it too, once it’s done.

(Speaking of that Lifeblood reissue? Wow, what a treat! So much fascinating stuff going on in those demos, genuinely some of the most exciting bonus material the band have ever released! I also really recommend the Necessary Evil post about the album and the reissue, which goes into so much detail in far more interesting ways than I could ever write – and they rubbed my ego by citing me so you know it’s a good article)

I also want to make a serious effort to fill some gaps on this site this year, namely in respect of James and Nicky’s solo works. While the solo albums don’t necessarily have the general context and the personal passion that the main Manics back catalogue does, they are often great and fascinating periods of the respective songwriters’ histories, and their absence feels a little odd even to me. I can’t promise when I’ll add all that in, but hopefully I can get at least started before the next Manics album comes out.

In more minor site updates, I’ve added a new page where I briefly rank all the Manics albums. This has actually been something I’ve been meaning to add for ages and was actually mostly written, but then I got distracted by regular site updates. It’s simply a brief overview of how I see the Manics’ world, for anyone who’s curious and wants some hard ranking to compare against opinions on the song entries.

I do also sometimes get asked if I write about anything more than just Manics, and the answer is yes. I have a personal website (which I think I’ve linked before but it never hurts) where I aim to review my entire music collection album by album, artist by artist (ish). There’s also an RSS feed if you still use one of those, to keep up to date.

That’s all I have this time, thanks so much for all your interest and time taken to read this blog!

Studies in Paralysis

Hope springs eternal that I will learn some lessons

The claims that the Solidarity/Door to the River split on the remastered Know Your Enemy is exactly like the band intended back in the day get thrown right out with the inclusion of “Studies in Paralysis”, the other previously unreleased and recently unearthed song from the vaults that now has a spot in the middle of the rockier/more unhinged Solidarity. Casting aside the general suspicion around how this was shelved so hard that it fell off the shelf completely and gathered dust underneath while no one noticed it was gone to begin with, even under the anything-goes mentality of these sessions “Studies in Paralysis” just doesn’t sound as polished – or finished – as the other album material. The heavily repetitive structure, minimal lyrics that rely on said repetition a lot and the general lack of any meat around its bones indicate that it’s a song the band didn’t really spend too much time on to begin with and it likely would have made a comfortable b-side for the period.

But Know Your Enemy b-sides are great, so it’s in good company! “Studies in Paralysis” has a solid groove to it which gives it a strong foundation to build on, it’s just the rest of the construction never quite started. The verses for example are so barebones that it’s obvious it was a one-take, one-guitar affair played in the practice sessions, but you can imagine that with just a little more stuffing around it they could easily be the kind of muscular post-punk menace you can hear being hinted at. And if it was left at that it’d be a minor footnote in the band’s discography and the obvious runt of the litter of this period, but then you’ve got the chorus that sounds like the real stroke of genius that the band came up with, and hastily scribbled the rest of the song around it. All the swagger, the attitude, the power that the verses hint come realised in the chorus, and the shared vocals between James and Wire are superb, passing off the baton from one another to create an effect far better than if it was just James singing the lines all by himself. I’ve always been a great fan of both of the band’s official vocalists coming together in a song because their wildly different approaches complement each other so perfectly, and that simple little vocal duet in this simple little chorus elevates it into something I keep coming back to over and over again. I’ve hit repeat on this song a lot and that’s just so I can get to the chorus again. It’s a great one.

In Solidarity though, its somewhat unfinished nature becomes apparent when sandwiched between the heavily remixed “My Guernica” and the boosted “Dead Martyrs”, both coming from the same place of origin in sound and tone but with a fuller, more realised execution. Solidarity overall is a bit of a mess the way the band have compiled it on the reissue and adding an obvious outtake like this doesn’t do either the song or the newly reforged album justice. But if this had been releases as one of the b-sides at the time, it would’ve made perfect sense. At least it’s out now though – the chorus is enough to justify its resurrection and it’s a piece of Manics vault material that in the end deserved to be brought into the sunlight.

While not a single, the song did receive a video which consists of various backstage footage of the KYE recording sessions and the Cuba gig. It’s a neat snapshot of the era, at the least.

Rosebud

Contempt is a glimpse of the past

Image

The arrival of two brand new songs from the vault with the Know Your Enemy reissue was a surprising sight: after all, the Manics’ b-side folders were always so bountiful that you had come to expect that any leftover material from the albums would have always seen the light of day. And that’s apparently indirectly the reason why it took until 2022 for “Rosebud” to be released: per the Manics’ court producer and “fifth Beatle” Dave Eringa, Wire had mistakenly assumed they had already released it as a b-side until they started pulling together the material for the re-release. It’s innocuous enough that it could be plausible (though given Wire’s obsessive archivist tendencies it’s hard to believe), and at the very least they saw to fix that error once they spotted it: “Rosebud” is a genuinely worthy addition to the discography.

The telltale signs of the Know Your Enemy era run all over “Rosebud”: the slightly disjointed, quietly experimental feel which lands it squarely in its parent era, the jagged acoustic edge, the organ and the ever-so-slightly raw sound. In fact, it’s such a striking time capsule that hearing it in the middle of the more contemporary Manics years really drives the point in of just how much the band has changed over the years. Listening to it alongside the other b-sides and bonus tracks of the period, it slots in perfectly – there’s none of the obvious demo-itis that happens with most archeological “previously unreleased” finds that end up in deluxe reissues. “Rosebud” is a fully formed song, and not just that but it’s also a well-written one. Both the disjointed groove in its verses and the sudden anthemic lift of the choruses are immediately striking and they stay with you, and the song doesn’t waste much time wrapping its curious hooks around the listener. The highlight of the song are Sean’s drums; once again very much in line with how he operated during the Know Your Enemy era, and subtly taking the lead of the song’s flow.

That said, as much as the reissue tracklist tries to convince otherwise – where this is placed on the more contemplative Door to the River disc of the newly-split double album – I don’t think for a second the band ever genuinely thought this was a strong contender for an actual album slot: it says enough that not only was this taken off the ultimate 16-track “best of” version of Know Your Enemy but then promptly forgotten so hard that it took two decades for the band to remember it. It’s also why I keep referencing b-sides and bonus tracks, because what ultimately ended up on the final original album made its own kind of mad sense, leaving the various non-album songs to weave all kinds of atmospheric slow-burner side paths. The murkiness and pace of “Rosebud” bears more similarity to songs like “Pedestal” or “Groundhog Days” than anything on the album, but keep in mind this was a truly rich period for b-sides and there’s no shame in that comparison. And as already referenced, despite the timespan between conception and release, it hasn’t lost any of that period’s charms: so much so that hearing it for the first time was like meeting a friend decades later after you had already forgotten what they looked like. There’s a bizarre pseudo-nostalgia around the song because it’s so close to that original era, and that’s in no way shape or form a bad thing.

Given my positivity about how much it reminds me of the past, the song’s message couldn’t be anything different. “Rosebud” is obviously a reference to Citizen Kane, the story of an elderly rich man who retreated his own bubble of treasures gathered over the years with his wealth, never able to fill the hole he had in his life as he yearned back to his innocent childhood days. It isn’t unheard of for Nicky to write an entire song about a fictional piece of work but the entire lyric seems to eventually trail off from Kane into something more personal; and the concept of building a world of your own out of things you gather isn’t too far off from “The Convalescent” which described that very world in great detail. If Rosebud is meant to represent the last tangible piece of your carefree days, then the refrain of “I think I lost a rosebud sometime today” seems to mark a breaking point, the moment when all of your optimistic innocence has been broken by the world around you. Which not only makes it an angle more befitting of Wire, but also the darker flipside of “Just a Kid” where that happiness still existed. If this had been a b-side back in the day, slotting it right after “Just a Kid” would have been absolutely beautiful.

While not properly a single, “Rosebud” was released as a promotional item for the Know Your Enemy reissue and received a video consisting of holiday-themed footage taken from the BBC Archives. If there’s a deeper meaning to it, I’ve missed it.

Borderline

Then you let me down when I look around

To sort of popularise on the unexpected success around The Ultra Vivid Lament, the Manics’ PR team started creating themed playlists of the band’s songs on streaming services and gave each one a minor promotional push: unique cover images, some social media posts, a quick blurb from Wire describing the theme and an angle or a hook of some kind: e.g. for their Duets playlist, the promotional texts were quick to mention “Black Holes for the Young” due to its obscure status. The Manics covering the early Madonna single “Borderline” was the hook for the Covers playlist. The band had covered the song as part of their BBC 6 Music Festival slot just a few months prior, seemingly just for the fun of it, and per Wire’s comments they had had such a good time playing it that they decided to record it. That cover then became the unofficial promotional single for the playlist as well as its accompanying digital-only cover compilation Sleep Next to Plastic which collected together a number of covers not available for streaming before.

In 2022 we’re well past beyond the point where the Manics covering a bubblegum pop cut is anything shocking, if it ever would have been given the band’s open love for such songs even in their early punk days and how they’ve covered “Umbrella” in the past. We’re also probably well past the point where they could be doing anything interesting with it. “Borderline” is a decent song (though far from Madonna’s best) and what positives there are to Manics’ cover stem entirely from the source, because the song is played completely straight – just replacing the original synthesizer production with a line-to-line rock band arrangement. It sounds like a version that any pub or wedding cover band could bring out to raise a few nostalgic smiles from the crowd. If the band had such an enjoyable time playing it, it’s not really audible from the recorded version because it has all the fun of seasoned session musicians clocking in for work. Though Bradfield at least sounds like he has memorised the lyrics to his heart thanks to a lifetime of listening to the song. Comparing this to the aforementioned version of “Umbrella” is almost inevitable and it highlights the difference between the two covers, and specifically how with “Umbrella” some thought has gone into how to move it into the world of the Manics and “Borderline” just sounds like a random copyright-dodging Spotify group.

But then, is any of this all that surprising? The Manics have never been a stand-out covers act and when they have accidentally landed with a genuinely good cover version, it’s often because they’re just playing the original and already excellent song 1-to-1 but with the benefit of having James Dean Bradfield sing it. I’m only writing an entry about this because this was sort-of-kind-of-maybe a single, but otherwise it’s nothing unusual from the Manics’ old habits. Live, it’s another matter – the BBC 6 Music Festival version has some ad hoc levity to it that’s missing from the studio version and that’s the kind of an environment where an ad hoc cover like this naturally belongs to.

These Dark Roads

Here I am, licking my wounds again

It’s interesting (to me, anyway) that we only received two actual additional songs from the The Ultra Vivid Lament sessions (pour one out in respect for the Manics’ rich b-sides legacy) and neither of them have anything to do with the album’s polished piano pop aspirations. You can tell by the way the rhythm flows on “These Dark Roads” that it was written on the piano like much of the album, but that’s where the similarities end. Instead stylistically we’re somewhere between a torchlight anthem and a Sunday school singalong (complete with lyrics about striving through difficulties), with a largely acoustic backdrop beyond a stylish organ and a skylining electric guitar solo and… well, we’re back in the realms of Rewind the Film again, much like “My Drowning World”. Both songs – and this one in particular – seem so out of place in the part of the Manics’ history where they are that it’s actually fascinating. Is this a leftover from the original writing sessions before the actual concept of the record started taking form, or a hint of the future?

Which makes it obvious why this became one of the Japanese bonus tracks for the album, but as a song it’s a really beautiful little number. The chorus this has could easily be something far more grating in much less skillful hands – it has that syrupy singalong quality familiar from the schmalziest of Britpop or your average school music class – but in Bradfield’s adept care it becomes a lovely and heartfelt moment of earnest optimism. There’s almost a little bit of a heartland rock/Americana vibe breaking through the seams when the solo does appear and the guitar continues to make a few simple licks throughout the final chorus, and the song has that overwhelming honesty and warmth that comes with the territory.

I’m also just a sucker for a Manics song with that classic organ sound, it’s such a good fit for them and I wish every time they were thinking of adding some synthesized strings into a song they’d just opt for the organ.

“These Dark Roads” is a curious relic out of time but a rather lovely little song in itself, and fingers crossed it receives a proper international release at some point.

My Drowning World

My father’s anger still raging

Wire’s mother passed away from leukemia in 2018, shortly after the release of Resistance Is Futile; a year later, his father died. And then, the world froze to a standstill when the pandemic happened. Wire has for a long time been contemplating the nature of time passing and his own mortality, but such major life events occurring one after another left an obvious heavy cloud above him which fuels most of The Ultra Vivid Lament. The only time Wire directly talks about his personal loss however is “My Drowning World”, left as the Japanese bonus track for the album and receiving no Western release (to date) thanks to the death of the single. It sees Wire summarising everything that made him the person who he is today: his parents, his upbringing in a Welsh mining town, the counter-culture literature and music he consumed. His national pride in Wales still burns strong despite everything he’s endured in his life: Saint David’s Day, mentioned in the closing lines, is a Welsh national holiday and though not a public holiday, Wire’s insistence in dedicating it to himself rather than work is a succinct statement of how close he is to his heritage.

Perhaps this was too directly personal to be in consideration for the main album – or maybe the sound of the song was too in contrast with the record’s high-polished elegiac pop, which would obviously have been an ill fit for the song. Instead Wire returns to the aesthetics of Rewind the Film with a melancholy acoustic rock song, naturally fronted by himself with some great backing vocals from James this time around. Like with many Wire songs the general arrangement is straightforward, but the melodies here are impeccable and the straightforward guitars and drums around them highlight them wonderfully: the chorus even threatens to go big with the rising melody and the additional guitars, like Wire trying to do a traditionally Bradders-like anthemic lift. The general muscle and depth of arrangement generally gives the impression that from a musical perspective, this is a “true” Manics collaborative piece that Wire just happens to lead; compare it to many of the other Wire b-sides which generally feel like remnants of his solo album without much of a Manics-specific flair, and you’ll see what I mean.

(I also want to mention the hazy production all over the songs that lends it a dream-like feel, but at this stage I can’t actually say whether that’s intended or if it’s the rip I have – but I would certainly want it to be attached to the song, because it works so perfectly with the song)

Despite the deep sorrow underneath it, “My Drowning World” is actually quite a defiant statement both in meaning and in execution, breaking through the sadness to stand back on its feet ready to face the rest the world has to throw against it. It’s an immediate stand-out: one of the best songs Wire has released under the Manics’ name. Leaving it off the album was the right thing to do though, because musically it has absolutely no place among the rest of it; to such an extent that this feels like a song without a real era, completely detached from the rest of the Manics’ material from this period.

Afterending

The near future has been and gone

Well, here’s the political statement we all wanted to hear from the Manics after the – quite frankly – insane half-decade that the UK has had. But it’s not a rage against the institution, a nihilistic call to arms or a song fighting for a cause. It’s the final salute to the broken horizon as the ship slowly sinks underneath your feet.

The Ultra Vivid Lament isn’t really a COVID album but the weight of the pandemic did affect the album and its writers as well: the title of the record is Wire’s summary of the more intense lockdown periods and how the loneliness and anxiety of so many people became so tangible – vivid – when the world shut down. “Afterending” starts out as a description of the state the UK had found itself in the early 2020s. The European Union HQ in Brussels took down the UK flag as the split from the union was fully realised while civil liberties movements started to draw attention to less positive parts of UK’s history and initiated the removal (whether legal or illegal) of a number of statues dedicated to historic personnel who had risen to power through slave trade and colonial greed. As COVID restrictions became a reality, the daily news feeds were inundated with stories of conservative politicials breaking rules they had set without any repercussions, practically even flaunting their corruption with the dodgy PPE deals set by the government; the genuine im promptu, grassroots-organised act of people publically showing their gratitude to the National Health Service by clapping for them on their balconies and porches soon became taken over and co-opted as means of distraction by the same people who were actively trying to starve off NHS at the time of their biggest need. In just five lines Wire summarises everything going on around him and he doesn’t need to say anything else – the picture is vivid enough and it’s genuinely melancholy. After the first chorus the attention turns from the outside world to inside people’s homes, to the solitude that once felt like a resting place until it became enforced, and to the technology that once gave freedom but suddenly became the only means of communication – and doomscrolling.

Once upon a time this could have resulted in a fiery rant naming names and probably linking those names to dictators and despots from across history, but not in 2021. Everything is too much and given Wire’s open statements about his lack of belief in any major political powers anymore – i.e. most of this very album – he can’t see a way forward either. “Afterending” is a song of quiet and mournful acceptance – that there is no visible light at the end of the tunnel as “the near future has been and gone”. But you can at least find company in someone else during the end, and that’s comforting enough.

“Afterending” may as well be the title track – it is the ultra vivid lament of our times, and whether intentionally or not it brings the rest of the album together with nods to the previous songs. links in with the previous album. “Sail into the abyss with me” echoes the invite to walk together through the apocalypse in “Orwellian”, earlier on the band encouraged to not let the night divide us as we now “enter into a night of nothingness” – if you really want to stretch it then “painting portraits of our loneliness” could be wink towards the painter siblings of “The Secret He Had Missed” but it’s more realistically simply a phrase to describe the number of social media posts and memes elaborately describing the weird times people found themselves in. It brings the album to a rest not with a bang or even a sigh, but a kind of melancholy serenity. It puts in overt words what the rest of the album often only glances at, provides the context to everything that came before and thus appropriately closes the circle as the record ends. It’s the first time where a Manics album closer feels so overtly like a summary of what came before – even something like “Cardiff Afterlife”, which also tackled directly something the rest of the album was inspired by but avoided saying outright, didn’t feel like it quite closed the book as effectively in its themes as “Afterending” does.

Maybe the combination of that oddly calming acceptance and the summation of everything before it is what makes “Afterending” so powerful. My first listen of the album was through the headphones of the flat I lived back then, with my chair turned towards giant glass windows facing what used to be a busy motorway; and even as the worst lockdowns had ceased, that urban stretch was still like a ghost town compared to how it used to be. That scenery hit deep when “Afterending” played, and the song quickly established itself as a powerful moment that resonantly depicted where we were in a wider perspective, including mentally. The Manics themselves had been a powerful presence in my life for half my lifetime and while there had been peaks and valleys during those years, I had coincidentally found myself revisiting their works in the run up to the album and rekindled a familiar love with their body of work. “Afterending” and its tone, its deep sadness and almost defiant call for facing the non-existing future together, was – and still is – one of the very few times where I felt like this band who’d been such a lifeline for me were expressing themselves on the same wavelength I was going through on a personal, emotional level.

It’s just absolutely stunning, isn’t it? No grand solos, no bombastic gestures – even the sing-along towards the end feels like a gentle farewell with your established comrades in arms rather than anything that would invite a crowd together from scratch. But it’s gorgeously arranged, poignantly performed and is a downright perfect melody/lyric combo. It is everything the album has been working towards from an emotional perspective and puts it together with a musical language that’s a comfortable evolution of the band during their greatest introspective moments. And it’s personal, and beautifully so. An ultra vivid lament indeed.

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started